Concept
Authority to Dispose of Collateral
Including secured party’s right to take possession and dispose of collateral (§§ 9-608 through 9-624)
Authority to Dispose of Collateral
Taking possession is only the first step, and UCC § 9-610 governs what the secured party may do next: after default, it may sell, lease, license, or otherwise dispose of any or all of the collateral in its present condition or following any commercially reasonable preparation or processing.1 The sentence answers three questions. When does the power arise? After default. What may the secured party do? Dispose of the collateral in any of those ways. In what condition may the collateral go? As it stands, or after commercially reasonable preparation or processing. Nothing in the sentence makes a judgment or court order a precondition, which fits the policy of the resale provisions: to allow realization on collateral with a minimum of resort to judicial proceedings, and to encourage higher yields by allowing private as well as public sale.2
The power turns on default, and the security agreement is where default gets defined. A secured party may not take default action unless an event of default set forth in the security agreement has occurred, and acting without one may expose it to liability to the debtor.3 A lender that sells collateral belonging to a debtor who is current and in compliance therefore has no authority to sell. Worry about the debtor's business does not change that. Even where the agreement lets the lender act when it feels insecure, the test is whether the lender in good faith believes that its ability to collect is impaired due to circumstances arising after the loan was made.4 A default can also be waived. A secured party that accepts a late payment may waive that default, and may even be estopped from enforcing a later default when the debtor pays late again.5
Once a default exists, the secured party's choice of transaction is wide. It may dispose of collateral by public or private proceedings, by one or more contracts, as a unit or in parcels, and at any time and place and on any terms, provided every aspect is commercially reasonable.6 The statute names sale, lease, and license, and the range suits the assets that get pledged: a forklift is naturally sold, a vehicle may be leased, and software is licensed rather than sold. The private option matters too. Creditors know that sales may need to be done quickly, usually in wholesale markets, and sometimes in markets that are plainly inefficient, such as the courthouse steps.7 Letting the secured party sell privately as well as publicly is one way the statute tries to improve on those yields.8
The phrase 'any or all of the collateral' matters because some collateral cannot be picked up. The power covers intangibles such as accounts as well as repossessed goods.9 A bank financing a florist shows the difference. To sell the flowers and plants, the bank must first get possession. It may take them by self-help if the debtor does not object, but if the debtor objects it must bring a replevin action, because repossessing over objection risks liability for conversion.10 The amounts customers owe the florist require no possession. Collecting from those customers is one route, but the bank could also sell the accounts to a buyer through the disposition process, which then demands notice, commercial reasonableness, and application of the proceeds under UCC § 9-615.11
The last phrase of the rule gives the secured party a choice about the collateral's condition: dispose of it as it stands, or prepare or process it first.12 Each path has a cost. Selling as-is saves expense and delay but may draw a lower price from buyers who must allow for needed repairs. Preparation may raise the price, but the reasonable expenses of preparing for disposition come out of the cash proceeds, so every dollar spent on refurbishing reduces what remains to pay the secured obligation.13 Unless otherwise agreed, the debtor is liable for any resulting deficiency, which gives the debtor good reason to scrutinize the spending.14 That is why the statute limits preparation to what is commercially reasonable, and why the choice between selling as-is and preparing first is itself part of the method and manner of the disposition that must be commercially reasonable.15
Although the statute says 'may,' disposition is sometimes the only course open. It is required in certain consumer-goods situations, and it is required when the debtor does not consent, or a person entitled to object does, to a proposal that the secured party keep the collateral in satisfaction of the debt.16 The debtor consents to such a proposal by agreeing to its terms in a record authenticated after default, or by failing to object within 20 days after the secured party sends it; silence, however, is not consent to an acceptance in partial satisfaction.17 In these cases disposition protects the debtor's equity, because the secured party must account to the debtor for any surplus.18
A power this broad, exercised without a judge, needs counterweights, because the secured party both runs the sale and collects from it. Three rules supply them, and the sections that follow take each in turn. First, every aspect of the disposition, including method, manner, time, place, and other terms, must be commercially reasonable.19 The debtor and obligor may agree to standards for measuring that reasonableness, but only if the standards are not manifestly unreasonable.20 Second, the secured party must send a reasonable authenticated notification of disposition to the specified persons unless an exception applies.21 For consumer goods those persons are the debtor and secondary obligors. For other goods they also include anyone who has told the secured party of a claim in the goods, and secured parties of record at least ten days before the notice is sent.22 Third, the secured party must apply the cash proceeds in the statutory order, which begins with its reasonable expenses of retaking, holding, preparing for disposition, processing, and disposing.23