Concept
Damages in Intentional Torts
Remedies and damages for intentional torts
Remedies for Intentional Torts
Damages in Intentional Torts
An intentional-tort plaintiff can win without proving that she lost anything. To make out a prima facie case she need only show that the defendant intentionally invaded a protected interest. The burden then shifts to the defendant to show justification or excuse, and, unlike in negligence, actual damages need not be proved. If she cannot establish any actual harm, tangible or intangible, she can still receive nominal damages.1
The Restatement (Second) of Torts defines nominal damages as a trivial sum of money awarded to a litigant who has established a cause of action but has not established that he is entitled to compensatory damages.2 The definition makes sense only because some claims are complete before any loss is proved. Most intentional torts are of that kind. They are based on trespass, and the cause of action is complete upon a showing that the protected interest was invaded.3
Negligence and strict liability work the other way. They stem historically from the actions on the case, in which damage is the gist of the action, so proof of damages is an essential part of the plaintiff's claim.4 A negligence plaintiff must plead and prove duty, breach, causation, and actual harm, which usually means physical injury or property damage. Only under unusual circumstances can she recover for emotional distress without physical injury, or for purely economic loss.5 The rule is no harm, no foul, and nominal damages are not recoverable in negligence.6
The difference lies in what the plaintiff must prove to establish liability, not in how a proven injury is valued. Valuing the plaintiff's injuries is integral to the tort system, and the compensatory sum for a given injury does not depend on the theory of liability. A fractured skull costs the defendant the same amount whether a deliberate blow, an act of negligence, or a defectively designed product caused it.7 What the intentional-tort plaintiff gains is access to nominal damages and, where appropriate, punitive damages, even when she cannot prove actual harm.8
Two features of the law explain why intentional torts are built this way. The first is the interest protected. A surgeon who touches anesthetized patients inappropriately has committed battery, and a patient who never realizes it happened can still recover.9 The wrong lies in the invasion, not in the plaintiff's awareness or in a measurable loss. The second is fault. Compensation is one goal of tort law, but courts have not made it the sole basis of liability, and fault remains the most common one.10 Greater blame attaches to intentional misconduct, and the law reflects that by asking only for the invasion.11 A merely careless defendant faces liability only when the carelessness produced actual harm.
On an exam, a fact pattern that stresses the plaintiff's lack of injury or medical bills does not defeat an intentional-tort claim; it shifts the question to which damages are available. The same fact in a negligence problem ends the analysis at the harm element.
The sections that follow turn to what a plaintiff recovers once liability is established. They cover nominal damages first, then compensatory damages for harm to the person, to land, and to chattels, the special rules for converted property, and punitive damages.