Concept
Payment Before Notification
Discharge of the account debtor and effect of notification
Payment Before Notification
An account debtor on an account, chattel paper, or payment intangible may discharge its obligation by paying the assignor until, but not after, it receives a notification, signed by the assignor or the assignee, that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.1 That is the first half of § 9-406(a), and several of the section's later subsections qualify it. The protected period ends at one moment, the account debtor's receipt of the notification, so a single question sorts every payment: had the notification reached the account debtor when it paid? A payment that precedes receipt falls inside the protected period. A payment that follows receipt falls outside it, and the next section takes up what changes there.
Until the account debtor has received notice, the assignment has no effect upon it.2 The assignment is a transaction between assignor and assignee, and nothing in the account debtor's own dealings tells it that the payee has changed. The law therefore lets the account debtor go on treating the assignor as the creditor until someone tells it otherwise, and the statute puts that telling in the hands of the assignor and the assignee.
A payment inside the protected period discharges the account debtor's obligation. Suppose Furniture Co. sells furniture to B on three installments and assigns its right to those payments to Finance Company. The first installment falls due, and B pays it to Furniture Co. before any notification reaches B. B owes nothing more on that installment, and Finance Company cannot demand it from B a second time.3 Finance Company's claim is against Furniture Co., which collected money that, as between the two of them, belonged to Finance Company. B did exactly what the statute allows, and making B pay twice would punish B for a failure that was not its own.
The rule places the risk of that outcome on the assignee. Either the assignor or the assignee can sign the notification, so an assignee that wants its collections to come straight to it can send one. An assignee that stays silent accepts the chance that the assignor will collect and keep the money in the meantime.
The protection does not depend on the payment being due. An account debtor that pays the assignor before the money is owed is still discharged, so long as the payment precedes receipt of the notification.4 The statute draws the line at receipt, so the maturity date of the debt plays no part in sorting payments.
A payment made to the assignor before notice and demand also gives the account debtor a defense of payment if the assignee later sues for the same money.5 On an exam, the tempting error is to reason that the assignee owns the receivable and therefore had to be paid. Ownership settles who may claim the money as between assignor and assignee. The account debtor's safe payment turns on whether it had received a notification.