Concept
The Three Knowledge Elements
Limitation on secured party's liability
The Three Knowledge Elements
Section 9-628(a)(1) relieves a secured party of liability for failing to comply with Article 9, and the relief runs in two directions: to the person itself, and to any secured party or lienholder that has filed a financing statement against that person.1 The relief is conditional. It turns on what the secured party knew about the person, and that knowledge has three parts: that the person is a debtor or obligor, who the person is, and how to communicate with the person. The prior section stated the test as one rule. On an exam, the three parts have to be taken one at a time, because a fact pattern usually supplies some of them and withholds the rest.
The parts are cumulative. The secured party loses the shield only when it knows all three, so lacking any one keeps the protection in place, and knowing two of the three does not defeat it. One kind of knowledge cannot substitute for another:
- A secured party holds a person's name and mailing address but has no reason to think the person has any stake in the transaction. It lacks the first element, and the address does not help.
- A secured party knows that a debtor exists but cannot say who the debtor is. It lacks the second element.
- A secured party knows that a person has a stake and who the person is, but has no way of reaching the person. It lacks the third element.
In each case the shield holds. The structure makes practical sense. A duty owed to a particular person can be performed only by a party that knows the person has a stake, knows who the person is, and knows where to direct the communication.
The working method follows. For each person who claims a violation, ask the three questions in turn: Did the secured party know this person was a debtor or obligor? Did it know who the person was? Did it know how to communicate with the person? A "no" to any one ends the inquiry in the secured party's favor. Only three "yes" answers take the shield away. The next three subsections take the elements in order, beginning with knowledge of debtor or obligor status, then identity, then the means of communication.