Concept
Damages for Noncompliance
Remedies for secured party's noncompliance
Damages for Noncompliance
Section 9-625(b) turns a violation into a money claim: subject to subsections (c), (d), and (f), a person is liable for damages in the amount of any loss caused by a failure to comply with Article 9.1 A claimant must therefore show three things: a failure to comply, a loss, and a causal link from the failure to the loss. The measure is the loss itself, so subsection (b) pays for harm and not for the violation as such.
The second sentence of subsection (b) names one kind of loss. Loss caused by a failure to comply may include loss resulting from the debtor's inability to obtain, or increased costs of, alternative financing.2 Suppose a secured party fails to comply with a requirement of Article 9, and the debtor, needing replacement credit, is turned down by a second lender or accepts a loan at a higher rate. Both the refusal and the added cost are losses of the kind the statute describes, provided the failure caused them. If the second lender would have refused for reasons unrelated to the secured party's conduct, the causal link is missing and the loss is not recoverable. Because the text says "may include," alternative-financing loss is a named example and not the only category.
Subsection (c) identifies who may claim. A person that, at the time of the failure, was a debtor, was an obligor, or held a security interest in or other lien on the collateral may recover damages under subsection (b) for its loss.3 The test looks to a claimant's status when the failure occurred, so later changes in who holds the collateral or the obligation do not decide the question. The next section takes up this standing rule in detail.
Subsection (c) also puts a floor under recovery in consumer-goods cases. If the collateral is consumer goods, a person that was a debtor or a secondary obligor at the time a secured party failed to comply with Part 6 may recover in any event an amount not less than the credit service charge plus 10 percent of the principal amount of the obligation, or the time-price differential plus 10 percent of the cash price.4 A consumer-goods debtor who cannot prove a large loss, or any loss, still has this statutory minimum. The loss measure of subsection (b) remains the baseline, and the floor supplements it.
Because subsection (b) is made subject to subsections (c), (d), and (f), it never operates alone. Subsection (c) supplies the standing rule and the consumer-goods minimum discussed above. Subsections (d) and (f) are developed in the later sections on deficiency offsets and double recovery and on requests under § 9-210. Any damages analysis under § 9-625 therefore starts with subsection (b) and then asks which of those provisions limits or supplements the recovery.