Concept
Crops Fed to Livestock
Commingling
Crops Fed to Livestock
Courts have answered differently the question whether feeding a crop to livestock creates commingled goods. Under UCC § 9-336, a security interest does not exist in commingled goods as such, but it may attach to the product or mass that results when goods become commingled goods.1 Grain that has been eaten has lost its identity, and the fattened animal looks like the product in which the crop lender’s value now sits. Yet the commingling rule’s application to feed has never been entirely clear.2
The dispute has stakes only when different lenders hold the crops and the animals. If one lender holds both, no one else competes for the fattened animals, and the label a court puts on the feeding changes nothing. If one lender holds a perfected interest in the corn and another holds a perfected interest in the steers that eat it, each can point to the same animals as its security.
If feeding does produce commingled goods, the sharing rule from earlier in this chapter supplies the answer.
The sharing rule applies only if the feeding is proved. In Beatrice National Bank v. Southeast Nebraska Cooperative, the Nebraska Supreme Court held that the commingling-of-feed rule does not apply where there is no evidence that the feed was fed to livestock.3 The reason lies in the definition: commingled goods are goods physically united with other goods so that their identity is lost, so a lender who invokes the rule must show that the union occurred. Feed sitting in a bin has been united with nothing, and it remains crop collateral under the ordinary rules.
Proof of feeding does not settle the outcome. In First National Bank of Brush v. Bostron, a Colorado court held that feeding grain to cattle pledged as collateral under a security agreement terminated the creditor’s security interest in the grain. In In re Pelton, a bankruptcy court faced a debtor who raised cattle owned by third-party investors and held that the creditor’s security interest in the crops fed to the cattle continued in cattle proceeds, whether under Article 9 or because the feeding was considered a sale of the crops to the investors.4 The two results run in opposite directions: Bostron ends the interest in the grain, and Pelton carries it into the cattle. The facts may explain part of the gap. The cattle were themselves collateral in Bostron and belonged to outside investors in Pelton, which made a sale easier to see. Pelton’s proceeds route also meets the commingling rule at its end, because commingled proceeds that are goods are identifiable to the extent § 9-336 provides.5
A feed problem therefore asks for more than a rule. Name the competing characterizations (commingled goods that yield a product or mass, a disposition that ends the interest in the grain, and a sale of the crops whose proceeds are the cattle), say that courts have not settled the choice, and apply the one the facts best support. None fits feeding comfortably, and the decisions show it. Two facts carry the weight in those decisions: whether the feeding was proved, and whether the animals were the debtor’s own collateral or belonged to others.
For lenders, the uncertainty is a reason to settle the question before the feeding starts. A crop lender cannot count on its interest following the feed into the animals, and an animal lender cannot count on the animals being free of the crop lender’s claim. The two can agree in advance how they will rank. A crop lender that knows the crop is meant for feed can also authorize its use free of the lender’s interest; to the extent feeding counts as a disposition, the continuation rule yields to that authorization, because a security interest continues in collateral notwithstanding a disposition unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of the interest.6 Because the Nebraska decision demands evidence of feeding, a lender that wants to assert commingling also needs records showing what was fed and when.
Perfection in Cash Proceeds
Tracing tells a lender which part of a mixed fund is its proceeds; perfection decides whether the lender’s interest in that part holds up against other creditors, and for how long. A security interest in proceeds is perfected if the security interest in the original collateral was perfected.8 That perfection is short-lived by default: it ends on the 21st day after the interest attaches to the proceeds unless an exception applies.9 Identifiable cash proceeds are one of those exceptions.10
Section 9-102(a)(9) defines cash proceeds as “money, checks, deposit accounts, or the like.” The secured creditor stays indefinitely perfected in identifiable cash proceeds, so a creditor perfected in the original collateral has a continuously perfected interest in the debtor’s bank account, at least as to the proceeds portion it can identify.11 The generosity is partly illusory, because money, checks, and the like are seldom long in the hands of a troubled debtor.12
The exception matters most when the lender has no other route to perfection in the account. In one worked problem, a bank without control of a deposit account was perfected in it only through automatic perfection of its interest in identifiable cash proceeds.13
The word identifiable limits the benefit. A lender whose collateral produced one deposit in a pooled account cannot claim the whole balance. What stays perfected is the amount the lender can identify by a tracing method that law outside Article 9 permits for commingled property of that type.14 The lowest intermediate balance rule supplies one such method. In a worked problem, it left $2,000 of identifiable proceeds in a debtor’s account, and the lender was perfected in that $2,000.15
The tracing presumption can decide a contest. If the $2,000 left in an account is presumed to remain from an earlier $10,000 deposit of proceeds under a rule like the lowest intermediate balance rule, the lender has an argument that its interest in that $2,000 outranks a tax lien. Under a different presumption, or if the account was drained to zero and then replenished, the tax lien would have priority.16 Perfected status also guarantees nothing about rank. In the same worked problem, a second lender perfected by control of the account had priority in all of the funds, even though the first lender was also perfected in its $2,000.17
The exception continues perfection and cannot create it, so a lender that was unperfected in the original collateral gains nothing from it. Cash that the debtor spends on other property also leaves the rule. A machine bought with cash proceeds is proceeds of the cash proceeds, and the next subsection shows what the lender must do to stay perfected in it.18
Perfection in Noncash Proceeds
A perfected security interest in proceeds is perfected automatically for 20 days; to keep that perfection longer, the lender must satisfy one of the other subsections of § 9-315(d) or take the step that would perfect an interest in the asset itself.20 For noncash proceeds, the usual route is the same-office rule of § 9-315(d)(1), which applies when all three of these conditions are met:
- a filed financing statement covers the original collateral;21
- the proceeds are collateral in which a security interest may be perfected by filing in the office where that financing statement was filed; and22
- the proceeds were not acquired with cash proceeds.23
The cash rule already protects money, checks, and deposit accounts, so this rule governs accounts, chattel paper, goods taken in trade, and similar proceeds. The second condition is usually met, because most collateral can be perfected by filing; the exceptions are deposit accounts, letter-of-credit rights, and money, and proceeds in those forms fall outside it.24 Almost all Article 9 filings against a corporate debtor are made where the debtor is incorporated, so the filing office usually matches, and perfection in the proceeds usually continues without any act by the lender.25 The financing statement need not list the proceeds. A creditor perfected by filing in the original collateral is perfected in chattel paper received as proceeds even though its financing statement does not list chattel paper, because chattel paper is perfected by filing in the same office and the debtor did not buy it with cash proceeds.26
The third condition is where cash breaks the chain. When the debtor spends cash proceeds on a new asset, that asset is proceeds of cash proceeds. The lender’s interest attaches to it, but the same-office rule gives no perfection, and the lender must file a financing statement describing the new collateral (a machine, for example, as equipment or as the specific machine) or take possession of it.27
The limit holds even when the asset types match. A lender whose financing statement describes one specific copier has an unperfected interest in a replacement copier bought with the cash from selling the first. The replacement is proceeds of proceeds, the same-office rule does not apply, and the description covers only the specific copier described.28
When the same-office rule is unavailable, the interest stays perfected only if the lender perfects it by another method when the interest attaches to the proceeds or within 20 days afterward.29 Filing as to the new collateral and taking possession both qualify.30 A lender that acts on the 15th day stays continuously perfected; a lender that acts on the 40th day is perfected only from then on, with a gap that opens on the 21st day. The step is mandatory for a lender that was unperfected in the original collateral, because it has no perfection to carry forward and must act on its own.31 In one worked problem, a bank unperfected in tools held an unperfected interest in the account received on their sale, because its interest in the tools was unperfected and it took no sufficient step as to the account.32
Same-office perfection lasts only as long as the filing that supports it. When a filed financing statement covers the original collateral, a security interest in proceeds that remains perfected under the same-office rule becomes unperfected at the later of two moments: the lapse or termination of the financing statement, and the 21st day after the interest attaches to the proceeds.33 In one worked problem, perfection in an account continued past 20 days under the same-office rule, and the later lapse of the financing statement unperfected the interest as to purchasers for value.34 Because the 21st day is the alternative, a filing that lapses soon after the debtor acquires the proceeds still leaves the lender the full automatic window.