Concept
Removal After Default
Accessions
Removal After Default
After default, and subject to Part 6, a secured party may remove an accession from the other goods if its security interest in the accession has priority over the claims of every person having an interest in the whole.1 That sentence is the payoff for the work in the earlier sections. A lender that financed a replacement engine, kept its interest after installation, and ranks first can pull the engine out of the tractor on default instead of selling a tractor it never financed.
The right is conditional on rank. Removal takes a part out of a machine that other lenders and owners claim, so the Code lets only a claimant that outranks every holder of an interest in the whole do it. The certificate-of-title rule from the previous section reaches the remedy through this condition. A security interest in an accession is subordinate to a security interest in the whole perfected under a certificate-of-title statute,2 so a component financier that ranks behind the lender named on a vehicle's certificate lacks the priority that removal demands.3
The right also has a price. A secured party that removes an accession must promptly pay for the repair of any physical injury the removal causes to the whole or the other goods.4 The first subsection below takes up priority as the prerequisite to removal. The second takes up that duty to reimburse.
Priority Over Every Holder of an Interest in the Whole
Removal has two triggers, and every fact pattern tests the second. The debtor must have defaulted, and the accession interest must have priority over the claims of every person having an interest in the whole.5 Removal means taking the accession off the other goods, so the engine comes out of the tractor. Because the right is subject to Part 6, the general limits on taking possession of collateral still apply, including the rule that a secured party may proceed without judicial process only if it can do so without breach of the peace.6 This section assumes those limits are met.
Tying removal to priority follows from what removal does. Each lender or owner with an interest in the whole has a claim that reaches the accession as part of the whole. If any of them outranks the accession lender, that person has the better right to the engine, and removing it would take collateral from a stronger claimant. The word every does the work: a single superior holder defeats the remedy.
The common error is to treat the test as a contest between two lenders. An exam stem usually supplies one priority fight, such as the engine lender against the lender on the tractor, and the instinct is to let whoever wins that fight remove. The text asks for more. The accession interest must be compared with the claims of every person having an interest in the whole, including holders the stem mentions only in passing.
Where the accession lender did not finance the accession, the general priority rule of § 9-322(a) decides each ranking, and a lender that filed first against the whole will argue that it wins.7 The pump financier in the next example is in that position.
The sequence for applying the condition is short enough to run on any fact pattern. Because the remedy depends on a comparison with a whole group of claimants, list the claimants before ranking anyone.
The tire financer fails at step three. A seller that finances tires for a car that is also subject to a security interest securing the car's purchase price will not generally be in a position to remove the tires after default.8 If the car lender perfected by compliance with a certificate-of-title statute, the accession interest is subordinate to it, and that subordination overrides both the general priority rule and the purchase-money rule.9 The tire seller's purchase-money status does not rescue it, because the seller still lacks priority over every person having an interest in the whole.
Now take a seller that financed a new motor for a tractor outside any certificate-of-title system. Accession claimants are typically purchase-money sellers or lenders, and the purchase-money rule of § 9-324 is what usually gives them priority.10 If that rule puts the seller ahead of each lender holding an interest in the tractor, and no one else holds one, the seller outranks everyone it must outrank and may take the motor out of the tractor after default. The motor seller and the tire seller differ in one respect: whether some holder of an interest in the whole ranks above them. That fact decides whether the remedy exists, and the cost of using it is the subject of the next subsection.
Paying for Physical Injury
Section 9-335(f) attaches a price to the removal right that subsection (e) grants. A secured party that removes an accession must promptly reimburse any holder of a security interest or other lien on, or owner of, the whole or the other goods, other than the debtor, for the cost of repair of any physical injury to the whole or the other goods.12 The protected group is the one the priority test looked to: the lenders and owners with a stake in the tractor, baler, or truck that the accession came out of. The debtor sits outside that group. The word promptly ties payment to the removal itself, so the repair bill is part of the cost of using the remedy. Because the duty attaches to a removal under subsection (e), it falls only on a secured party that already outranks everyone with an interest in the whole.
The statute then draws a line inside the loss that a removal can cause. The secured party pays for physical injury, but it need not reimburse the holder or owner for any diminution in value of the whole or the other goods caused by the absence of the accession or by any necessity for replacing it.13 Physical injury is something broken, cracked, or torn loose by the removal. Diminution in value means the whole is worth less, or costs money to complete again, simply because the accession is gone. Only the first is compensable.
The split tracks what each loss takes from the holder of an interest in the whole. The removing secured party outranks every such holder, so the value its accession added was never something those holders could keep against it. When the accession leaves, the whole falls back to the worth it had without it. The cracked frame is a different kind of loss, because it comes from the secured party's own exercise of its right. That is why a student should never award the lender on the whole the drop in market value after a clean removal. The usual exam error treats any financial harm to the whole as reimbursable, when only the repair of physical injury qualifies. The pattern also resembles the treatment of fixtures: an accession secured party's rights and liabilities on default are similar to those of a fixture secured party.14
The last sentence of subsection (f) protects the person owed repair costs before any damage is done. A person entitled to reimbursement may refuse permission to remove until the secured party gives adequate assurance for the performance of the obligation to reimburse.15 Once the accession has been pulled out and the frame damaged, a lender holding only a claim for repair costs would be chasing a secured party that already has what it came for. Letting the claimant withhold permission until payment is assured moves the security to the front of the process.