Concept
When Compliance Carries More Weight
Scope of the statutory standard and effect of compliance
When Compliance Carries More Weight
A defendant who obeyed every applicable statute and regulation can still be found negligent. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 288C states the default: compliance with a legislative enactment or an administrative regulation does not prevent a finding of negligence where a reasonable person would take additional precautions.1 A corporation can be truly negligent even though it fulfilled the letter of a safety regulation.2 The common-law system accommodates that possibility: state legislatures do not comprehensively prescribe when a defendant is liable, and they act knowing that courts can still hold defendants liable for unreasonable conduct.3
Two doctrines give compliance more force than the default allows, and they work at different levels. Within a negligence or defect claim, a legislature or, rarely, a court can give compliance extra weight, in the extreme by treating it as conclusive. Above the claim, federal preemption asks which lawmaker controls; when federal law does, compliance is a complete defense to the preempted claim.4 Earlier sections showed that a court decides case by case whether to adopt a statute as the standard of care, and that it usually should decline when the statute is obsolete, arcane, trivial, or vague.5 The question now is the defendant's side of the same coin: when does a statute help the defendant more than ordinary evidence would?
Presumptions Favoring Compliance
A legislature can give compliance more weight than a court ordinarily would. Because a corporation sometimes is truly negligent despite obeying a safety regulation, the question would otherwise be argued in scores of cases. A legislature may settle it once with a flat rule: one who obeys a safety regulation issued by an administrative agency may not be held negligent.6 A court could announce the same rule on its own. The alternative open to courts is gentler: compliance may be used as evidence that the defendant was not negligent, without being a hard and fast defense.7
Colorado shows a middle path between those two poles. Its statute creates a rebuttable presumption that a product is not defective if it complied with a federal or Colorado statute or administrative regulation.8 A rebuttable presumption directs the fact-finder to assume the product was sound unless the plaintiff comes forward with proof that overcomes the assumption. The claim survives, but the plaintiff now carries the burden of going forward.
A court occasionally reaches a result close to the flat rule without any statute. The wording of § 288C leaves room for a rare exception. Compliance fails to prevent a finding of negligence where a reasonable person would take additional precautions; where nothing suggests that more care was needed, a court may treat conformity as due care as a matter of law and keep the question from the jury.9
Regulatory status seldom decides a case alone in either direction. A restaurant's failure to obtain an operating license, a drug maker's failure to obtain FDA approval, or an aircraft maker's failure to obtain FAA certification may each bring administrative penalties, but none converts the defendant into an outlaw subject to absolute liability.10 The favorable direction follows the same caution. Compliance becomes weighty through a legislative choice, such as a flat rule or a presumption, or in the rare case where nothing suggests a need for more care.
Federal Preemption
Preemption asks which lawmaker controls, not whether the defendant took enough care. A statute can modify or altogether preempt a common-law tort claim, and the most heavily litigated version of the problem involves federal statutes that arguably preempt state products liability law, whether that law rests on state legislation or on the common law.12 The Supremacy Clause, U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 2, supplies the constitutional footing.13 When a claim is preempted, compliance with the statute provides a complete defense to it, and no jury weighs that compliance against anything.14
Prescription drugs and medical devices supply the standard examples. Comprehensive FDA regulation of prescription drugs is sometimes found to preempt a negligence claim by a patient harmed by the drug.16 In Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc. the Supreme Court held that the FDA's premarket approval process for medical devices preempts state-law claims of defective design and permits tort damages only for claims premised on a violation of FDA regulations.17 In Bruesewitz v. Wyeth LLC the Court held that the National Childhood Injury Vaccine Act preempts state-law design-defect claims, provided there was proper manufacture and warning.18 The two decisions draw the same line. An attack on the federally approved design is preempted, while a claim that the maker violated FDA regulations (Riegel) or failed to manufacture or warn properly (Bruesewitz) remains open.
Preemption is not the only special rule for these products. Under Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability § 6, the manufacturer of a prescription drug or medical device is not liable if a reasonable health care provider, knowing the benefits and risks of the product, would prescribe it.19
Most federal standards displace nothing. Federal statutes and regulations often incorporate measures to assure product safety but rarely provide compensation for the injuries they fail to prevent, and federal law and state common law coexist in a sometimes uncomfortable balance.20 Where no preemption route applies, the ordinary rule holds, and even a defendant in compliance with every statute and regulation may be found negligent.21 Keeping the two doctrines apart prevents two errors: treating federal compliance as automatically ending a suit, and treating a genuine preemption bar as one more fact for the jury.