Concept
The Battery Rule
Battery
The Tort of Battery
The Battery Rule
Battery is the remedy for an intentional and unpermitted physical contact with a person's body, brought about by the defendant's affirmative conduct or by an agency the defendant set in motion.1 Section 13 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts compresses that idea into one sentence, and every later section on this page examines a phrase of it. An actor is subject to liability for battery if the actor acts intending to cause a harmful or offensive contact with the person of the other or a third person, or an imminent apprehension of such a contact, and a harmful contact with the person of the other directly or indirectly results.2
The sentence asks two questions. First, what was the defendant trying to bring about when acting? That is the intent half, §13(a). Second, what actually happened to the plaintiff because of the act? That is the result half, §13(b). A plaintiff must win both, and the two can come apart, as the hypothetical below shows.
The intent half looks at purpose. The object of the intent may be a harmful or offensive contact with the plaintiff, the same kind of contact with a third person, or an imminent apprehension of such a contact.3 A defendant who aims at one person and hits another, or who means only to frighten, is therefore within the rule once a harmful contact follows. Those extensions have their own sections below, as does the meaning of intent itself. The court in Wagner v. State described battery as two elements: the contact must have been deliberate, and it must have been harmful or offensive at law. It then held that the actor need not intend the contact to be harmful or offensive, so long as he deliberately made the contact and the contact meets the legal test for harmful or offensive.4 The Restatement's wording speaks of intending a harmful or offensive contact, a tension the sections on single versus dual intent take up.
The result half requires that a harmful contact with the plaintiff's person actually occur. It is satisfied whether the contact comes directly or indirectly,5 so a defendant who sets some other force in motion is as exposed as one who strikes with a hand.6 Modern cases allow recovery when an intentionally inflicted contact is not direct and immediate but indirect.7
Section 13 speaks only of harmful contacts, yet a person can be invaded without being hurt, and §18 supplies the twin rule. Section 18(1) repeats the intent clause word for word and then requires that an offensive contact with the person of the other directly or indirectly result.8 A bodily contact is offensive if it offends a reasonable sense of personal dignity.9 A plaintiff who proves the intent half and either kind of contact has made out a battery.
Because the intent half is required, modern battery is exclusively an intentional tort. There is no battery when a defendant negligently, or even recklessly, drives a car into the plaintiff and injures the plaintiff without intending to hit anyone, as in Cook v. Kinzua Pine Mills Co.10 Section 18(2) says the same about offensive contacts: an act not done with the §18(1)(a) intent does not make the actor liable for a mere offensive contact, even though the act carried an unreasonable risk of it.11 The defendant's state of mind therefore decides which tort applies, because a collision can injure as badly as a punch.
The two halves reflect what the tort protects. Battery vindicates the basic right to have one's body left alone by others, and it secondarily deters relatively minor but offensive contacts that can precipitate breaches of the peace.12 That second purpose explains why an offensive contact that leaves no mark can still be a battery. A right to be left alone also means the contact must be unpermitted: the usual summary of the tort speaks of unconsented-to, harmful or offensive contact with the person of another, caused with intent to produce either bodily contact or the apprehension of it.13
The tort's history shows the same concern with protecting the body. Medieval England, from which our tort law evolved, answered physical aggression with a criminal remedy, the appeal of felony. A guilty defendant was fined, which helped enforce the King's peace but did nothing to compensate the injured victim.14 Battery, in contrast, is the touched person's own claim. In Cole v. Turner, decided in 1704, Chief Justice Holt declared that the least touching of another in anger is a battery. He added that two people who meet in a narrow passage and touch gently, without violence or design of harm, commit none, while one who uses violence to force his way through in a rude, inordinate manner does.15 What separates the cases is the character of the touch, not the size of the injury.