Concept
Sorting Commingling Problems
Commingling
Sorting Commingling Problems
Every commingling problem begins with one question: what is the secured party trying to reach? The answer sends the facts down one of three routes.
- The debtor sold or otherwise disposed of original collateral, and the lender follows the goods. The interest continues in the collateral unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of it.1
- The debtor physically merged original goods with other goods until their identity was lost, and the lender follows the merged goods. No security interest exists in commingled goods as such, but an interest may attach to the product or mass that results.2
- The debtor received something in exchange for the collateral, and the lender follows the proceeds. Commingled proceeds are sorted by type. Proceeds that are goods are governed by the commingled-goods provision, and proceeds that are not goods must be traced.3
Each route asks a different question about the debtor's property, so the first job is to decide which question the facts are asking.
Article 9 matches the tool to the property. Goods merged into a product or mass are tangible, and the product-or-mass rules covered earlier in this chapter fix each lender's share by the value of the collateral it supplied when the goods merged. A bank balance is a fungible pool, and for that the statute asks how much of the balance the secured party can attribute to its collateral by tracing. The wrong tool gives the wrong answer. Dividing a bank account among lenders by collateral value answers a question the facts never asked. Demanding a trace for oats that have merged in a bin ignores the rule the statute assigns to them.
What the debtor holds after the event controls the classification, because the same original collateral can end up as merged goods, as a trade-in, or as a bank deposit. A student who sees the word commingled in both branches of § 9-315(b) and applies one regime to both has skipped step five, where the two regimes part.
The first branch is the one in which the lender's own goods merged. A lender whose agreement covers a manufacturer's sand cannot reclaim sand from the glass the manufacturer makes of it, because the sand no longer exists as sand. Yet the lender's interest attaches to the glass even though the agreement never mentions glass.4 A financed engine bolted into a tractor presents the contrast. The engine can still be picked out and removed, so its identity survives, it is not commingled goods, and the product-or-mass provisions have no work to do. The line between the two scenes is whether the original goods can still be distinguished after the union.
Proceeds that are goods reach the same destination as original goods that merge, because the statute sends both to the same provision.5
Cash takes the other fork. Commingled proceeds that are not goods are identifiable only to the extent the secured party identifies them by a tracing method that law outside Article 9 permits for commingled property of that type.6 The standard illustration uses the lowest intermediate balance rule. A debtor sells equipment for $100 and deposits the price in an account holding $500, then withdraws $550 and later deposits $200, ending at $250. The lowest balance after the deposit was $50, so $50 is identifiable proceeds.7 Tracing matters only when something else shares the account.
The route through original collateral and the route through proceeds run side by side, and nothing in the sorting forces the lender to choose. Section 9-315(a)(1) continues the interest in collateral after a disposition, while the interest in proceeds attaches separately and automatically, even when the agreement is silent.8 A sale that sends the machine to an unprotected buyer and the price to the debtor's account therefore leaves the lender with two claims. The lender may pursue the machine in the buyer's hands and the traceable part of the account. Each dollar collected from one source reduces what remains owing, because the debt is paid only once. An answer that finds a continuing interest in the original goods should therefore also check for proceeds, and an answer that traces proceeds should check whether the original goods remain reachable.