Concept
Effect of Provocation
Remedies and damages for intentional torts
Effect of Provocation
A plaintiff who provoked the defendant keeps the full compensatory award, but the provocation can cost that plaintiff punitive damages or shrink them. The Restatement (Second) of Torts states both halves: compensatory damages are not diminished because the injured person provoked the tortfeasor, yet the provocation is considered in determining whether punitive damages are allowed and how large they should be.1 Provocation here means an insult, a taunt, or other conduct that helped set off the defendant's wrongful act. The rule governs damages, so it operates only after the plaintiff has proved a tort.
Compensatory damages follow the plaintiff's loss, and provocation leaves the loss where it was. A punch breaks the jaw of someone who taunted the defendant exactly as it breaks a stranger's jaw, and the surgery costs the same. The provocation may explain why the defendant swung, but it does not make the injury any smaller.
Punitive damages follow the defendant's culpability, which is why provocation reaches them. They may be awarded for conduct that is outrageous because of the defendant's evil motive or reckless indifference to the rights of others. In setting the amount, the factfinder may consider the character of the defendant's act, the nature and extent of the harm the defendant caused or intended to cause, and the defendant's wealth.2 Provocation bears on the character of the act and the motive behind it, and a defendant who strikes out in the heat of a taunt may be less culpable than one who attacks a stranger without cause. Compensation is one goal of tort law, but judges have not ranked it above justice, and fault remains the usual basis for liability.3 The rule divides along that line: loss governs the compensatory award, culpability governs the punitive award, and provocation touches only culpability.
Courts generally admit provocation to mitigate punitive damages, and under a minority holding it may also be considered in mitigation of compensatory damages.4 The question whether provocation can reduce compensatory damages is the one raised in Ezzell v. Miranne. On an exam, state the Restatement rule and treat any compensatory reduction as the minority view.
The plaintiff's own negligence is a separate matter, and confusing it with provocation is a common error. Provocation concerns what moved the defendant to act; negligence concerns how carefully the plaintiff guarded against injury. It is standard hornbook law that contributory negligence is not a defense to an intentional tort, so a defendant cannot defend a battery by arguing that the plaintiff was negligent in failing to duck. Almost every jurisdiction has extended the same rule to wanton and willful or reckless conduct.5 The rule has outlasted the retreat from the old all-or-nothing bar, since only four states and the District of Columbia still treat contributory negligence as a complete bar to recovery.6 A Nebraska court explained that when the defendant intends the harm, the difference from the plaintiff's carelessness is one of kind, not merely degree, and the defense has never been extended to intentional torts. It added that the state's apportionment statute allocates noneconomic damages by percentage of negligence.7 Punitive damages also stay whole, because where the defendant's reckless misconduct justifies them they are not reduced under the comparative negligence rule.8
When a stem reports that the plaintiff did something before the injury, sort the conduct first. If the plaintiff taunted or incited the defendant, the compensatory award stands in full, and the provocation becomes an argument against punitive damages or for a smaller sum. If the plaintiff was merely careless about personal safety, as in failing to duck a swing, the carelessness reduces neither the compensatory nor the punitive award for an intentional tort. A complete answer states both halves of the provocation rule and names which kind of plaintiff conduct the facts describe. The usual mistake is to attach a compensatory reduction to either kind.