Concept
Working the Time Line
Purchase-money fixture priority
Working the Time Line
Section 9-334(d) gives a perfected security interest in fixtures priority over a conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the real property, but only when the debtor has an interest of record in or possession of the land and the subsection's further conditions are met.1 Two of those conditions concern status: the debtor's tie to the land, and whether the creditor's interest is purchase-money.2 The other two concern dates, and they compare three events: the day the competing real-property interest arose, the day the goods became fixtures, and the day the fixture filing was made.3 Affixation sits in the middle of that line and anchors both date tests. The competing interest must be older than affixation, and the filing must come before affixation or within 20 days after it. A problem that looks like a tangle of mortgages, assignments, and installation dates shrinks to one short comparison once the three dates are written down in order.
The status steps come first because they eliminate a creditor without any counting. A creditor that fails step 5 or step 6 has lost only the purchase-money route. Outside that route, priority turns on who filed or recorded first, so the creditor wins if its fixture filing came before the competitor's recording.9 Test the creditor against the competitor's recording date before calling the contest.
A standard heater problem shows the steps at work. An owner who holds record title mortgaged the building to a lender on March 1, and the lender recorded that day. On April 1 the owner bought a heater and gave the seller a security interest to secure the price. The heater became a fixture on installation April 15, and the seller made a fixture filing on May 1. Laid out as a time line, the facts read:
- March 1: the mortgage arises and is recorded.
- April 1: the owner buys the heater and signs the security agreement.
- April 15: the heater is installed and becomes a fixture.
- May 1: the seller makes the fixture filing, 16 days after affixation.
- May 5: 20 days after affixation, the outer edge of the window.
The owner holds the land and the seller kept its interest to secure the price, so steps 1 and 2 are met. The mortgage is 45 days older than affixation, so step 5 is met, and a filing 16 days after affixation sits well inside a window that closes May 5. The seller therefore outranks the mortgagee. The seller does not win under the first-to-record rule, because the mortgage was recorded 61 days before the seller filed. It wins only through the purchase-money route.
The same answer holds against an assignee of the mortgage. The assignee takes the mortgagee's place, so the date that counts at step 3 is the date the mortgage arose, not the date of the assignment, and a seller that beats the mortgagee beats the assignee as well.10 The converse is the source's own example. A purchase-money interest that is not filed as a fixture filing within 20 days after the fixture is installed is subordinate to a prior recorded mortgage, and also to the mortgage's assignee even though the assignment is recorded after the fixture filing.11 On the heater facts, a seller that filed on May 15, 30 days after affixation, would miss the window. The mortgagee would prevail, and so would the assignee.
Only the June 28 anchor produces that answer. Counting from the June 1 agreement puts the filing 44 days out, and counting from the June 10 delivery puts it 35 days out. Either count would wrongly give the cooler to the bank. Signing, delivery, and the bank's recording all sit on the time line, and each tempts a solver to start counting there, but only affixation starts the 20 days. A seller that waited until July 20 would be 22 days past affixation and outside the window, and the bank, which recorded first, would prevail.
One check remains after the dates line up. The opening clause of subsection (d) subordinates the priority to subsection (h), and a construction mortgage can defeat a seller that meets every condition above.12 In the standard illustration, a house is built under a construction mortgage, and a seller that financed a furnace installed during construction files an effective fixture financing statement 15 days after installation. That filing falls inside the 20-day window, yet the seller still loses to the bank.13 The answer reached at step 6 is therefore provisional until step 7 has been run, and the next section takes up that limit.