Concept
Assault Beside Battery
Assault
Assault Beside Battery
Assault and battery are separate torts, and one incident can produce either or both. A battery is a non-consensual touching that is harmful or offensive. An assault is the placing of the plaintiff in reasonable apprehension of such a touching.1 Awareness is therefore essential to assault and irrelevant to battery, and contact is essential to battery and irrelevant to assault. Either tort may be committed without the other, so each claim has to be tested against its own elements.2
One skating rink shows all three possible outcomes, because only two facts change: what Hennie perceives, and whether the banner lands. In each version Wilson lets a banner fall, aiming for Hennie.
- If Hennie sees the banner coming, cannot get out of the way, and is hit but not injured, she has both claims. Her expectation of the blow as the banner fell is the assault, and the touching when it landed is the battery.3 The familiar club example divides the same way: seeing the club directed at you and fearing it is the assault, and being struck is the battery.4
- If Hennie looks up, sees the banner, and skates to safety, she has an assault claim and nothing more. Her apprehension was complete, and nothing ever touched her.5
- If Hennie never looks up and is simply struck, she has a battery claim and no assault claim. A plaintiff who is kicked while asleep stands in the same position, because the defendant has committed a battery without placing the plaintiff in fear of the contact.6 The club example agrees: a sleeper hit over the head still prevails on battery, but the assault claim lacks the element of fear or apprehension.7
Two common mistakes come from running the torts together. The first is the oft-repeated statement that 'every battery includes an assault,' which appears in decisions such as Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Hill. A historical distinction between the torts lingers in these confusing statements, but the statement is untrue in tort: the kicked sleeper was never put in fear of anything.8 The second mistake treats 'assault' as a synonym for battery or as shorthand for both. A plaintiff who calls a punch from behind an assault has described a battery, because a blow the plaintiff never saw coming produces no apprehension. Use the two terms precisely, and do not follow those who do not.9
Intent is the one element that links the two torts. For assault, the actor must act intending to cause a harmful or offensive contact with the plaintiff or a third person, or an imminent apprehension of such a contact.10 The link also runs the other way. An act done to inflict a harmful contact, or to put the plaintiff in apprehension of a harmful or offensive one, makes the actor liable for battery if an offensive contact in fact results, even though the actor did not intend that contact.11
The customer's lack of any plan to touch the clerk is no defense to the battery claim, because an act done to threaten or to inflict contact makes the actor answerable for the contact that results.12 Since intent does not separate the two torts, a fact pattern that reports a touching calls for the next question of whether the plaintiff perceived it beforehand. A fact pattern that reports a threat calls for the question of whether a touching followed. The answer to one question does not decide the other.
Pleading follows the same split. A single incident often supports both claims, and a complaint recasts the facts in separate counts. In the Romeo and Juliet complaint, the assault count alleges an act (Romeo 'threatened to strike her and shook his fist'), intent ('intentionally'), and resulting fear of a touching ('placing her in fear that he was about to strike her').13