Concept
Parties and Scope
Discharge of the account debtor and effect of notification
Discharge of the Account Debtor
Parties and Scope
B buys office furniture from Furniture Co. for a small down payment and agrees to pay the balance in three monthly installments. Furniture Co. then assigns its right to those installments to Finance Company, and shortly afterward B receives a notification that the installments have been assigned and are to be paid to Finance Company.1 B's problem is practical: which of the two does it pay? Section 9-406(a) of the Uniform Commercial Code supplies the answer.
An account debtor on an account, chattel paper, or a payment intangible may discharge its obligation by paying the assignor until, but not after, it receives a notification, signed by the assignor or the assignee, that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee. After receipt, the account debtor discharges its obligation by paying the assignee, and paying the assignor no longer discharges it.2 Had B paid an installment to Furniture Co. before the notification arrived, that payment would have discharged B. Now that the notification has arrived, only payment to Finance Company discharges B.
Three parties stand behind the rule, and the example shows each one. B is the account debtor, the person who owes the money. Furniture Co. is the assignor, the person to whom the money was originally owed and who transferred the right to receive it. Finance Company is the assignee, the party that took that right. The transfer need not be a loan secured by receivables. Where there is a sale of an account or chattel paper, including an assignment without recourse, the transaction is within the scope of Article 9.3
The rule turns on receipt of a notification, not on the existence of an assignment, because of B's position. B made its promise to Furniture Co. and has no part in whatever arrangement Furniture Co. later makes with Finance Company. B cannot readily learn whether that arrangement exists or is valid, and it should not have to investigate before each payment. Receipt of a notification is something B can observe for itself. Until one arrives, B may keep paying Furniture Co. and be discharged. Once one arrives, B must pay Finance Company, and a payment to Furniture Co. will not discharge it. That rule protects B from paying twice through no fault of its own.
The opening clause of the rule also marks its boundaries. It protects the obligor on an account, chattel paper, or a payment intangible, all of which are rights to payment. That limit is tolerable because, where the obligor's only duty is to pay money, a change in the person to whom payment is to be made is not ordinarily material.4 A negotiable note is a different case. The maker owes payment to the person entitled to enforce the instrument, and Article 3 governs that payment.5 The opening clause also makes the discharge rule subject to later subsections of the same section. The rest of this chapter takes up those qualifications: what a notification must say, partial assignments, sold payment intangibles, anti-assignment terms, and controllable accounts.