Concept
Nature of Redemption
Right to redeem collateral
Redeeming Collateral After Default
Nature of Redemption
Section 9-623 lets a debtor, any secondary obligor, and any other secured party or lienholder redeem collateral.1 The Code never defines redeem, so the term carries its traditional meaning: the right to free the collateral from any lien or encumbrance and regain absolute title by paying the amount due.2 A party who redeems takes the collateral back clear of the security interest.
The payment is what separates redemption from curing a default. A cure catches up missed installments. Redemption requires a tender of fulfillment of all obligations the collateral secures, which ends the lien (§ 9-623(b)(1)).3 If the agreement accelerates the whole balance on default, the whole balance must be tendered. The redeemer must also pay certain expenses and, if the security agreement provides for them and the law does not prohibit them, reasonable attorney's fees and legal expenses.4 Local consumer statutes may allow a consumer debtor merely to bring the debt current, so check them before applying the general rule.5
The usual exam error is to treat a tender of the overdue amount as a redemption. When a debtor demands the collateral back, the amount tendered is the first fact to check.
The right survives default because foreclosure exists to pay the debt, not to enrich the creditor. In Indianapolis Morris Plan Corp. v. Karlen the court put the principle plainly: at no time before or after default may the creditor take the collateral for the debt and thereby forfeit the debtor's surplus value or equity in it.6 The case was decided under the earlier version of Article 9, so it explains the purpose of the right, and § 9-623 governs the details taught below.
The right does not last forever. It must be exercised before the secured party has disposed of the collateral or entered into a contract for its disposition under § 9-610, and before the obligation has been discharged under § 9-622 by the secured party retaining the collateral in satisfaction of the debt.7 Acceptance in satisfaction cuts off the debtor's chance to pay and keep the collateral because it transfers to the secured party all of the debtor's rights in the collateral.8 The Code sets no fixed period after foreclosure or sale during which redemption remains available, which departs from some real estate law and pre-Code secured transactions law.9
The rest of this chapter takes up three questions in the order the statute asks them. Who may redeem? Section 9-623(a) names the debtor, the secondary obligor, and other secured parties and lienholders. What must be tendered? Section 9-623(b) requires the secured debt plus certain expenses and, when the agreement provides for them, attorney's fees. Until when? Section 9-623(c) ties the cutoff to the secured party's collection, disposition, or acceptance of the collateral. The chapter then turns to when the right can be waived and ends with a single analysis sequence.