Concept
Construction Mortgage Exception
Purchase-money fixture priority
Construction Mortgage Exception
A purchase-money creditor can satisfy every condition of the fixture priority rule and still lose to the lender that financed the building. Perfection and a timely filing carry a secured party a long way in a priority contest; a perfected secured creditor, for instance, generally beats a lien creditor whose lien arrives after the secured party has protected its rights.1 In the fixture setting, subsection (h) of § 9-334 marks the limit of that strength. The purchase-money priority of subsection (d) opens with the words “Except as otherwise provided in subsection (h),” and this exception is what those words point to.2
Subsection (h) begins with a definition. A mortgage is a construction mortgage to the extent that it secures an obligation incurred for the construction of an improvement on land, including the acquisition cost of the land, if a recorded record of the mortgage so indicates.3 Work the time line for the purchase-money test first. The construction mortgage exception is the check that follows, and it can reverse a result that a timely fixture filing seemed to secure.
The subordination rule then follows. Except as subsections (e) and (f) provide otherwise, a security interest in fixtures is subordinate to a construction mortgage if a record of the mortgage is recorded before the goods become fixtures and the goods become fixtures before the construction is completed.4 Three events therefore decide the matter, and they must fall in one order: the mortgage is recorded, the goods become fixtures, and the construction is completed. Affixation is the pivot. Recording must come before it, and completion must come after it. If either condition fails, the exception does not apply, and the fixture creditor's priority is tested without it.
The exception guards against double-financing. A builder obtains funds from the construction mortgagee to purchase goods and then buys the same fixtures on credit from a supplier, so that two lenders have financed one set of goods.5 Without the exception, the supplier's purchase-money priority could carry those goods ahead of the mortgagee whose advances may already have paid for them. The supplier can avoid the problem by looking first: a supplier that sells on credit for installation in a house or building under construction should check the real estate records before allowing the credit sale.6
Each phrase of the definition does separate work. The words to the extent confine construction-mortgage status to the part of the debt that secures a construction obligation, so a mortgage that also secures an unrelated loan carries the priority of (h) only for its construction portion.7 The inclusion of land acquisition cost means that a single loan that buys the lot and pays for the building is one construction obligation. The third phrase, the recorded indication, is the easiest to overlook. A lender whose loan in fact paid for construction, but whose recorded mortgage says nothing about construction, holds an ordinary mortgage for purposes of (h), and a supplier with a timely fixture filing keeps its purchase-money priority. The requirement fits the search that the supplier is expected to make anyway, because a supplier that checks the real estate records can see from the recorded mortgage itself whether construction financing is in place.8 Each of these conditions is written into the statute and should be applied as written. Other doctrines work differently; the elements of adverse possession, for example, are a judge-made gloss on statutes of limitations.9
A mortgage given to refinance a construction mortgage has the same priority to the extent of the refinancing.10 That carry-over keeps a refinancing from reopening a contest that the construction mortgage had already won.
A construction mortgage should not be confused with a mechanic’s lien. Mechanic’s lien statutes take differing approaches to how much a lien claimant may recover; some states, following the New York system, limit recovery to the balance due on the general construction contract on the date the lien is filed.11 Subsection (h) speaks of mortgages and does not turn on those rules.
The standard illustration shows the checklist at work. State Bank records its construction mortgage on a house. SP-1 then finances the debtor’s purchase of a furnace, which is installed during construction and is a fixture under state law once installed. SP-1 files an effective fixture financing statement in the county real estate records 15 days after installation. SP-1’s purchase-money security interest in the furnace does not have priority over State Bank’s interest under the construction mortgage rule.13 The filing fell inside the 20-day window, so lateness is not the problem. SP-1 loses because the mortgage was recorded before the furnace became a fixture and the furnace became a fixture before the house was complete.
The completion condition marks the point at which the rationale for the exception ends. Once the building is finished, a new item is an addition to the property and no longer part of the project the construction lender financed. The rule accordingly does not apply where additions are made to a building after completion and are financed under an open-end clause of a construction mortgage or a refinancing mortgage.14 Seeing the word construction in a recorded mortgage and awarding the lender priority, without asking when the goods became fixtures, skips the condition on which clinic-type problems turn.
Subsection (h) does not defeat every fixture creditor. The subordination rule operates “except as otherwise provided in subsections (e) and (f),” so a supplier with priority under either subsection keeps it against a construction mortgagee.15 Under (e)(1), a security interest has priority over the interest of the owner or encumbrancer if the secured party perfected by a filed fixture financing statement before that interest was recorded in the real estate records, the security interest has priority over the interest of the predecessor in title to the owner or encumbrancer, and the debtor has an interest in or is in possession of the real estate.16 Subsection (f) gives a security interest in fixtures priority, whether or not perfected, over an encumbrancer or owner who has consented in writing to the security interest or has disclaimed an interest in the goods as fixtures, and also where the debtor has a right to remove the goods as against the encumbrancer or owner.17 Each provision has conditions of its own and is read on its own terms. Test (d), then (h), and then return to (e) and (f) before declaring the construction lender the winner.
The practical consequence falls on the fixture supplier. Before extending credit for goods that will go into a building under construction, the supplier should search the real estate records, and if the search discloses a construction mortgage that satisfies (h), its route to priority runs through the mortgagee’s written consent to the supplier’s security interest under (f).18