Concept
Working an Assault Problem
Assault
Working an Assault Problem
Every assault problem turns on the two clauses of Restatement (Second) of Torts § 21(1). The defendant must have acted intending a harmful or offensive contact or an imminent apprehension of one, and the plaintiff must thereby have been put in imminent apprehension of a contact.1 The first clause examines the defendant's aim; the second examines the plaintiff's expectation. An exam seldom says which clause carries the question. It describes a messy incident with several people in it and leaves you to find the element on which the claim holds or breaks.
A fixed sequence protects you from the two costliest shortcuts: inferring liability from the plaintiff's fright and inferring it from the defendant's hostility. Neither fact answers an element, since intent is judged from the defendant's side of the incident and apprehension from the plaintiff's. The order of the steps also follows the way the elements depend on one another. The plaintiff's apprehension deserves attention only after the act is tied to a tortious aim, and imminence matters only after you find that the plaintiff expected a contact.
The steps divide the work unevenly. Step 2 attaches to the act, while steps 3 through 5 attach to each plaintiff. One swing can therefore leave one person with a claim and another with none, depending on what each perceived and whose body each expected to be touched.
Several facts that feel important appear nowhere in the steps. The defendant's motive is irrelevant, because the actor need not be inspired by personal hostility or a desire to offend.8 Fright is not an element either. Apprehension means an expectation of contact, so a plaintiff who is calm, who could easily defend, or who realizes the defendant does not mean to strike still qualifies if the defendant's act puts that plaintiff in apprehension of the contact.9 And a defendant who changes his mind, or whom a bystander stops, cannot undo an assault the plaintiff has already apprehended.10
A threat made partly in words shows the sequence working through time, because the same incident can fail at one moment and succeed at the next.
The farmer meets the intent step from the first shout, because he acted to put the strangers in apprehension of being shot. The claim nonetheless fails at first. With their backs turned, the strangers have only words, and words count only when joined with other acts or circumstances that put the plaintiff in reasonable apprehension of an imminent contact.11 When they turn, the leveled gun supplies the missing circumstance and gives the earlier threat its meaning, and they become aware while the attempt is still under way.12 Whether the gun is loaded does not matter, because the farmer need not have the ability to shoot, only to apparently threaten a shot,13 and a weapon leveled from a few strides away threatens an imminent contact.14 The "stop or" form of the command lets the strangers avoid the shot by obeying, but that option does not defeat the claim.15 Whether the farmer was privileged to defend his property is a separate question, reached only after these elements are met.
A thrown object with several onlookers is the other common exam setting, and it tests whether you run the steps person by person.
Kessler made one deliberate throw aimed at a contact with Lowe, so the intent step is met for the whole incident. The plaintiff-side steps then sort the three people. Lowe perceived nothing before the throw ended, so his claim fails at the awareness step; had the wrench struck him, the claim would have been battery.16 Pak was not Kessler's target, but an act done with the intention of inflicting a contact on a third person makes the actor liable to another who is put in apprehension of such a contact.17 Pak expected the wrench to strike Pak's own person, and a tool spinning through the air a few feet away threatens an imminent contact, so Pak has an assault claim although nothing touched anyone. Ng feared for Lowe, not for Ng's own person, so Ng has no claim.18 Kessler's fury adds nothing to Pak's recovery; the same throw made without ill will, but still aimed at Lowe, would give Pak the same claim.19 One act thus left the person aimed at without a claim, gave the bystander in the line of flight a claim, and gave the distant onlooker none.