Concept
The Reasonableness Standard
Commercially reasonable disposition
Commercially Reasonable Dispositions
The Reasonableness Standard
A secured party that disposes of collateral after default must do so in a commercially reasonable way, and the duty reaches every step of the sale. Section 9-610(b) requires that every aspect of the disposition, including the method, manner, time, place, and other terms, be commercially reasonable.1 The sentence comes directly from former § 9-504, so most cases decided under the old section remain good law after the 1999 revision. The comments to § 9-610 and the text of § 9-627 modify those cases only in limited ways.2 The cases are numerous. Hundreds of reported opinions, many of them older than the revision but still good authority, interpret the sentence, and they make dismal reading for the secured creditor. They seem an endless repetition of Murphy’s Law: anything that can go wrong, will go wrong.3
Debtors rarely sue over method or timing as such; they sue over price. The dispute between debtor and creditor is almost never about some “aspect of the disposition.” It is about the price, which the debtor thinks was too low.4 Price matters because it fixes the deficiency, the balance the debtor still owes after the sale. The deficiency judgment is inversely proportional to the sale price: a high price yields a low judgment, and vice versa.5 Yet a low price is not itself a reason to find a disposition unreasonable.6 That gap explains the shape of the statute. The tests of method, manner, time, place, and terms are really proxies for “insufficient price,” and their importance lies almost exclusively in the extent to which they protect against an unfairly low price.7 A debtor who cannot win on the number alone attacks the way the creditor reached it.
Courts say as much. In Hall v. Owen County State Bank, the court called the price received one of the most important factors in deciding whether a sale was commercially reasonable. When a fair price was received, the debtor has suffered no injury and normally has no complaint, except perhaps where the debtor could have found alternate financing and redeemed the collateral. When a fair price was not received, the other aspects of the sale matter to the extent they may have prevented a fair price or contributed to an unfair one.8
Those other aspects are concrete. The creditor must properly advertise or take other proper measures to find the best market and the best buyers. Advertising a drilling rig in the county newspaper will not do where everyone else would use the trade journals. Timing can pull against publicity, because a speedy sale is the first requirement, yet the best advertising medium may publish only biweekly or monthly. Delay justified by the need to advertise, or by other good reasons, should be memorialized so the creditor can prove those reasons later at a deficiency trial.9
Within the duty, the creditor has wide freedom of method. If commercially reasonable, a secured party may dispose of collateral by public or private proceedings, by one or more contracts, as a unit or in parcels, and at any time and place and on any terms.10 The public or private proceeding may even be conducted over the Internet.11 Freedom of method is the starting point, and commercial reasonableness limits every choice. The debtor cannot waive the duty, which § 9-602(7) lists among the nonwaivable rights and duties, and variation by agreement is a separate matter under § 1-302.12
The statute does not say what commercially reasonable requires. In Hall, the court found the statutory definition vague and observed that the answer depends on the circumstances of each particular case, which is why many courts treat reasonableness as a question of fact.13 Another court reached the same result: because the standard cannot be measured with a bright-line test, each sale is judged case by case. The question is whether the circumstances of the sale and the manner and business context in which it occurred support a conclusion that the sale was conducted in a commercially reasonable manner.14 A dictionary gloss captures the flavor of the standard: a sale conducted in good faith and in accordance with commonly accepted commercial practice.15 Because the benchmark is practice rather than a fixed procedure, the same step may be reasonable in one setting and unreasonable in another.
The cases on the failing side show the standard at work. In Pioneer Dodge, an automobile dealer repossessed a truck, took it to a few other local car dealers for oral bids, and placed it on its own sales lot for a few days. Immediately before beginning, it announced over its loudspeaker that the truck would be sold at auction. The appellate court reversed the finding that this public sale was commercially reasonable, declaring that “[i]t is fundamental that a public sale presupposes posting public notices or advertising.”16
The two sales differ in the effort each creditor made to reach buyers. The consequences of falling short explain why creditors care. A sale that is not commercially reasonable can reduce or eliminate the obligor’s liability for any deficiency.17 If the secured party fails to prove compliance, a presumption arises that the debtor is damaged by the amount claimed in the deficiency action. To recover any deficiency, the creditor must then rebut the presumption by showing that the debtor’s damages were less than the deficiency.18
Because the standard is open-ended and fact-bound, a creditor cannot know before it sells whether a court will approve its choices. Section 9-627 narrows that uncertainty. Subsection (a) provides that the possibility of a greater amount at a different time or by a different method does not alone preclude a showing of commercial reasonableness. Later subsections identify categories of dispositions that are deemed commercially reasonable, and everything outside those categories is judged on its circumstances.19 The sections that follow take up those categories, beginning with the weight price carries.