Concept
Trespass Versus Nuisance
Trespass to land
Trespass Versus Nuisance
The same neighborly conflict can arise as trespass or as nuisance, and the two torts test it with different questions. Trespass asks whether the defendant intentionally entered, or put something onto, land in the plaintiff's possession. Nuisance asks whether the defendant's activity has substantially interfered with the plaintiff's use and enjoyment of that land.
Under the Restatement (Second) of Torts, a person is subject to liability for trespass, whether or not any legally protected interest is harmed, if he intentionally enters land in another's possession or causes a thing or a third person to do so, remains on the land, or fails to remove a thing he has a duty to remove.1 An intentional entry is actionable even though it harms neither the land nor anything on it.2 The tort protects possession and control, while nuisance protects something else: use and enjoyment of land, which can be impaired without any disturbance of possession.3
A nuisance is a substantial invasion of another's use or enjoyment of property. It is usually continuous, and unlike trespass it requires no physical invasion.4 Traditionally the line followed the kind of intrusion. A direct physical entry, such as a steam boiler lofted onto a neighbor's land, was trespass, and interferences from noise, vibration, or light were nuisance.5 Trespass thus requires an unauthorized direct or immediate intrusion, while nuisance typically involves interference with use and enjoyment over a period of time.6
The sharpest difference appears when the defendant acted intentionally. If the invasion was unintended, liability for trespass and for nuisance is virtually identical. Once the invasion is intentional, trespass joins the other intentional torts, and liability follows without regard to the amount of harm or the reasonableness of the activity. An intentional nuisance, by contrast, is usually subjected to inquiries about reasonableness and amount of harm.7 The rule on mistake shows how far the trespass side of that contrast runs. An entrant who believes, even reasonably, that he owns the land, has consent, or holds some other privilege is still a trespasser unless the possessor's own conduct induced the belief.8 Reasonableness never reaches the scale in trespass, but in nuisance it is the central question. The label therefore matters: unless the plaintiff can show a physical invasion by a tangible thing, the defendant may escape liability for intentional conduct on grounds of reasonableness or amount of harm that would be irrelevant to a trespass.9 The orchid grower whose crop is ruined by a coal-fired power plant's lawful emissions will probably lose in nuisance for exactly this reason, because the plant's importance to the regional economy outweighs the harm.10
Five points of comparison will usually decide which tort a fact pattern invokes:
- Trespass protects possession, while nuisance protects use and enjoyment.11
- Trespass requires a physical entry by a person or thing, while nuisance can rest on noise, vibration, or light with no entry at all.12
- An intentional trespass is actionable without proof of harm, while a nuisance requires a substantial invasion.13
- A trespass may be a single entry, while a nuisance is usually continuous.14
- Trespass involves no weighing of the defendant's conduct, while nuisance weighs the utility of the activity against the harm.15
Three short hypotheticals put the five points to work. Chan, late for a train, deliberately cuts across Pasik's lawn and leaves no mark. Chan has committed a trespass, because the entry was intentional and physical and harm is not an element.16 Now suppose Rowe's stamping press thumps through the night, every night, and Okafor's family cannot sleep. Nothing physical crosses the boundary, and excessive noise alone will not support a trespass action, so the claim is nuisance.17 Okafor must then show a substantial interference and survive the weighing of Rowe's use of the property against the harm.18 The same noise on a single evening, from a one-time party, probably supports neither claim. Nothing physical enters, and when an intrusion is short-lived, nuisance may offer no remedy at all.19
Both torts can continue, but in different senses. A trespass continues for as long as a structure, chattel, or other thing the actor placed on the land stays there after the consent or privilege that justified it has ended.20 Clements leaves a trunk at Kobe's house for the summer and never returns for it. She becomes a trespasser when the agreed time runs out, and the trespass lasts as long as the trunk remains.21 A nuisance continues because the defendant's conduct keeps producing an interference with use and enjoyment.22
Some facts support both torts. A factory that sends particulate emissions onto pastureland and makes grazing impossible may satisfy the elements of nuisance and of trespass, at least in some states.23
Invisible intrusions are the hard case, because they cross the boundary yet cannot be seen. Suppose a smelter knowingly emits chemicals that settle as detectable deposits on a neighboring farm. A modern court may find a trespass, because there is a detectable physical entry that damages the property, and also a nuisance, because the behavior is continuous and interferes with the farmer's use of the land.24 Courts that accept the trespass theory, however, are likely to require proof of actual damage, although traditional trespasses are actionable without it.25 The court in Bradley v. American Smelting and Refining Co. gave the reason: "no useful purpose would be served by sanctioning actions in trespass by every landowner within a hundred miles of a manufacturing plant."26 Trespass has no reasonableness inquiry of its own, so a harm requirement does the screening that balancing does in nuisance.
The courts divide on the theory. Martin v. Reynolds Metals Co. went furthest toward trespass, permitting a rancher whose cattle were harmed by fumes from an aluminum plant to sue on that theory. Some courts that find an intentional trespass then apply a balancing test of reasonableness, harmonizing the two torts by subjecting both to the calculus of intentional nuisance.27 Other courts keep the older line. In Adams v. Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Co. a Michigan appellate court rejected the trend toward finding trespass in pollution cases, insisting on a direct intrusion of a physical, tangible object and leaving unreasonable interference to nuisance.28 A Minnesota court likewise rejected a trespass claim based on pesticide drift particles.29 In Wilson v. Interlake Steel Co. the court held that excessive noise alone will not support a trespass action without some physical invasion or physical damage, and it sent intangible intrusions to nuisance.30 Some courts have characterized airborne gases and particles as a trespass, but most such cases are brought as nuisance.31
The choice of theory has practical consequences. Limitations periods may differ, and trespass usually has the longer one. A short-lived intrusion may find no remedy in nuisance at all. If only nuisance applies, a court may find some level of interference reasonable and therefore not actionable.32 A fact pattern about drifting particles is therefore best answered under both torts. Ask first whether the jurisdiction recognizes a tangible entry by particles and, if it does, whether the plaintiff can show harm.