Concept
Fixture Filings
First-to-record fixture-filing priority
Fixture Filings
A secured party who wants to beat a mortgagee or buyer of the land cannot rely on an ordinary filing. One condition of the first-to-record exception is that the security interest be perfected by a fixture filing before the interest of the encumbrancer or owner is of record.1 That makes the filing the first thing to check in any fixture dispute. A secured party with no fixture filing has no recorded notice to measure against the land claimant's timeline. Its central filing is totally ineffective against purchasers of the real property and mortgagees, so it stays in the subordinate position the baseline assigns.2 The exception's other conditions, which concern the debtor's connection to the land and the secured party's standing against earlier owners, come after the filing itself.
Mortgagees and purchasers are the land-side claimants a fixture secured party most often meets. Statutory lienors on the land add variations of their own; mechanic's lien statutes, for example, take sharply different approaches to how much a lien claimant may recover.3
A fixture filing is a financing statement, the same notice device Article 9 uses for all collateral, made in a different office and carrying added content.4 The adaptation follows from who must receive the notice. A buyer or lender dealing with a parcel searches the title records for that parcel, and a financing statement kept only in a statewide personal-property file never turns up in that search.5 The fixture filing puts the claim against attached goods where the title searcher will find it. Both questions a student must answer, where the filing goes and what it must say, follow from that purpose. A filing in an office the searcher never opens, or one that never tells the searcher it concerns goods attached to the land, gives the notice the priority rule depends on to no one. The first-to-record rule, taught next, assumes a valid fixture filing, so the mechanics come first.
Where to File
Article 9 offers two offices for goods that are or will become fixtures, and the character of the filing decides between them. Under § 9-501(a), a financing statement goes to the office designated for filing or recording a mortgage on the related real property when it is filed as a fixture filing covering goods that are or are to become fixtures. In all other cases it goes to the central office the state designates.6 One court put the choice in practical terms: a secured party perfecting in goods that are or will become fixtures should file in the county registry of deeds if the filing is to be a fixture filing, or with the Secretary of State.7
The office rule answers two different ways a searcher could miss the notice. The first is the choice of office. Placing the fixture filing where a mortgage on the parcel would be recorded puts it in the files the searcher will actually open. The second is findability. The filing must be made in the real-estate records of that office in a way that lets someone searching the title locate it.8 A document left in the right building but out of reach of a title searcher supplies no more notice than one filed in the wrong building.
Among competing personal-property claimants, Article 9 generally favors whoever filed or perfected first, with important exceptions in which a later perfecter prevails.9 A security interest in fixtures can be perfected by an ordinary financing statement filed centrally, as with other goods, but that perfection is totally ineffective against purchasers of the real property and mortgagees. Its value lies against other personal-property claimants. In the standard illustration, Secured Party I takes a security interest in an air-conditioning unit to be installed in a house and files only an ordinary financing statement with the Secretary of State. Secured Party II later takes a security interest in the same unit and files both an ordinary financing statement and a fixture filing. Secured Party I still has priority, because the contest is between two personal-property claimants and I filed first. Against a purchaser or mortgagee of the house, however, Secured Party I has no rights.10
The two kinds of filing also look in different directions. A central filing goes to the central office of the debtor's location, while a fixture filing goes to the real-estate recording office for the land where the fixture sits.11 Dave Debtor runs A-1 Appliances in Kansas City, Missouri, but lives across the river in Kansas City, Kansas, so a central filing against him belongs in Kansas.12 If Dave buys a walk-in cooler for a store in Missouri, a fixture filing for the cooler would go to the real-estate records there. Because fixtures are tied to land, the law of the state where the land lies governs perfection by fixture filing, the same rule that applies to timber to be cut.13 A secured party financing equipment for a building in another state must therefore look to the recording system of the state where the building stands, whatever the debtor's home state. One narrow exception departs from the real-estate office rule: when the debtor is a transmitting utility, filing occurs at a designated central location even if the collateral is fixtures.14
The office rule gives the first-to-record exception its footing. The exception asks whether the security interest was perfected by a fixture filing before the interest of the encumbrancer or owner is of record.15 Both halves of that comparison are measured in the same set of records, because the fixture filing and the mortgagee's or purchaser's interest each appear in the real-estate records, so the question of who got there first has an answer. A central filing, however early, is not a fixture filing and starts no clock against the land claimant. Any timeline problem therefore begins with one question: did the secured party file in the real-estate records for the land?
What the Filing Contains
A fixture filing must satisfy two layers of content rules, both found in § 9-502.17 Subsection (a) supplies what every financing statement carries, beginning with the names of the debtor and of the secured party or its representative.18 Subsection (b) adds the fixture-specific content. The 1999 Code authorizes electronic filing, so the statement need not be on paper, but the added content is required whatever the form.19 Under subsection (b), the filing must:
- state that it covers goods that are or are to become fixtures;
- recite that it is to be filed in the real-estate records;
- describe the real property; and
- give the name of a record owner of the real property if the debtor has no interest of record in it.20
The previous subsection put the filing in the office where a title searcher will look. These four items decide whether the searcher, once there, can recognize the filing and tie it to the parcel under examination. Land records are organized around parcels and around the names in each parcel's chain of title, so a searcher reaches a document through the land description or the record owner's name.21 Nobody searches under the name of whoever bought a boiler for the building. The description of the real property anchors the filing to the parcel. The record owner's name supplies, when the debtor is not an owner of record, the name under which the searcher would actually look. The statement that the goods are fixtures and the recital that the filing belongs in the real-estate records tell the searcher what the document claims and where it is meant to operate. A filing that omits any one of them can sit in the right office and still be unfindable by the people it is supposed to bind.
The description of the land need not be a special Article 9 invention. It is sufficient if it complies with the real property filing rules of the jurisdiction.22 The test is therefore the local recording system's own, so the description should be one that system accepts for the parcel.
The fourth item ties the filing to the debtor's own status. A debtor that owns the land, or holds another interest recorded against it, can be found in the land records under its own name. A tenant in possession under an unrecorded lease cannot, because nothing in the title chain mentions the tenant. For that debtor the filing gives the name of a record owner, which points the searcher to the chain of title where the filing will be discovered.23 The same debtor status is the opening condition of the first-to-record exception: the debtor must have an interest of record in the real property or be in possession of it.24 Possession alone therefore qualifies a lessee for that condition, and the record owner's name makes the notice findable. A debtor with neither, such as a contractor with no hold on the land, fails the requirement, and a fixture secured party cannot defeat real estate interests by taking a security interest from that kind of debtor.25