Concept
Why a Threshold Exists
Threshold: act, volition, and intent
Act, Volition, and Intent
Why a Threshold Exists
Every intentional-tort claim must clear a threshold before the elements of the particular tort come into play: the defendant must have acted voluntarily, and the defendant must have acted with intent. Two drivers show where that line falls.
The first driver clears the threshold. The second acted voluntarily too, but a voluntary act is only half of the test. A driver who looks away from the road and collides with a pedestrian acts voluntarily, and so does a joker who throws a snowball at a tree when a pedestrian unexpectedly steps into its path. Neither acts with the state of mind an intentional tort requires, which is purpose, or substantial certainty, that a harmful or offensive contact will result.1
Intent, in the restricted sense peculiar to tort law,2 means what the Restatement says it means: the actor desires to cause the consequences of the act, or believes that those consequences are substantially certain to result from it.3 The first driver desired the contact. The second wanted nothing of the sort and did not believe it substantially certain.
The definition centers on the desire to cause certain immediate consequences. One who throws a rock with great force against a glass window intends that it break, and one who points a loaded gun at another and pulls the trigger intends that the bullet strike and injure him. The reason for acting is a different matter. Revenge, protest, theft, self-defense, even a wish to help may aggravate, mitigate, or excuse the wrong: malice may support punitive damages, and self-defense may be a complete defense. None of those motives is the intent the threshold measures.4
The threshold has historical roots. As to physical harm, the old actions of trespass and case came to be separated not by whether the harm was direct or indirect, but by whether the tort fit the traditional trespass categories (battery, assault, false imprisonment, trespass to land and chattels) or involved mere negligence, for which case was the usual remedy. At the same time, courts began requiring fault as an element of the trespass action, meaning some sort of wrongful intent. The trespass actions became what we now call the intentional torts.5 Negligence stayed on one side of that line, and the torts built on wrongful intent stayed on the other.
Today's intentional-tort claim demands little of the plaintiff beyond that intent. To establish a prima facie case, the plaintiff need only prove that the defendant intentionally invaded a protected interest. The burden then shifts to the defendant to show justification or excuse. Unlike a negligence plaintiff, the intentional-tort plaintiff need not prove actual damages, and if no actual harm, tangible or intangible, can be shown, nominal damages can still be awarded.6 Intent is what keeps so light a claim tied to fault.
The other half of the threshold rests on a simpler idea: there cannot be an act without volition. A knee jerk, a blink in defense against an approaching missile, the convulsive movements of an epileptic, and movements of the body during sleep are no acts of the person whose body moves. Nor does a defendant act when a third person uses the defendant's body as an instrument to carry out the third person's own intention to harm the plaintiff. In that case the third person is the actor.7
Two standards describe how far intent must reach, a single-intent standard and a dual-intent standard, and the chapter returns to them later. In many and perhaps most cases the choice does not matter, because defendants have both intents. In a few cases, the indifferent or oblivious defendant is liable under the single-intent standard but not under the dual-intent standard. Even under the single-intent standard, however, there is no liability unless the contact actually turns out to be harmful or offensive.8
The rest of the chapter takes the threshold in order: the voluntary act, the definition of intent and the consequence it must reach, the arguments defendants raise about motive, mistake, youth, and mental illness, and finally the application of the threshold to facts.