Concept
Timing Limits on Modification
Modification of the assigned contract
Timing Limits on Modification
A good-faith modification does not bind an assignee without limit. Subsection (b) of UCC § 9-405 provides that subsection (a) applies only "to the extent that" one of two timing conditions holds.1 Either the right to payment, or a part of it, has not yet been fully earned by performance,2 or the right to payment has been fully earned and the account debtor has not received notification of the assignment under § 9-406(a).3 A modification must therefore pass two gates: the good-faith test of subsection (a), and then one of these timing conditions. Subsection (a) says as much when it declares itself "subject to subsections (b) through (d)."4
The conditions sort a contract by how far it has run. Where performance remains, the assignor and the account debtor are still in the middle of their deal, and adjusting the unfinished part is the ordinary business change that the freedom to modify protects. Where performance is complete, the assignor has done everything needed to deserve payment, and the assignee counts the claim as collateral already in hand. The statute therefore lets the unfinished part change freely, and it lets the finished part change only until the account debtor is told whom to pay.
The words "to the extent" let one contract be divided into parts, each tested by the condition that fits it.
The two conditions are alternatives, not cumulative requirements. A portion of the right to payment is either earned or unearned and cannot be both, so each portion must satisfy only the condition that fits it. The unearned portion comes first below. The earned portion, where notification decides the result, follows.
Both conditions describe the commercial baseline. Where other law sets rules for an individual account debtor who incurred the obligation for consumer purposes, the Article 9 rules on modification of assigned contracts are subject to those rules,5 and a separate consumer protection law that provides otherwise will preempt.6 A later section returns to consumer account debtors.
Right Not Yet Fully Earned
Section 9-405(b)(1) lets a good-faith modification bind the assignee to the extent that the right to payment, or a part of it, has not been fully earned by performance.7 Performance earns the right when the assignor has done what the contract requires to deserve payment, such as delivering the goods or finishing the work. Until then the right is executory, because the contract still calls for something to be done. The condition measures how much of the contract remains to be performed, and a modification that passes the good-faith test binds the assignee as far as it reaches that unfinished part.8 The words "or a part thereof" matter because most contracts hold finished and unfinished performance side by side.
Nothing in this condition mentions notification. The text asks only whether the right to payment has been fully earned.9 Notification enters the statute only in the second condition, which governs rights that performance has already earned.10 Students often assume otherwise, because notification has weighty effects elsewhere: once the account debtor receives appropriate notification, it can discharge its obligation only by paying the assignee.11 But notification redirects the payment. It does not freeze the terms on which an unearned right will fall due, so a modification made after notice is judged under (b)(1) exactly as one made before it.
Two reasons support the rule. An assignee who takes an interest in a right that still depends on performance holds a claim whose size is set by what remains to be delivered or built, and the assignor and the account debtor are the parties placed to decide how that work should change. If every adjustment needed the financer's approval, the financer would hold a veto over the assignor's ordinary business. Notification does not alter this analysis, because it does not turn an expectation of future payment into a fixed sum. The assignee keeps two protections: the good-faith filter of subsection (a), and the option to provide in the assignment that a modification is a breach of contract by the assignor.12
The lumber dispute between Plank Company and Mayflower Motel shows the condition at work. Plymouth Bank wrote to Mayflower that it held an assignment of all of Plank's present and later-arising accounts and that Mayflower was to pay the bank directly for any lumber it bought from Plank. Mayflower then contracted to buy lumber from Plank on credit, and Plank has yet to deliver most of it. Now the parties wish to cut the price by 10% because lumber prices have dropped, and they want to know whether the change will affect the bank's entitlement against Mayflower.13 Whether they may change their own contract is a separate question from whether the change binds the bank, and § 9-405 answers only the second. For the lumber still undelivered, the right to payment is not fully earned, so a good-faith reduction is effective against the bank even though the bank's letter reached Mayflower before the contract existed. The bank's rights for that lumber then correspond to the lower price.14 A price cut that follows a falling market is the kind of adjustment the good-faith test is built to allow. Lumber already delivered is a different matter, and it falls to the next subsection.
The same line governs a cut in quantity. The executory part of a contract can shrink, but the amounts earned by past deliveries stay outside (b)(1).
The unearned status of the right opens the timing gate and says nothing about the parties' conduct. Good faith tests that conduct, and a modification must pass both gates before it binds the assignee.
Earned but Not Notified
Section 9-405(b)(2) reaches the part of a contract that performance has already earned. A good-faith modification is effective against the assignee as to that part only if the account debtor has not received notification of the assignment under § 9-406(a).17 The first condition asked how much work remained. This one applies after the work is done, when the assignor has delivered the goods or finished the job and the assignee holds a claim to a sum already deserved, and it asks only what the account debtor knows. Until the account debtor is notified, a good-faith change can reach even the earned amount. Once it is notified, the earned amount is beyond modification.18
Notification marks the end of the account debtor's freedom to deal with the assignor as its creditor. Until it receives appropriate notification, the account debtor may discharge its obligation by paying the assignor. Afterward, it may discharge the obligation only by paying the assignee.19 The statute treats a good-faith adjustment, such as a discount for a defect or a concession on a late shipment, the same way, because until notification the account debtor is still dealing with the assignor as its creditor. After notification, a reduction of an earned amount would do nothing except take the assignee's collateral away. The line also falls where the risk can be controlled. The assignee can send notification the day it takes the assignment, while an account debtor has no way to learn of a private financing arrangement unless someone tells it.
Because everything turns on notification, its content matters. Section 9-406(a) speaks of appropriate notification, one stating that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.20 Two practical points follow. A bare remark that the seller has financing tells the customer neither that its account was assigned nor whom to pay, so it is not that notification. And an assignee that wants earned amounts protected should send a signed written notice that names the accounts covered and directs payment to it, which removes any dispute about what the customer knew.
Meeting either timing condition never displaces the good-faith requirement. A collusive reduction of an earned amount fails even against an assignee who gave no notice.21
The lumber facts can be changed to test where the notification line falls in time. Suppose Plank delivers all the lumber, and only afterward does the price drop and the parties agree to the 10% reduction. For lumber that performance has fully earned, (b)(1) is no help, and the reduction binds the bank only if Mayflower, when the price changed, had not received notification of the assignment.22 The bank's letter reached Mayflower before any lumber contract existed. Was that notification?
Mayflower's argument does not rest on what the letter said, since the letter told Mayflower that Plank's accounts were assigned and directed payment to the bank. The argument rests on timing. Section 9-406(a) fixes the juncture as the moment "the account debtor receives a notification that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee." Mayflower can ask whether it was an account debtor when the letter arrived. It owed nothing then, because no contract and no account existed, and on that view a letter received before any account arose is not the notification the statute contemplates.23
The bank has answers. The text of (b)(2) asks whether the account debtor has not received notification and does not say when the notification must have arrived. The phrase "to become due" shows that a notification may speak of amounts not yet owing. And Mayflower was told whom to pay before it owed anything, so it cannot say it dealt with Plank in ignorance of the assignment.24
A Minnesota decision gives the bank a quotable line, but only a limited one. After quoting the UCC definitions of notice, the court concluded that the account debtor had notice of the assignment before it made its independent-contractor agreement with the assignor. The court then said that § 9-404(a)(1) "provides otherwise" and that § 9-404(a)(2) did not govern the dispute.25 That passage came from a case about the account debtor's defenses under § 9-404, not about modification under § 9-405, so it works as a dictum that points the bank's way and does not decide the question. An answer to the lumber problem should therefore treat the point as arguable on both sides. The lesson for an assignee is practical: a notice sent after the account arises, directing payment to the assignee, leaves nothing to argue about.