Concept
Certificate-of-Title Exception
Accessions
Certificate-of-Title Exception
Section 9-335(d) marks the one point where accession priority leaves the ordinary rules of Part 3.1 It provides that a security interest in an accession is subordinate to a security interest in the whole that is perfected by compliance with the requirements of a certificate-of-title statute under § 9-311(b).2 The paradigm is the titled vehicle. A debtor installs a new engine in a truck. The lender who financed the engine holds the interest in the accession, and the lender whose lien appears on the truck’s certificate of title holds the interest in the whole. If the whole’s lender perfected through the title system, it ranks first in the engine, and the usual contest over who filed first or who financed the part never gets decided.
The exception reverses results a student would otherwise reach with confidence. Under the general rules, a purchase-money financier of the engine expects to do well, and an earlier filer expects to win on timing. Neither argument survives when the whole is a titled vehicle and its lender perfected by title compliance. Every accession problem therefore carries one more step before the answer is final: ask whether the whole is a titled good and, if so, how its lender perfected.
The first subsection below defines the title method of perfection and the goods it covers, because the subordination rule is triggered only by that method. The second states the rule, shows what it displaces, and tells the component financier what to do about it.
Certificate-of-Title Systems
Perfection by title compliance replaces the Article 9 filing that lenders ordinarily use. When goods are covered by a state certificate-of-title law that requires a security interest to be indicated on the certificate, the filing provisions of Article 9 do not apply, and compliance with the title law is the equivalent of filing.3 The same is true where a state statute other than the UCC requires central filing.4 A lender in that position has its lien noted on the certificate, and a UCC filing alone is not adequate for goods covered by a title scheme that makes the notation a condition or result of perfection.5
The qualifying statute has to provide for indicating the security interest on the certificate. In a “nontitle” state, one without a certificate-of-title law that uses that indication as the means of perfection, a lender financing a motor vehicle must file a financing statement in the ordinary way.6 The title method is not limited to paper. Since 2010 the Code’s definition of “certificate of title” has covered electronic records where the relevant governmental unit permits them as an alternative to a certificate.7
Coverage depends on state law. Motor vehicles are the major items subject to these laws, in probably the majority of states,8 and a state may extend a separate title scheme to trailers, boats, and similar goods.9 A fact pattern that mentions a certificate of title, or a lien noted on one, is signaling that this method of perfection is in play.
One carve-out catches students who reach for the title system by reflex. The certificate-of-title laws do not apply to motor vehicles that are inventory held by a dealer for sale, so during that time a lender’s security interest in those vehicles is perfected by filing.10 A bank financing a dealer’s showroom cars therefore files against the inventory. The same sedan changes treatment once the dealer sells it to a customer, because it is then no longer inventory held for sale, and a lender financing the customer’s purchase perfects by having its lien noted on the certificate.
These two methods connect directly to the accession rule. Section 9-335(d) is triggered only when the lender on the whole perfected through title compliance.11 A lender on a customer’s titled truck meets that condition. A lender on a dealer’s inventory of trucks perfected by filing and sits outside the condition as written.
Subordination to the Whole
To be subordinate is to rank behind. When the whole’s lender perfected by compliance with a certificate-of-title statute under § 9-311(b), that lender is paid first out of the value of the engine, alternator, or other component, whatever the two lenders’ filing dates or purchase-money status would otherwise have produced.14 The trigger is the one the previous subsection developed: the whole’s lender must have perfected through the title system and not through an ordinary financing statement. Once that condition is met, the rule operates without any weighing of timing or of who financed which good.
The rule matters because of what it displaces. Under the ordinary Part 3 rules, a non-purchase-money security interest in equipment or consumer goods ranks by time of filing or perfection.15 A purchase-money financier of the accession can invoke the purchase-money rule of § 9-324(a) instead.16 Subsection (d) overrides the first-to-file-or-perfect rule of § 9-322 and the purchase-money rule of § 9-324 alike.17
Does a seller that has done everything the purchase-money rule requires still lose to the lender on a titled vehicle? It does, as the following facts show.
Engine Co. met every requirement of the purchase-money rule, and under the general rules that status would give it a strong claim. Subsection (d) takes the contest out of that rule because Lender’s interest in the whole is perfected through the certificate. Promptness of filing, purchase-money status, and the order of the two filings all drop out of the analysis, since the text asks only whether the whole’s lender perfected by title compliance. The answer changes when that trigger is missing. If Lender had never had its lien noted on the certificate, its interest would not be perfected by title compliance, subsection (d) would have nothing to operate on, and the ordinary Part 3 rules would decide the contest, with Engine Co.’s timely purchase-money interest well placed under them.
The rule allocates a burden, and the Code assigns it to the component financier. The party that finances a new engine for an automobile or truck should secure a subordination agreement from the lender whose name appears on the certificate of title if it wants priority over that lender.18 The allocation makes practical sense. The component financier knows from the start that it is financing a part for a titled vehicle and can read the certificate to learn who the lender is. The vehicle lender cannot know in advance which parts the debtor will later buy and install. That is also why even a purchase-money financier, the party the Code usually favors, gets no exception.
The practical consequence is simple. A lender financing an engine or similar component for a titled vehicle that wants priority over the lender named on the certificate must obtain a subordination agreement from that lender, a contract in which the vehicle lender agrees to let the component financier rank ahead of it in the accession. The agreement belongs before the credit is advanced, while the financier can still decline to lend if the vehicle lender refuses. Prompt filing within the purchase-money period will not substitute for it, because subsection (d) takes the contest out of that rule entirely.
The same rule explains a result that surprises many students. A seller that financed tires for a car, where the car is also subject to a security interest securing its own purchase price, will not generally be in a position to remove the tires after default.19 Removal depends on priority, a point developed below under “Priority as a Prerequisite,” and a seller subordinated by subsection (d) lacks that priority. Close calls about whether a part counts as an accession will often fall on the accession side, because Comment 2 to § 9-335 directs many of the hard classification cases into the accession category.20 The subordination rule can therefore reach more installed parts than a narrow reading of “accession” suggests.