Concept
Removal After Default
Accessions
Removal After Default
The earlier parts of this chapter settled three questions about status: whether a lender has an interest in an accession, whether the interest is perfected, and who ranks first. A security interest may be created in an accession and continues in collateral that becomes an accession.1 If the interest was perfected when the collateral became an accession, it remains perfected afterward.2 Rank against a lender on the whole comes from the general priority rules of Part 3, with one exception: a security interest in an accession is subordinate to a security interest in the whole that is perfected by compliance with a certificate-of-title statute.3
None of those rules tells the lender what it may physically do once the debtor defaults and its collateral sits inside someone else's machine. Subsections (e) and (f) of § 9-335 answer that question, and the answer is the practical payoff of priority. After default, a secured party whose interest in the accession has priority over the interests of everyone who holds an interest in the whole or in the other goods may take the accession out of them. The engine can be pulled from the vehicle and need not be sold along with it.
A hypothetical shows how rank controls the remedy. Bank A holds a security interest in a delivery truck, perfected by notation on the certificate of title. Lender B finances a replacement engine, and the engine is installed in the truck. B's interest continues in the engine after installation, and if B was perfected when the engine became an accession, B stays perfected. B still ranks behind A, because an interest in an accession is subordinate to a whole-vehicle interest perfected under the certificate-of-title statute.4 When the debtor defaults on both loans, B cannot pull the engine out of A's truck.
The right is tied to rank because removal disturbs collateral that other lenders financed as a complete machine. A lender that ranks behind one of them has no claim to disturb it.
The right also carries a price. A secured party that removes the accession takes on a duty to compensate others for physical injury that the removal causes.
The next two parts take these points in turn: priority as the prerequisite for removal, then reimbursement for physical injury. Removal itself runs through the default rules of Part 6, which are taught in the enforcement reading. Section 9-335 covers only how those rules fit the special setting of an accession.