Concept
Waiver of Defenses: Reversing the Baseline
Assignee subject to account debtor's terms, claims, and defenses
Waiver of Defenses: Reversing the Baseline
The shoes rule of § 9-404(a) announces its own exception in its opening words: an assignee's rights are subject to the account debtor's defenses unless the account debtor has made an enforceable agreement not to assert defenses or claims.1 A valid agreement of that kind reverses the baseline, so the assignee takes free of the defenses the account debtor promised not to raise. The account debtor, in Article 9's vocabulary, is the person who owes the obligation on an account, chattel paper, or general intangible.2 Section 9-403 decides when that promise binds, and the exceptions section below examines its limits in detail. What follows sets out the rule, the conditions on it, and the points at which it gives way.
If a waiver clause is valid, it effectively eliminates the rule that an obligor may assert against the assignee any defense it holds against the assignor, and the assignee's rights come to resemble those of a holder in due course.3 An assignee can then rely on the debtor's promise to pay without pricing in the debtor's disputes with the assignor. Freedom of contract is the argument for enforcing the clause. The argument against is fairness: it is unfair that a consumer must pay even though the consumer has a defense against the assignor, and the unfairness is sharpest when the assignor has become insolvent.4
The holder in due course supplies the Code's yardstick. The official comment to § 9-403 says the section is "designed to put the assignee in a position that is no better and no worse than that of a holder in due course of a negotiable instrument under Article 3."5 An assignee of an ordinary contract cannot claim that status directly, because a writing that lacks an element essential to negotiability may not be governed by Article 3 at all.6 The waiver gives the assignee, by agreement, a position it could not reach through negotiability.
Section 9-403(b) makes an agreement between an account debtor and an assignor not to assert claims or defenses enforceable only by an assignee that satisfies four conditions, and the assignee must satisfy all of them.7
The conditions fall into two pairs. Value and good faith test the assignee's own conduct: a party that paid for the account and dealt honestly has relied on the debtor's promise in a way worth protecting. The two notice conditions test what the assignee knew when it took, and an assignee that knew of a competing claim to the account, or of the very defense in question, can hardly say it relied on the promise. The notice conditions also reflect some mistrust of good faith standing alone.8 None of the four turns on notification to the account debtor. (Notification matters under the cutoff rules, and to be effective it must be authenticated by the assignor or assignee and state that the amount due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.9)
The conditions do their work in a simple case. A farmer buys a tractor from a seller on a conditional sales contract that contains a waiver of defenses in favor of any assignee. The clause bars the farmer from resisting the assignee on the ground that the tractor is defective, on the assumption that the assignee gave value and took in good faith without notice of the defense. The tractor is not consumer goods, so the consumer limit discussed below does not apply.10 California reached a like result for an equipment lease in Equico Lessors, Inc. v. Mines (1978) 84 Cal.App.3d 374, holding that the only defenses open to the lessees were those available to a holder in due course of a negotiable instrument and that failure of consideration was not one of them.11 Take away any single condition and the clause fails. An assignee told before buying that the lessee claimed the equipment was defective took with notice of the very defense, and it cannot enforce the waiver against that defense.
Even a waiver that meets every condition stops short of the real defenses. Section 9-403(c) provides that the waiver does not apply to defenses of a type that may be asserted against a holder in due course of a negotiable instrument under § 3-305(b).12 Those defenses include lack of capacity based on infancy or other disabling status, duress, illegality, fraud that left the account debtor no reasonable opportunity to learn the nature of the contract or its essential terms, and discharge in insolvency proceedings.13 The line follows what each defense attacks. A real defense goes to whether the law should enforce the obligation at all, and the waiver is a term of the very contract under attack, so a clause in a minor's lease cannot cure the minor's incapacity. A personal defense such as breach of warranty or failure of consideration assumes a valid contract that was badly performed, and a party may sensibly bargain away the right to complain about that. This is the official comment's measure in practice: the assignee is no better and no worse off than a holder in due course, so real defenses still reach it and personal defenses do not.
Waiver clauses almost always appear in standard-form contracts prepared at the instance of firms that take assignments as a vocation, and signers may not appreciate the threat when they sign. Federal and state authorities have therefore moved to counteract them.15 The Code defers to that effort: separate consumer-protection law is given preemptive effect.16 Section 9-403(e) makes the waiver rule subject to other law that establishes a different rule for an account debtor who is an individual and who incurred the obligation primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.17
The purpose of the purchase separates the tractor from a household case. Suppose a family buys an appliance for the home under a contract in which it promises not to assert any claim against the seller's assignee, and the appliance is never delivered. The assignee may have given value and acted in good faith without notice, yet consumer-protection law can override the clause for these buyers, who may therefore be able to assert nondelivery.18 The same distinction runs through the cases. The Toyota 4-Runner in LaChapelle v. Toyota Motor Credit Corp. fell within subsection (e), assuming it was leased to Ms. LaChapelle for her personal use. The account debtors in Wells Fargo Bank Minnesota, N.A. v. B.C.B.U. and Chemical Bank got no help from the subsection, because their goods were wanted for business purposes.19
A second override protects the consumer when the contract's paperwork is deficient. A federal regulation, 16 C.F.R. § 433.2, requires certain contracts to include a prominent anti-waiver-of-defenses clause. When a contract omits the required clause, § 9-403(d) undercuts a waiver clause to the extent the required clause would have done had it been included.20
An exam answer about an assignee facing an account debtor's defense should begin by asking whether the contract contains a waiver, because an enforceable waiver reverses the baseline. If it does, test the four conditions. Then ask whether the defense is a real one, whether the account debtor is an individual who incurred the obligation for personal, family, or household purposes, and whether the contract omitted a required clause, since each of those defeats the waiver in whole or in part. If no enforceable waiver exists, the shoes rules from the earlier sections decide the result.