Concept
The Privilege to Use Force
Defense of property: land and chattels
Defense of Land and Chattels
The Privilege to Use Force
One's interest in the peaceful possession and enjoyment of property justifies a limited self-help privilege against imminent intrusions.1 Restatement (Second) of Torts § 77 sets the limits: an actor is privileged to use reasonable force, not intended or likely to cause death or serious bodily harm, to prevent or terminate another's intrusion upon the actor's land or chattels, if three conditions are met.2 A privilege excuses conduct that would otherwise create liability, and this one excuses what would otherwise be an assault, battery, false imprisonment, or trespass to chattels.3 A possessor who shoves a trespasser off the porch, within those limits, commits no tort against the trespasser.
The next section takes the three conditions in turn. The intrusion must be unprivileged, or the intruder must have intentionally or negligently caused the actor to believe that it is. The actor must reasonably believe that the intrusion can be prevented or terminated only by the force used. And the actor must first have asked the intruder to desist and been ignored, unless the actor reasonably believes that a request would be useless or that substantial harm would be done before it could be made.4
Those conditions presuppose a trigger: there must be an actual intrusion or a threat of immediate interference with the possession.5 Brittany parks her Mercedes, and her former partner Zachary raises a sledgehammer over the hood and says, "I'm going to bash in your hood." Brittany throws one punch and knocks him out cold. Zachary's battery claim fails, because the threat to the car was immediate and Brittany was privileged to use reasonable force to protect her property.6
The privilege is narrower than self-defense because the law ranks the interests differently. The social value of property is considerably less than that of the safety and bodily integrity of human beings, and the privilege is therefore more limited than self-defense.7 That ranking accounts for the ceiling in § 77: the force may not be intended or likely to cause death or serious bodily harm.8
Self-defense is a separate privilege with its own reach. If the intruder threatens bodily harm to the possessor or other occupants, ordinary self-defense rules apply, and the possessor may use whatever defensive force is required, including death or serious bodily harm if the threat is of similar harm.9 Had Zachary swung the sledgehammer at Brittany instead of at her car, her response would be judged under those rules, which reach further than the property privilege does.
Section 77 speaks of the actor's own land or chattels.10 Whether the privilege should extend to protecting another's property is disputed. The Model Penal Code is grounded in the conclusion that there is no adequate reason for limiting the privilege to protect property of others. The narrower approach in many statutes appears to rest on two policy judgments: a mistake about the disputants' respective legal rights is more likely when property interests are involved, and property interests are somewhat less deserving of protection, so violence by strangers to protect them should not be encouraged.11
Like self-defense, the property privilege operates as an affirmative defense, so the burden is on the defendant both to raise it and to prove the facts necessary to establish it.12 In Zachary's suit, Brittany would have to prove the raised sledgehammer, the immediacy of the threat, and the reasonableness of a single punch.
When the proof is clear enough, a justification can end a case before the jury deliberates. In People v. La Voie, a murder prosecution, the trial court granted the defense's motion and directed a verdict of not guilty, concluding that the evidence established a clear case of justifiable homicide.13
A privilege to act does not always carry immunity from paying for the harm. In a dispute over a ship saved at the expense of a dock, the court held that the defendant had a conditional privilege only: although the defendant had done nothing wrong, it was liable for the damage that resulted.14 The property privilege differs in this respect. A possessor who stays within its limits commits no tort against the intruder, and the sections that follow mark where those limits lie.