Concept
Limits on Notification
Discharge of the account debtor and effect of notification
Limits on Notification
A notification can be signed, can announce the assignment, and can identify the rights assigned, and the account debtor may still keep its freedom to pay the assignor. Section 9-406(b) lists the situations in which a notification is ineffective under subsection (a), and the list operates subject to subsections (h) and (l).1 Subsection (a) supplies the baseline that the list qualifies: an account debtor on an account, chattel paper, or a payment intangible may discharge its obligation by paying the assignor until it receives a notification, signed by the assignor or the assignee, that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee. After receipt, it may discharge the obligation only by paying the assignee.2 The identification requirement taught earlier is one entry on the list, because a notice must reasonably identify the rights assigned.3 This section covers two more entries: the notification that asks for less than a full installment, and the notification that concerns a sold payment intangible.
The account debtor's rights against an assignee come from three places: the terms of the assigned contract, the rules of Article 9 (including §§ 9-401 through 9-409), and other law governing assignment of that type of obligation.4 The two limits below draw on different sources. The partial-payment option is an Article 9 rule that the account debtor cannot waive or vary. The payment-intangible exception depends on the account debtor's own agreement and on law outside Article 9. Both leave the account debtor where subsection (a) found it before any notice: free to pay the assignor and be discharged. When a problem pairs a clear, signed notification with a payment to the assignor, run through these limits before concluding that the account debtor lost.
Partial Assignments
Section 9-406(b)(3) lets an account debtor disregard a notification that asks it to split a payment. A notification is ineffective, at the account debtor's option, if it tells the account debtor to pay the assignee less than the full amount of any installment or other periodic payment.5 The consequence runs through subsection (a). The cut-off on paying the assignor arrives only with a notification of the kind that subsection describes, so an account debtor that treats a partial notice as ineffective may keep paying the assignor and still be discharged.6
The option spares the account debtor the work of dividing each installment among payees. The paradigm notice asks for everything: the notice a secured party sends to collect on collateral must require the account debtor to pay the secured party the entire obligation it owes the debtor.7 A notification that directs the full installment to the assignee never triggers the option, because it does not ask for less.8 If it meets the other requirements, it ends the account debtor's freedom to pay the assignor.9
The choice belongs to the account debtor alone.10 An account debtor whose payables system handles split payments easily may honor a partial notice and pay each party its share. One that finds the arrangement burdensome may disregard the notice and keep paying the assignor. Either way, an assignee that holds only part of a payment stream cannot count on a notification to redirect anything. It must rely on the account debtor's willingness.
The statute forecloses three arguments that a partial notice binds automatically. The option applies even if only a portion of the account, chattel paper, or payment intangible has been assigned to that assignee, even if a portion has been assigned to another assignee, and even if the account debtor knows that the assignment to that assignee is limited.11 The tempting argument runs that a limited assignment makes the notice accurate, so an account debtor that knows the facts has no reason to doubt it. But the trigger is the shape of the demand, which is payment of less than the full installment. That demand looks the same whether the assignment is genuine, whether other assignees share the stream, and whether the account debtor has been told so. Knowing how the receivable is carved up gives the account debtor information, and it does not oblige the account debtor to administer the carving.
The option would mean little if the account debtor could surrender it in advance, and subsection (g) closes that door. Subject to subsections (h) and (l), an account debtor may not waive or vary its option under subsection (b)(3).12 Without that bar, an assignor could write the waiver into the original contract, and the protection would vanish for every account debtor that signed it. The words 'waive or vary' reach both an outright surrender and a clause that narrows the option. They do not stop an account debtor from deciding, when a particular notification arrives, to pay as directed. That decision exercises the option and does not waive it.
Students usually err in one of two directions. The first reasons that the assignee holds a valid partial assignment, the account debtor knows it, and the notice therefore binds. The three 'even if' clauses answer that reasoning, and the account debtor's payment to the assignor discharges the debt.13 The second error treats a partial notice as void. It is ineffective only at the account debtor's option, so an account debtor that honors it pays the assignee as directed.
Sold Payment Intangibles
A second limit applies when the right assigned is a payment intangible that the assignor has sold. Under § 9-406(b)(2), a notification is ineffective to the extent that an agreement between the account debtor and a seller of a payment intangible limits the account debtor's duty to pay a person other than the seller, and the limitation is effective under law other than Article 9.15 A payment intangible is a general intangible under which the main obligation is to pay money, as with the right to repayment of a negotiated loan. The consequence again runs through subsection (a). The account debtor loses its freedom to pay the seller only on receipt of an effective notification, and one that is ineffective under (b)(2) is not that kind. The account debtor may keep paying the seller and be discharged.16 The words to the extent matter, because a limit covering only part of the account debtor's duty defeats the notification only for that part.
The exception honors a bargain. Where the account debtor's agreement with the seller confines its duty to the seller, and law outside Article 9 respects the confinement, the seller's sale of the right does not let the buyer's notification rewrite that duty. The exception fits the broader principle that the account debtor's rights against an assignee depend on the assigned contract, Article 9, and other law governing assignment of the obligation.17
Two neighboring subsections explain why (b)(2) points to law outside Article 9. Subsection (d) addresses terms in the account debtor's agreement that prohibit or restrict assignment, or that require the account debtor's consent to assignment or to the creation, attachment, perfection, or enforcement of a security interest.18 The next section treats it in detail. Its general function is to strip such terms of effect, which is why a limiting clause usually does not defeat a notification on an account. Subsection (e) then provides that subsection (d) does not apply to the sale of a payment intangible or promissory note, other than a sale pursuant to a disposition under § 9-610 or an acceptance of collateral under § 9-620.19 For an ordinary sale of a payment intangible, then, Article 9's general override of restrictive terms drops out. Whether the account debtor's limit holds depends on other law, and (b)(2) says so. Sales through the two foreclosure channels stay inside subsection (d).
The same kind of limiting language can produce opposite results, depending on what was assigned.
The tempting shortcut on an exam is to check that the notification is signed, says the amount has been assigned, directs payment to the assignee, and identifies the rights, and then to declare it effective. That checklist covers subsection (a) and the identification requirement, and it misses (b)(2). When the facts describe a sale of a loan-type right and a clause confining the obligor's payments to the seller, the problem is testing this exception. The type of right still controls the answer, because the same clause in the paperwork for an ordinary account does not stop a notification from working.