Concept
Product or Mass Rule
Commingling
Product or Mass Rule
Commingling destroys the lender's usual remedy of following the asset. Once flour is baked into cakes, or corn is poured into a bin of other corn, no particular asset remains to follow. UCC § 9-336(b) answers in two sentences. A security interest does not exist in commingled goods as such, but a security interest may attach to a product or mass that results when goods become commingled goods.1
A bakery shows how the two sentences work together. Lender finances Baker's purchase of flour and takes a security interest in it. Baker mixes the flour with eggs and sugar and bakes cakes. Under the first sentence, Lender holds no interest in "the flour" as such, because the flour no longer exists as a separate thing. Under the second, Lender may assert its interest in the cakes, which are the product that resulted from the mixing. Grain works the same way. If a farmer pours Lender's corn into a silo of other corn, the silo's contents are a mass, and Lender's interest may attach to that mass rather than to its own bushels.
The rule avoids two bad results. If the statute kept the interest in goods that can no longer be picked out, the interest would bind nothing identifiable. If it declared the interest extinguished, a debtor could erase a lien by mixing the collateral into a larger pile. Attaching the interest to the product or mass keeps the lender's claim in the thing that now contains its goods.
The rule also reaches proceeds. Commingled proceeds that are goods are identifiable proceeds to the extent § 9-336 provides.2 Proceeds that are not goods follow a different test: they are identifiable only to the extent the secured party identifies them by a method of tracing, including equitable principles, that law outside Article 9 permits for commingled property of the type involved.3 A later section takes up that tracing test.
A commingling problem raises two questions, and an exam answer should take them in order. First, does the lender have a claim to the product or mass at all? This rule answers that: no interest survives in the commingled goods as such, but an interest may attach to what results. Second, is that claim perfected, and how does it rank against other claimants to the same mass? The next section takes up that question.