Concept
Who May Recover Damages
Remedies for secured party's noncompliance
Who May Recover Damages
Section 9-625(c)(1) names the people who may sue: a person that, at the time of the failure, was a debtor, was an obligor, or held a security interest in or other lien on the collateral may recover damages under subsection (b) for its loss.1 Subsection (b) makes a noncomplying person liable for the loss its failure causes, but liability needs a claimant, and paragraph (c)(1) defines the claimants by the position each held when the failure occurred. The Part 6 duties are what a failure breaches. One of them requires that every aspect of a disposition, including its method, manner, time, place, and other terms, be commercially reasonable.2
Subsection (c) begins by yielding to § 9-628, which shields a secured party from liability in some circumstances, including liability to unknown persons and under circumstances that would not let the secured party protect itself.3 That shield belongs to another reading. For now, the three classes below mark the outer boundary of eligibility, and § 9-628 can narrow it.
The list reaches beyond the debtor because a defective sale injures more people than the debtor. The price the collateral brings is one pool of money, and a shortfall in that pool falls on every person whose position depends on it. If only the debtor could sue, a guarantor facing a larger deficiency or a junior lienholder shut out of the proceeds would have to rely on a debtor who has already lost the collateral and may have little reason to complain. Giving each affected position its own right lets the people actually injured enforce the Part 6 duties themselves.
The three classes track the three ways a low price or a skipped step does damage:
- A debtor loses through a larger deficiency or a smaller surplus.
- An obligor, meaning a person who owes payment or other performance of the secured obligation, such as a guarantor, loses through the larger deficiency it may have to pay.
- A holder of a security interest in or other lien on the collateral, such as a junior lienholder, loses through the smaller proceeds available to satisfy its lien.
Qualifying under paragraph (c)(1) opens the door, and subsection (b) still governs what passes through it. The paragraph allows recovery for the claimant's own loss, so each claimant must prove its own harm and its own causal link, as the earlier discussion of damages required. A guarantor that would have owed the same deficiency after a fully compliant sale has the right status and no loss, and it recovers nothing.
The classes also fix where eligibility ends. An unsecured trade creditor owed money by the debtor has no lien on the collateral and no obligation tied to it, so it fits none of the three classes, even if it believes the defective sale weakened the debtor's finances. Its position rests on the debtor's overall solvency, which the Part 6 duties for handling collateral do not protect. Students often treat anyone hurt by the sale as a claimant. The test looks at the claimant's status, and economic injury without a qualifying status gives no damages claim.
The status must also exist at one moment: the time of the failure. The failure is the event that injures, so the right belongs to someone who stood in a position to be harmed by it. A person who acquires an interest afterward finds the conduct already complete and has no claim for what happened before it arrived.
This standing rule is wider than the consumer-goods minimum covered in the next section. Paragraph (c)(2) gives its fixed minimum recovery only to a person that was a debtor or a secondary obligor at the time of the failure, and only where the collateral is consumer goods.4 A junior lienholder therefore qualifies under paragraph (c)(1) to recover the loss it can prove, but it cannot claim the statutory floor.