Concept
Burden Allocation in Negligence
Plaintiff's burden of proving negligence
Plaintiff's Burden in Negligence
Burden Allocation in Negligence
A negligence suit starts from an uneven assignment of work: the plaintiff must prove the case, and the defendant, at the outset, need prove nothing. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 328A states the rule in its opening words: “In an action for negligence the plaintiff has the burden of proving” the facts the section goes on to list.1 A burden of proof is the duty to establish a fact, together with the penalty for failing to do so, which is a loss on that point. Section 328A places that penalty on the person who sued. Unless a court finds a specific reason to move the burden, a possibility taken up at the end of this chapter, the defendant owes no proof on any question that makes up the plaintiff’s claim.
The burden attaches to each element separately. Negligence requires four: a duty of care, a breach of the applicable standard, a proximate causal link between the breach and the injury, and compensable harm. The plaintiff must establish each by a preponderance of the evidence.2 Strong proof on one element therefore cannot carry weak proof on another.3 A negligence claim is a chain of facts, and the plaintiff must forge every link. The allocation is the same when the defendant is a professional. Negligence is the most common theory of liability in medical malpractice litigation, and the malpractice plaintiff also bears the burden on every element.4
Because the burden sits with the plaintiff, a defendant need not prove that he acted with reasonable care in order to win. He may rest on the weakness of the plaintiff’s proof, since a failure on any one element defeats the claim. Consider the opposite rule. If the defendant had to establish his own care, a plaintiff could open a case with an injury and an accusation, and the defendant would have to prove a negative: that nothing he did fell short in any respect. A court’s power to make one person pay another would then depend on what the defendant could disprove, not on what the plaintiff had shown.
The allocation costs the plaintiff most when the facts are in the defendant’s hands. A customer who slips on a foreign substance in a store can usually say what was on the floor and that it caused her fall. She usually cannot say who put it there or how long it had been there, while the store knows, or can find out, what its employees did. Some courts have responded by moving the burden. In Lanier v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., the Kentucky court held that once the customer shows a foreign substance on the floor and that it caused the fall, the burden shifts to the store to show that its employees neither caused the condition nor had enough time to discover and remove it.5 Other courts, including those deciding Wintersteen v. Food Lion, Inc. and Rallis v. Demoulas Super Markets, Inc., declined to depart from the traditional allocation.6
The two lines of cases disagree about whether the store’s better access to the facts is enough, standing alone, to move the risk of missing proof. Take a customer who proves the substance and the fall it caused, and nothing more. In a traditional jurisdiction she loses, because the gap in proof is hers. Under Lanier, the same customer reaches the same point in the case with the burden now resting on the store, which must come forward with evidence about what its employees did. The facts are identical in both cases; the allocation alone decides who bears the cost of the missing information.
The traditional rule can look harsh, and sometimes it is. Tort law has no rule that injured plaintiffs must always win. A plaintiff wins only by proving every element, and the uncertainty of making that proof generally falls on her.7 She may lose even when the defendant’s fault seems probable to everyone in the courtroom, because suspicion is not evidence.
The rule also does structural work. A plaintiff must connect the defendant’s wrong to her own injury. Without that causal requirement, tort law would no longer be a system of private law that enforces individual rights and their correlative duties. It would become a system of public law that serves a policy such as product safety, with plaintiffs acting as private attorneys general.8
Narrow exceptions do exist, but they are narrow. The fact that a plaintiff sued several defendants and cannot say which one acted carelessly does not by itself move the burden. Shifting it in every such case would be a major change in American tort law, one not even the California court in Summers made, and the burden remains on the plaintiff to prove who caused the harm.9 Circumstantial proof and the exceptions return near the end of this chapter. Until then, assume the plaintiff carries the burden on every element.