Concept
Why Classification Matters
Fixture status and Article 9 coverage
Why Classification Matters
Whether goods are fixtures decides which priority rules govern a contest over them. Article 9 lets a security interest be created in goods that are fixtures and continue in goods that become fixtures.1 But a fixture is, by definition, a good so related to particular real property that an interest in it arises under real property law.2 Someone besides the secured party therefore holds a claim to the same item: an encumbrancer or an owner of the real estate. If real property law gives those parties no interest in the goods, no conflict exists, and the ordinary personal property rules settle who ranks first. If it does give them an interest, a conflict arises, and § 9-334 supplies the priorities.3 Classification is what sends the dispute there.
The starting point in § 9-334 is a default rule: a security interest in fixtures is subordinate to the conflicting claim of an encumbrancer or owner of the real estate, other than the debtor.4 Several exceptions qualify the rule, so it governs whenever none of them applies. The drafters tied the rule to how land claimants protect themselves. Those who take later interests in real estate typically check the real estate files and only those files, so a secured party that wants priority over them must file where a mortgage on the land would be recorded.5 A claim recorded only in a central personal property file lies outside the search such a claimant runs.
That reasoning explains why filing a financing statement in the central office, as for other goods, perfects a security interest in fixtures but protects little. The central filing is totally ineffective against purchasers of the real property and against mortgagees. To reach anyone with an interest in the real property, the secured party must make a fixture filing. Both its contents and its location differ from a filing for other collateral.6 Which filing a secured party needs depends on the opponent, because the Code offers two ways to file for goods that are or are to become fixtures, according to the parties against whom protection is sought.7
A cited illustration shows the two results from a single filing. Secured Party I takes a security interest in an air conditioning unit that is to be installed in a house and become a fixture. It files only an ordinary financing statement with the Secretary of State. Secured Party II later takes a security interest in the same unit and files both an ordinary financing statement and a fixture filing. Secured Party I still has priority over Secured Party II, because the contest is between two Article 9 claimants. Against a purchaser or mortgagee of the house, however, Secured Party I has no rights.8
Fixture status is often uncertain under local real property law, and that uncertainty complicates the secured party's choice of where to file. The Code deals with it directly. A secured party may make a fixture filing as a precaution, and a court may not infer from the filing alone that the secured party concedes the goods are or will become fixtures.9 If a precautionary filing counted as an admission, caution would cost the secured party its argument that the goods are not fixtures.
Two mistakes recur on exams: assuming that a central filing defeats a mortgagee of the land, and reading a fixture filing as proof that the secured party agrees the goods are fixtures.