Concept
Other Collateral and Demand
Termination statement (§ 9-513)
Other Collateral and Demand
Filing is the ordinary way to perfect a security interest in personal property, which is why the rules for ending a filing matter as much as the rules for making one.1 For consumer goods, subsection (a) makes termination the secured party’s own obligation once its conditions are met.2 Subsection (c) governs everything else: in cases that subsection (a) does not govern, the secured party must send or file a termination statement within 20 days after it receives a signed demand from the debtor, if a listed condition exists.3 Two ideas organize this unit. With collateral other than consumer goods, the debtor has to ask. And whether the request works depends on what the financing statement protects: an ordinary loan, a purchase of receivables, or a consignment. The first subsection follows the demand through an ordinary loan, and the second takes up the receivables and consignment exceptions.
Demand Requirement
Under § 9-513(c), the debtor’s signed demand is the event that starts the secured party’s duty. Within 20 days after receiving that demand, the secured party must cause the secured party of record either to send the debtor a termination statement or to file one in the filing office, provided a listed condition exists.4 The commentary describes the same sequence from the debtor’s side: the debtor may demand a termination statement when it believes the secured debt is paid and the transaction is at an end, and the secured party then has twenty days to send it or file it.5 A secured party that has received no demand has no duty to do either, however long the financing statement has outlasted the loan, because the 20 days run only from receipt of a demand.
Three details of the demand decide most problems. The text calls for a signed demand, and the 20 days run from the secured party’s receipt of it, not from the day the debtor wrote it or the day the loan was paid. The demand also starts the period without creating the duty by itself, because the secured party owes something only if a listed condition exists, so a debtor who demands termination while the loan is unpaid has asked for something the secured party need not supply. And the vocabulary has shifted: the current text says “signed,” while the commentary and the case discussed below use the term “authenticated demand.”
A secured party that receives a proper demand and faces a listed condition has two ways to comply, and they leave the public record in different places. Filing the termination statement itself changes the record. Sending the statement to the debtor does what subsection (c) asks and leaves the filing to the debtor.6 A form in the mail changes nothing of record, because a financing statement is rendered ineffective by the filing of a termination statement.7 A secured party that sends the form within the 20 days has therefore done what the subsection requires, even if the debtor never files it.
The condition that fits an ordinary secured loan is the payoff condition, and it has two halves: no obligation secured by the collateral covered by the financing statement remains, and no commitment to make an advance, incur an obligation, or otherwise give value remains.8 It repeats the test applied to consumer goods.9 Both halves must hold. A secured party still committed to make future advances owes no termination statement even though nothing is presently due.10 The same provision carves out accounts and chattel paper that have been sold and goods that are the subject of a consignment, and those exceptions belong to the next subsection.
AEG Liquidation Trust v. Toobro N.Y. LLC shows what happens when no duty ever arises. The court noted that AEG never sent a termination statement to the debtors, that the debtors never sent AEG an authenticated demand for one, and that no termination statement was filed by the debtor, with or without AEG’s authorization, after the Settlement Agreement, so nothing had rendered AEG’s financing statements ineffective.11 Under the text of subsection (c), the missing demand was enough by itself: without a demand, the 20-day period never begins, and the secured party has nothing to send or file.
The second step is where consumer-goods habits mislead. A fact pattern in which a business pays off its loan and then does nothing shows no violation by the secured party, because its duty has not begun until a demand is received.
Sold Receivables and Consignments
Section 9-513(c)(1) states the payoff condition, but it opens with an exception: the no-secured-obligation, no-commitment test applies “except in the case of a financing statement covering accounts or chattel paper that has been sold or goods that are the subject of a consignment.”13 The commentary lists the replacement grounds in (c)(2) through (c)(4): sold accounts or chattel paper whose obligor has discharged its obligation, consigned goods that are no longer in the debtor’s possession, and an initial financing statement the debtor did not authorize.14
The exception exists because, in these arrangements, the filing does not protect a loan that will be repaid. A buyer of accounts or chattel paper files to give notice of its interest in the right to collect from the people who owe on them. Accounts are rights to payment, and chattel paper combines a customer’s promise to pay with a security interest in, or lease of, specific goods, as in an installment contract for a car. The seller ordinarily owes the buyer no loan balance for the filing to secure, so a payoff test could be met at once, while the buyer is still waiting to be paid, and terminating then would remove the notice while uncollected receivables remain with the buyer. Subsection (c)(2) therefore looks to the customer’s side of the transaction: the duty arises when the financing statement covers accounts or chattel paper that has been sold and the account debtor or other person obligated has discharged its obligation.15
The phrase “other person obligated” reaches the obligor on chattel paper, such as the installment purchaser, and discharge means the obligation has been satisfied, usually by payment. The debtor in this arrangement is the seller of the accounts, and its signed demand starts the 20 days. Because the text asks about the obligated person’s side, a fact pattern describing what seller and buyer have settled between themselves does not answer the question.
Consignment follows the same logic with a different event. A consignment is a delivery of goods to a merchant who is to sell them for the owner, and the owner’s filing warns those who deal with the merchant that goods in its possession may belong to someone else. The filing does its work while the goods sit with the consignee. Subsection (c)(3) accordingly makes the demand effective when the financing statement covers goods that were the subject of a consignment to the debtor but are not in the debtor’s possession.16 On its face the trigger asks only about possession of the goods, and it says nothing about payment of any amount.
These two triggers, together with the ordinary payoff condition and the ground for an unauthorized initial filing, are the conditions that give a debtor’s demand force when the collateral is not consumer goods.17 Because each exception swaps in a different question, the analysis begins by sorting the filing according to what it protects.
A fact pattern that reports a zero balance owed to the secured party therefore does not settle a sold-accounts or consignment problem. The question there is whether the account debtor has paid or whether the goods have left the debtor’s possession, and the ordinary payoff test is the wrong tool for either.