Concept
Applying the Rule
General subordination to real-property interests
Applying the Rule
Every fixture priority question either ends at UCC § 9-334(c) or never reaches it, and the work lies in deciding which. The subsection provides that, in cases not governed by subsections (d) through (h), a security interest in fixtures is subordinate to the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the related real property other than the debtor.1 Its opening clause fixes the order of the analysis. The default has no one to lose to unless a land-side claimant exists, and it applies only after every exception has been tried and has failed.
The first check comes first because § 9-334 settles a collision between two property systems, and a collision needs two parties. When real property law gives a land-side party an interest in the goods, a conflict arises and § 9-334 states the priorities.2 The check therefore has two parts. Goods may be fixtures with no mortgagee, owner, or other land-side party claiming them, and a mortgagee may exist whose lien does not reach the goods under local law. In either case there is no conflict for the section to resolve.
The second check precedes the default because each exception takes its case out of subsection (c) altogether, and a lender who stops at the default has skipped the provisions most likely to help. Screen the way a land-side claimant would look at the facts. A purchase-money security interest in fixtures, for example, has priority over the interest of an encumbrancer or owner that arose before the goods became fixtures, if the lender perfects by a fixture filing before the goods become fixtures or within 20 days afterward, and the debtor must have an interest of record in the real estate or be in possession.3 A lender whose fixture filing is made before anyone other than the debtor records an interest in the land has first priority against a person with a later-recorded interest, and a lender who is behind an interest already of record can obtain that person's consent to the lender's interest in the fixtures.4 The other grounds in subsections (d) through (h), including those that turn on the kind of goods and on the debtor's right to remove them, belong on the same checklist.
Only when every ground fails does the third check apply, and at that point perfection drops out of the analysis. Subsection (c) draws no line between perfected and unperfected security interests, so a lender with a central filing loses to the land-side claimant just as a lender with no filing at all does. An answer that stops at the word perfected has not yet looked at the land-side claimant.
Computer Systems, Inc. shows all three checks on one set of facts. It uses a building in Story County, Iowa, as its only retail store. On January 4 it granted Real Estate Moguls, Inc. a mortgage on the building, and Real Estate Moguls recorded the mortgage on January 5 in the Story County real estate records.5 Now add two facts. In March a lender finances a generator wired into the store, and the lender files a financing statement only in the central filing office. Assume the generator is a fixture and that the mortgage reaches it under local real property law. The first check is satisfied: the goods are fixtures, and a mortgagee other than the debtor has an interest in them.
The second check fails on every ground. The lender made no fixture filing, so the purchase-money exception, which depends on one, is out of reach, and the lender cannot claim to have filed first in the land records, because the mortgage was recorded on January 5.6 Nothing in the facts shows a consent signed by Real Estate Moguls or a right in Computer Systems to remove the generator as against the mortgagee. The third check therefore controls. The mortgage outranks the lender, and the central filing does not change that. It perfects against other secured parties, but it protects against real estate claimants only in narrow cases, and a mortgagee is not among them.7
A stem full of installed equipment does not by itself engage the method, because the method needs a land-side claimant. Suppose a retailer's cash registers are claimed by a lender with a perfected security interest, a second secured party, and a buyer, and no mortgagee or other person claiming through the land asserts anything. The registers may well be fixtures, but with no real-property claimant there is no conflict for § 9-334 to settle, and subsection (c) is never reached.8 So long as no person claiming an interest in a fixture has an interest in the real property, the normal rules of perfection and priority apply, and perfection is by filing a financing statement with the Secretary of State.9 The two secured parties rank by the first-to-file-or-perfect rule.10 If the buyer is a buyer in ordinary course of business under UCC § 1-201(b)(9), it takes the registers free of both security interests under § 9-320.11 The generator and the registers are comparable goods in comparable stores. One fact sends them to different bodies of law: whether a land-side claimant exists.
A lender controls only what it does before the loan funds, so the same method, read from the lender's side, yields a pre-funding checklist with one move for each kind of opponent.
Each move answers a step in the analysis. The lender chooses between a fixture filing in the local real estate records and a regular filing in the personal property records at the state capital, and the choice matters. The former protects against certain real estate claimants. The latter protects only against lien creditors and certain other claimants where the fixture is not important to mortgagees and the like.16 Subsection (e)(3), for instance, puts a lender with only a personal property filing ahead of the trustee in bankruptcy, on the theory that a lien creditor does not rely on the real estate records.17 A central filing alone therefore leaves the lender behind a mortgage already of record, as the generator hypothetical showed. The consent move exists for that case, and a lender who makes neither move reaches the third check on the wrong side of the mortgage.