Concept
The Subordination Rule
Subordination (§ 9-339)
Subordination by Agreement
The Subordination Rule
A secured party that ranks first may agree to rank behind someone else, and Article 9 lets the agreement stand. Section 9-339 says so in one sentence: "This article does not preclude subordination by agreement by a person entitled to priority."1 Subordination is a creditor's agreement to let another claimant's rights in the collateral come ahead of its own.
Each phrase of the section does its own work. "Does not preclude" makes the section a saving clause: it removes any doubt that a claimant with the better position may give it up. "By agreement" limits the rearrangement to one the parties choose. "A person entitled to priority" names the party that surrenders its position, which is the claimant some priority rule has already placed ahead. The section therefore ranks no one. It operates on a ranking that other rules have already produced.
Those other rules come first. Article 9 has no single priority rule, because each kind of dispute has its own, and a lone "first-in-time, first-in-right" idea cannot resolve them all.2 The rule that applies depends on who the competing creditors are. One rule governs a secured party against a lien creditor whose lien arose by execution on a judgment; a different rule governs two secured parties with interests in the same asset.3 The first task is to identify the basis of each side's claim, and the second is to select the rule that matches.
For two perfected security interests, the matching rule ranks them by the earlier of the time a filing covering the collateral is first made or the interest is first perfected, provided no period follows when there is neither filing nor perfection.4 Suppose Old Bank files against the debtor on July 1 and New Bank files on August 1. New Bank then advances funds before Old Bank has advanced anything. Old Bank still has priority, even though New Bank's advance came first and its interest was perfected when made. It also makes no difference whether Old Bank knew of New Bank's interest when it made its own advance.5
That default result stands unless the party entitled to priority agrees otherwise. Knowledge of a competing interest changes nothing, and only an agreement can change the ranking, which is the step § 9-339 preserves.
The agreement is enforceable because Article 9 follows a freedom-of-contract approach. Before the 1999 revision, the Code stated that, except for the procedure on default, freedom of contract prevails between the immediate parties to a secured transaction, and the 1999 Article 9 continues to honor that approach.6
The rule reaches two kinds of beneficiary. A security interest may be subordinated to another security interest, as in the Old Bank hypothetical. It may also be subordinated to the claim of some other person, so the party that benefits need not hold a security interest at all.7 What matters is that the claimant entitled to priority agrees to let another claim come first.
Step five does different work from the steps before it, and the order matters. A student who stops after step four announces the default ranking and misses an agreed ranking that reverses it. A student who tries to fit § 9-339 into step three, as one more candidate for the matching priority rule, asks the section to do something it does not do. It ranks no one, and it operates on a result already reached.