Concept
Priority Under the General Rules
Accessions
Priority Under the General Rules
Section 9-335(c) gives accessions no ranking system of their own. It sends you to the rest of the Code: except as subsection (d) provides, the other provisions of the same part of Article 9 (Part 3) determine the priority of a security interest in an accession.1 Earlier sections of this chapter explain how an interest in an accession arises and what happens to it after installation. Subsection (c) answers a different question: when two secured parties claim the same accession, which one ranks first?
The answer is the same one you would give for any other collateral. A lender on the accession and a lender on the whole are two competing secured parties, and the general priority rules apply to them. Physically attaching one item to another does not alter those rules. The attachment explains why the two lenders are in a dispute, but it does not decide who wins.
The working method has two steps. First, run the ordinary Part 3 priority analysis as you would for any two secured parties claiming the same collateral. Second, check whether subsection (d) displaces that analysis. Subsection (d) is a narrow exception, and it applies only when the whole is covered by a certificate-of-title statute. In that setting, a security interest in the accession is subordinate to a security interest in the whole that is perfected by compliance with the certificate-of-title statute under Section 9-311(b).2
Here is how the exception works. Suppose a lender finances a new engine that is later installed in a truck, and a different lender's interest in the truck is perfected by compliance with the truck's certificate-of-title statute. Under subsection (d), the engine lender is subordinate to the truck lender, so you never reach the general rules. Without a titled whole perfected in that way, the general rules of Part 3 decide the contest. The next section takes up the certificate-of-title exception in detail.