Concept
Who Must Agree
Subordination (§ 9-339)
Who Must Agree
Article 9 does not preclude subordination by agreement by a person entitled to priority.1 That phrase decides whose signature counts. The person entitled to priority is the claimant the applicable priority rule already ranks ahead. Between Old Bank, which filed first, and New Bank, which filed later, that claimant is Old Bank, so only Old Bank has a position to give up. The agreement must therefore come from the creditor willing to subordinate its own interest, and that creditor's rights cannot be adversely affected by an agreement to which it is not a party.2
The rule has two halves, and both rest on one idea. The entitled creditor's own consent makes a subordination effective. Without that consent, the ranking stays where the default rules put it.
An examiner who wants to test the point will usually have the debtor and the junior lender sign a document and then ask who ranks first.
The only difference between the two versions is Old Bank's signature. In the first version, neither signer has any priority to surrender. Debtor is not a competing claimant, and New Bank ranks behind Old Bank. Their document does nothing to Old Bank, which is under no obligation to subordinate and decides for itself whether to do so. In the second version, the creditor entitled to priority consents, and the ranking changes.
The rule also settles who bears the cost. A subordination costs the subordinating creditor its place in line. If a document signed by others could subordinate Old Bank, Debtor and New Bank would collect the benefit and hand the whole cost to a creditor who never accepted it. Requiring Old Bank's own agreement keeps the loss with the party that chose it.
This result fits the general treatment of security agreements. A security agreement is effective according to its terms between the debtor and the secured party who made it.3 That general rule yields to overriding provisions in Article 9. The official comment gives the Part 3 priority rules as examples, such as § 9-317 and § 9-322, and then cross-references § 9-339, the subordination-agreement section.4 Debtor and New Bank are therefore bound to each other by whatever they sign. The ranking among competing creditors, however, comes from the priority rules, and only the consent of the creditor holding the better position can change it. The next section turns to agreements that fall short of subordination.