Concept
Subordination Versus Security Interest
Subordination (§ 9-339)
Subordination Versus Security Interest
Article 9 leaves room for a secured creditor to agree to rank behind another claimant: it does not preclude subordination by agreement by a person entitled to priority.1 Such an agreement changes who is paid first from the collateral. The harder question is what else it changes. The creditor lifted up by the agreement now holds a better claim, and the Code defines "security interest" so broadly that a careless reader may conclude the elevated creditor has acquired one in the subordinating creditor's rights. It has not.
The breadth of the definition is real. Section 1-201(b)(35) applies to any transaction that, regardless of its form, creates a security interest, so parties will find it difficult or impossible to build a deal with the economic characteristics of a security interest that the law treats as something else.2 Article 9's scope follows the same approach: all security interests, regardless of form, fall within it, along with certain financing transactions that are not conventional security interests.3 But the definition catches a transaction only when that transaction creates a security interest, and a bare agreement to rank behind another creditor creates none.
Two sets of rights are in play, and the answer follows once they are kept apart. Debtor's collateral is subject to each bank's security interest, and subordination operates on the ranking of those interests. Old Bank's right to be paid by Debtor is a separate asset that belongs to Old Bank. An agreement that moves Old Bank behind New Bank in the collateral does not hand New Bank any interest in that asset. Ranking behind someone is not the same as pledging something to them.
Article 1 states the same result directly. Its provision on subordination, drafted as an optional provision and not enacted in every Code jurisdiction, permits one obligation to be subordinated to payment of another by agreement of the subordinating person with either the obligor or the beneficiary of the other obligation. Such a subordination does not itself create a security interest as against either the common debtor or a subordinated creditor, and the provision is declared to state existing common law, not change it.4 Article 9 and Article 1 therefore treat subordination alike, as a device for ranking claims and not as a property interest. Under Article 9, one limit applies: the agreement must be made by the person willing to subordinate, because that person's rights cannot be adversely affected by an agreement to which it is not a party.5
Nothing in these provisions prevents a creditor from doing more. A creditor may subordinate its interest to another creditor and also give that creditor a security interest in its right to payment from the debtor.6 The second step is a different arrangement from the first. A grant of that kind is a security interest, and Article 9 reaches it whatever form the clause takes.7 The ranking produced by the subordination does not supply the grant.
The two agreements involve the same parties, the same collateral, and the same ranking, and they differ by a single clause. The question to put to any such document is whether it contains words of grant. If it speaks only of ranking, the favored creditor has priority and no security interest in the subordinating creditor's rights. If it also grants an interest in the right to payment, the favored creditor has a security interest, and that interest comes from the grant.