Concept
Applying the Test
Purchase-money fixture priority
Applying the Test
Section 9-334(d) asks its questions in an order that works as a method. A perfected security interest in fixtures beats a conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the real property when the debtor has an interest of record in the land or is in possession of it and three further conditions are met, all subject to subsection (h).1 That one sentence holds the whole problem: who the competing claimant is, what kind of creditor is claiming, how the debtor is tied to the land, when each event happened, and what record the creditor made. Running the questions in the statute's order on one set of facts, and changing one fact at a time, shows what each condition tests and where a problem is most likely to turn.
Two threshold questions come first. The goods must be fixtures, meaning goods so affixed to realty that they have characteristics of both personal and real property, because that status is what sets an Article 9 secured party against someone who holds an interest in the land.2 The opponent must also be the right kind of claimant. Subsection (d) governs contests with an encumbrancer or owner of the real property, most often a purchaser or a mortgagee. A lien creditor is a different opponent, governed by § 9-317: a perfected secured party generally beats a lien creditor if it acted to protect its rights before the lien arose, and an unperfected secured party loses to a creditor whose lien arises first.3
A solver can run the problem in seven steps, taking the statute's conditions in order and leaving the override and the fallback routes for last.
One set of facts will carry the method. O owns a lot and gave M a mortgage on it, which M recorded on March 1. On April 1, O bought a heater from S, and S kept a security interest to secure the price. The heater was installed and became a fixture on April 15, and S made a fixture filing in the real estate records on May 1.11 The heater is a fixture, and M is the opponent. S's interest secures the price, so it is purchase-money, and O holds record title, so the debtor's interest of record is satisfied. M's interest arose about six weeks before the heater became a fixture. S's record is a fixture filing, and May 1 falls 16 days after April 15, inside a window that closes on May 5. Nothing suggests a construction mortgage, so no override applies. S outranks M even though M recorded two months earlier.
The instinct that loses points is to treat any filing made within 20 days as enough. Suppose S's only record is an ordinary financing statement in the central filing office. That filing perfects S's interest in the usual way, but it is totally ineffective against purchasers of the real property and mortgagees. To reach them, S must make a fixture filing, whose contents and location differ from those of other filings.12 The filing condition fails, subsection (d) is closed to S, and without a fixture filing S cannot show a filing ahead of M's recording either, so M prevails.13
How late may S file and still beat a mortgagee? That depends on which mortgagee. Against M, whose interest predates affixation, S must file by May 5. A filing on May 15 misses the window, the purchase-money route closes, and the contest returns to who filed or recorded first, which M won in March.14 Against a lender whose mortgage arrives after S's fixture filing, lateness costs nothing. In the standard illustration, a seller who filed 25 days after installation beat a bank that obtained and recorded its mortgage five weeks later.15 Condition (d)(2) concerns only claimants whose interests arose before the goods became fixtures, so the 20 days decide the outcome against a claimant already in place. Against a claimant who arrives later, what counts is who filed or recorded first, with the debtor holding an interest in the land or possession of it.16
The kind of mortgage is the next variable. Suppose a bank recorded a construction mortgage on a house, and a furnace was then installed during the construction process. S made a fixture filing 15 days after installation. Every condition of subsection (d) is met, and S still loses to the bank under the construction mortgage.17 The example stresses that the furnace went in during construction because that detail brings the exception into play: as the construction-mortgage discussion above explained, the exception reaches goods that become fixtures before construction is complete. A furnace added after the house was finished would send the problem back to the (d) analysis.
The debtor's tie to the land is the last variable. It hides in the heater facts because O holds record title, but the opening clause does real work when the buyer is someone other than the owner.
A tenant who occupies the house reaches the opposite result on this condition, because possession satisfies the opening clause without a recorded lease. A debtor has an interest of record only if it owns the property or holds a recorded lease, so a tenant with an unrecorded lease has none, and the supplier's fixture filing must then include the name of the record owner.19
A creditor that fails a condition has not necessarily lost. The failure closes the purchase-money route and sends the problem to the other priority rules. Purchase-money status is the fork the general priority analysis turns on: a creditor whose interest is not purchase-money cannot use (d), and in other settings non-purchase-money interests rank by time of filing or perfection.20 So a seller who filed 30 days after installation should be tested against each opponent's recording date before anyone declares a winner. A creditor that is not first to file can still rank ahead if the holder of the earlier recorded interest consents to its interest in the fixture.21
A lender who plans ahead need not win these contests. Recording the fixture filing before the goods arrive makes the 20-day count and the affixation date irrelevant, because the statute rewards a filing made before the goods become fixtures.22 A lender financing equipment for a building under construction should also search the real estate records for a construction mortgage before extending credit, since that is a record that can defeat an otherwise complete showing under subsection (d). Where priority remains doubtful, the lender should ask the earlier encumbrancer for consent.23