Concept
Perfection After Installation
Accessions
Perfection After Installation
A security interest that is perfected when its collateral becomes an accession stays perfected afterward.1 That is the rule of § 9-335(b), and it completes what subsection (a) begins. Subsection (a) tells the lender that its interest still exists after installation; subsection (b) tells it that the interest keeps its standing. Perfection supplies that standing against competing creditors: the lender has taken the public step Article 9 requires, usually by filing a financing statement or taking possession, and in a few situations merely by letting the interest attach. An interest that survived the union but lost its perfection would be exposed in every later contest, and the survival rule would be worth little.
The rule works in three events, in order: the lender perfects, the debtor installs the collateral, and the interest is still perfected afterward. The standard tractor problem shows the sequence. S1 holds a perfected security interest in a tractor. The debtor then buys a new motor from S2, grants S2 an interest in the motor, and installs it in the tractor.2 Add one fact: S2 files a financing statement on the motor before the installation. S2 was perfected when the motor became an accession, so it remains perfected in the motor afterward. It need not refile against the tractor, amend its financing statement, or notify S1. The method of perfection does not alter the result, because a filed interest, a possessory interest, and an automatically perfected interest are all carried forward alike.
Remaining perfected does not mean winning. S1 and S2 now contest the motor under the regular priority rules, and an accession lender that financed the component gains the preference given to purchase-money security interests.3 Whether the first-to-file-or-perfect rule or the purchase-money rule controls is a question for the priority discussion that follows.4
Carrying perfection through the union makes sense for two reasons. First, perfection rests on public steps that do not depend on where the goods sit. A financing statement is a notice on a public record that identifies the debtor by exact full legal name,5 and bolting the motor into a tractor changes neither the debtor nor the record, so anyone who searches still finds the notice. Second, a reperfection requirement would open a gap. The debtor alone performs the installation, can do it on any day, and has no reason to tell the lender; a lender required to refile would often not know its time had started to run, and a competing creditor could step ahead in the meantime. The Code's general approach points the same way, because it treats perfection as continuous so long as no period passes in which it was lost.6 Installation creates no such period, so the lender keeps its original perfection date. That date matters because the first-to-file-or-perfect rule ranks competing interests by when each lender filed or perfected.7
The statute fixes the moment at which the lender's status is examined: the interest must be perfected when the collateral becomes an accession. A lender perfected at that moment is carried forward. A lender that has done nothing public by then gets no help from subsection (b), so an exam question should ask what the lender's status was on the day of installation.
S2 in the tractor problem and the pump lender each held an attached interest in a component that the debtor later installed. They differ only in whether a public step preceded the installation, and that single fact produces the different outcomes. The rule must therefore be applied as a question of timing.
Automatic perfection counts as perfection for this purpose. A purchase-money security interest in consumer goods is perfected as soon as it attaches, so a seller that financed a consumer's replacement part and never filed is still perfected after the consumer installs it. The rule is narrow, because both a purchase-money interest and consumer goods are required: a purchase-money interest in equipment is not automatically perfected, and neither is a non-purchase-money interest in consumer goods.8 Nor does automatic perfection reach a motor vehicle bought for personal or family use, where the lender must file or comply with a state certificate-of-title law.9 The same may hold for consumer goods such as boats, trailers, and mobile homes that a title statute covers.10 The certificate-of-title section below takes up how title-statute perfection interacts with accessions.
Creating an Interest in an Accession
Perfection presupposes an interest that exists, and § 9-335(a) supplies it in two clauses, one on creation and one on continuation. The first clause provides that a security interest may be created in an accession.12 An accession keeps its separate identity after it is joined to other goods, so it remains a distinct item that a debtor can offer as collateral and a lender can take as security. The clause therefore adds no requirement for creating the interest: whether a lender holds an enforceable interest in a motor, an alternator, or a memory module depends on the same test of attachment that governs any goods. Attachment is the moment a security interest becomes enforceable against the debtor.
That test has three requirements. The lender must have given value, the debtor must have rights in the goods, and the debtor must have authenticated a security agreement that describes the collateral.13 The third carries the most weight in accession problems, because a lender without possession or control of the goods has no other way to identify its collateral, so the agreement itself must describe it.14 A lender that sold the debtor a replacement motor on credit will ordinarily hold an agreement describing that motor, and that agreement is the vehicle for its interest in the accession.
Treating the accession as ordinary goods at the creation stage protects component credit. Sellers and lenders routinely finance a component, keep a security interest in it, and extend credit because the component itself stands behind the loan. If the debtor's power to install the component in something else cast doubt on whether the interest could exist, no component lender could rely on its collateral. Sending the creation question back to the usual attachment requirements removes that doubt: the lender checks its own paperwork and need not know what the debtor plans to do with the goods.
The clause speaks of goods that are already accessions, so it covers a lender who takes its interest after installation. A component still in its crate is ordinary goods under the same attachment rules, and the continuation clause carries that interest through installation. Either way, the hinge is the paperwork.
Because the accession keeps its own identity, an exam stem that describes the motor as part of the tractor has not put the motor beyond the reach of the motor lender. The tractor lender may hold an interest in the whole and the motor lender holds its own interest in the motor, so both can claim the same item and the regular priority rules govern the conflict.15 Creation settles only whether each claimant has something to assert; which claimant prevails is a priority question taken up later in this chapter.
Continuation After Union
The second clause of § 9-335(a) provides that a security interest continues in collateral that becomes an accession.17 It protects a lender whose interest attached while the goods were still separate, before the debtor installed them in anything. Installation leaves that interest intact, and it keeps attaching to the same goods, which now sit inside a larger object. The creation clause covers goods that are already accessions when the interest is granted. This clause covers the more common sequence: the lender finances a component, the debtor takes delivery, and the debtor later bolts the component onto something else.
The rule follows from the fact that installation is the debtor's own act. The debtor chooses when and where to install the component, and the lender is rarely present. If installation extinguished the interest, a debtor could turn secured property into unsecured property with a wrench, and a lender that had given value and obtained a proper agreement would lose its collateral through no fault of its own. The accession keeps its separate identity after the union, which is the test that defines an accession, so installation does not turn the motor into a different item from the one the lender financed. It changes only where the motor sits. Continuation of the interest follows.
What continues is the interest in the accession, and the clause reaches no further. The interest does not spread into the whole. The lender on the whole made its own bargain under its own agreement describing the tractor, and the lender on the component never bargained for the tractor and was never offered it. If a component lender's interest swelled to cover every machine its component was bolted into, it would collect collateral the debtor never granted it, and every lender on the whole would face claims it could not discover from its own paperwork.
The standard problem for this clause shows the interest surviving the union. S1 takes a security interest in a tractor on February 1 and perfects the same day. On March 1 the debtor buys a new motor from S2, gives S2 a security interest in the motor, and installs it in the tractor.18 S2's interest attached to the motor when the debtor bought it, and it continues in the motor after installation. The contest between S1 and S2 is then a priority question, and because S2 financed the motor itself, the purchase-money rule, taken up in a later section, is the one S2 invokes. Continuation did the earlier job of keeping S2's interest alive, so that there is something to rank.
The accession rule has a boundary, and the sand-to-glass illustration marks it. A lender holds an attached interest in a debtor's inventory of sand, and the debtor melts the sand into glass. The sand's individual identity is now subsumed in the product, so the goods are commingled goods and § 9-335(a) does not apply. The lender's interest attaches to the glass under § 9-336(c), even though the security agreement never describes glass.19 The two outcomes differ because of identity. Where the component can still be told apart from the rest, the interest stays with the component, as with the motor. Where identity is lost, nothing remains for the interest to attach to, so it moves into the product or mass. Some cases sit on the border between the two rules, but they are probably few, and Comment 2 to § 9-335 directs many of the hard ones into the accession category.20
Continuation preserves the interest in the accession and says nothing about how that interest ranks against the lender on the whole. The other priority rules in Article 9 answer that question, subject to one exception for goods covered by a certificate-of-title statute.21 The first part of this unit showed that the interest keeps its perfected status through the union, and the next sections apply the priority rules to the contest between the component lender and the lender on the whole.