Concept
Commingled Goods Defined
Commingling
Commingled Goods Defined
When proceeds are goods and end up mixed with other goods, the proceeds rules defer to § 9-336 to the extent that section provides, and § 9-336 opens with a definition.1 Commingled goods are goods physically united with other goods in such a manner that their identity is lost in a product or mass.2 Two conditions follow. The goods must be physically united with other goods, and the union must destroy their identity. Physical union alone proves little, because goods can be united with others and still be picked out afterward; the loss of identity decides the question.
The easy cases show what loss of identity looks like. Eggs and flour baked into cakes cannot be taken back out of the cakes, and the official comment to § 9-336 uses flour in baked goods as its example.3 A farmer who puts harvested corn into a grain elevator, or stores grain in a commercial silo alongside other farmers' grain, has commingled it, because the grain loses its identity.4
Article 9 treats the result differently from ordinary collateral. A security interest does not exist in commingled goods as such, but it may attach to the product or mass that results when goods become commingled.5 A security interest in the goods before they were commingled carries into the product or mass afterward.6 The classification therefore tells a lender where to look: not at the vanished originals, but at the whole they became.
Article 9 has a second category for goods united with other goods, and the line between the two turns on identity. An accession is goods physically united with other goods in such a manner that the identity of the original goods is not lost.7 The two definitions share their language about physical union and part company on that one clause. The consequence differs as well. The secured party in an accession keeps its interest in the accession itself after the union, while the secured party in commingled goods must look to the product or mass.8 A lender that financed an engine can keep following the engine; a lender that financed flour looks to the cakes.
A new engine installed in an automobile is the standard accession, and so is an alternator installed on an automobile engine, because each is still an identifiable item after installation.9 Identity, not the effort of separation, decides the matter. Comment 2 to § 9-335 says an accession does not lose its status merely because of the cost or difficulty of removing it from the other goods, or because the original goods have become an integral part of the whole.10 An engine that takes a full day to pull out is still an accession. Flour baked into a cake is different in kind, because nothing identifiable remains to separate.
The definition is not limited to processing. It reaches raw materials that lose their identity as they are processed into finished goods, and it reaches components assembled into a machine, with ball bearings in a machine as the comment's example.11 Set that example beside the engine above. The engine installed in an automobile is an accession, yet the ball bearings installed in the engine are commingled goods.12
Not every case is as easy as cakes and corn. Comment 2 to § 9-335 directs many of the hard cases into the accession category, so a borderline item often ends up there.13 On an exam, commit to one classification and defend it by asking whether the original goods can still be distinguished.