Concept
Fixtures and Related Collateral
Fixture status and Article 9 coverage
Fixtures and Related Collateral
A fixture is a condition that real property law attaches to certain goods, not a class of collateral that stands beside the Article 9 categories. Section 9-102(a)(41) begins from the word goods: fixtures are goods so related to particular real property that an interest in them arises under real property law.1 Section 9-334(a) accepts the same premise by allowing a security interest to be created in goods that are fixtures and to continue in goods that become fixtures.2 Earlier sections showed how to tell whether the condition exists. This section asks where fixtures sit among their neighbors, so that the label is not stretched over collateral that merely resembles them.
Three shortcuts tempt students here, and each fails. The first treats an installed item as nothing but a fixture, as though fixture status replaced the ordinary Article 9 categories. The second assumes that anything tied to land, a growing crop for example, must be a fixture. The third assumes that anything built into something else, a part in a machine for example, must be a fixture. The subsections below answer them in that order.
Each answer turns on two questions: what the goods are, and what they are joined to. The answers lead to different provisions of Article 9, so a mistake at the classification step sends the whole analysis to the wrong rules.
Equipment and Consumer Goods
The Code's list of things that count as goods names fixtures, alongside crops growing or to be grown, standing timber to be cut and removed under a sales contract, and the unborn young of animals.3 A fixture is therefore goods first, and it remains subject to the use-based classes that Article 9 applies to goods generally. Two of those classes matter here. Consumer goods are goods used or bought for use primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.4 Equipment is the residual class: goods other than inventory, farm products, or consumer goods.5
The use classes and the fixture label ask different questions, so one item of collateral answers both. The use classes ask who is using the goods and for what. The fixture label asks whether the goods have become related to particular land. A heating unit attached to an office building is therefore both a fixture and equipment; the same kind of unit attached to a home is both a fixture and consumer goods. Had either unit never been attached, it would simply be equipment or consumer goods.6
Keeping the labels cumulative makes structural sense. Article 9 attaches different rules to goods according to their class, and if the fixture label displaced the class, an installed furnace would sit in no class at all, leaving the rules for business goods and household goods with nothing to govern. Cumulative labels give the fixture the rules of its ordinary class and add the real estate rules on top. Filing shows the second layer at work. To take first priority in fixtures, the secured party files a fixture financing statement in the real estate recording office for the land where the fixtures sit, and a filing made before anyone other than the debtor records an interest in the real estate ranks ahead of that later interest.7
Class follows principal use, so identical goods can land in different classes. In borderline cases, such as a physician's car or a farmer's truck that might be either consumer goods or equipment, the principal use decides. Goods can also change class over time: a radio is inventory in a dealer's hands and consumer goods in a consumer's.8
Inventory is the one use class that fits a fixture poorly. It covers goods held for sale or lease, goods furnished under a contract of service, and raw materials, work in process, and materials used or consumed in a business, in each case other than farm products.9 Goods in that condition are not normally affixed to real estate while held for sale in the ordinary course of business, so it is difficult to conceive of goods that are both inventory and fixtures.10 The furnace in the warehouse is inventory; the same furnace in a basement has moved to another class.
Mutual exclusivity explains why the overlap is no contradiction. The use classes are mutually exclusive, so the same property cannot be both equipment and inventory.11 Fixture status stands outside that exclusive set, which is why a boiler can be both a fixture and equipment.12 A student who extends exclusivity to fixtures has carried a rule beyond the group it governs. A student who labels the boiler a fixture and stops has left out the use class that Article 9 still assigns.
Crops Are Not Fixtures
Crops resemble fixtures because both are tied to land, and Article 9 resolves the resemblance by putting crops in a different class. Section 9-102(a)(34) defines farm products as goods, other than standing timber, with respect to which the debtor is engaged in a farming operation, and the first category it lists is crops grown, growing, or to be grown.14 The definition reaches crops that are only to be grown, so the class does not wait for a seed to be in the ground.
Two consequences follow. A crop is goods, because the Code's list of goods names crops growing or to be grown as an entry separate from fixtures.15 And the class depends on the debtor. Corn growing in a grower's field is a farm product because the grower is engaged in a farming operation. Grain that a dealer buys to resell is not, because inventory covers goods held for sale that are not farm products.16
The confusion is understandable. A growing crop is part of the real property, so a person with an interest in the land has an interest in the crop.17 Yet the Code treats crops as farm products and not as fixtures, even though they relate to real estate.18 It also treats them as goods and not realty, so creating a security interest in crops requires compliance with Article 9, and crops can serve as Article 9 collateral.19
The classification has consequences beyond the land question. A buyer in ordinary course of business who buys goods from the seller that created the security interest takes them free of the interest, even a perfected one the buyer knows about, but the rule covers goods other than farm products.20 Calling the corn a farm product takes it out of that rule.
A farm-loan question usually puts two items on the same land and asks which one the fixture rules govern.
The annexation factors from earlier in this chapter test the pump, and they do not test the corn at all. Both items sit on the same land, so the land connection settles nothing. What separates them is the kind of goods each is: a crop is a farm product tied to the debtor's farming operation, while the pump is business equipment that real property law may claim as part of the land.
Because crops are not fixtures, the fixture priority rules do not decide a contest between a perfected secured party in growing crops and the owner or mortgagee of the land. Section 9-334(i) is a separate subsection. It gives a perfected security interest in crops growing on real property priority over a conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the real property if the debtor has an interest of record in the real property or is in possession of it.21 A mortgage on the farm therefore sends a crops problem to that subsection, and a student who applies the fixture rules to the corn has chosen the wrong provision.
Accessions Compared
Section 9-102(a)(1) defines an accession as goods physically united with other goods in such a manner that the identity of the original goods is not lost.23 The definition resembles the one for a fixture, which also begins with the word goods and also describes goods joined to something else.24 The two part company over what the goods are joined to. A fixture is joined to real property, so an interest in it arises under real property law. An accession is joined to other goods, so the whole remains a movable thing and no land enters the picture. A student who notices only that something was installed will blur the two, and the question that separates them is what the item was installed in.
The standard examples fall on either side of that question. A new engine installed in a used automobile is an accession, because it is still an identifiable engine and the automobile is still an automobile.25 A furnace affixed to a house or other building is a standard fixture, because the thing it is joined to is real property.26 Each example is a part built into a larger thing, and each part keeps a recognizable identity, so neither fact sorts the examples. The larger thing does: it is other goods in the first and real property in the second.
Article 9 keeps the concepts apart because different claimants compete for an installed item depending on what it was joined to. A claimant to a furnace holds rights through the land, and those rights rest on real property law. A claimant to an engine in a vehicle is typically another creditor or a buyer of the vehicle or its parts, and personal property law governs, including the rule that a buyer in ordinary course of goods other than farm products takes free of a security interest created by its seller.27 Article 9 gives accessions their own provision in § 9-335, apart from the fixture provisions of § 9-334. Section 9-335(a) and (b) parallel § 9-334(a): a security interest may be created in an accession and continues in collateral that becomes an accession, and an interest perfected when the collateral becomes an accession remains perfected.28 The rules that rank conflicts among accession claimants belong to a later reading. For now it is enough to know that the fixture rules developed in this chapter do not govern accessions.
The same caution about thin connections applies on both sides of the line. Easily removable goods installed on other goods, such as tires mounted on the wheels of an automobile, usually are not accessions, just as carpeting tacked to a floor is not a fixture.29 Mounting or tacking creates contact, but the connection falls short of the union the governing definition requires. The identity element marks the opposite boundary. Goods that lose their identity when combined, such as wheat put into a silo with other wheat, are commingled goods and not accessions.30 An accession therefore occupies a middle position: it is united with other goods more firmly than a tire on a wheel, yet it stays distinguishable afterward in a way wheat in a silo does not.
An exam stem tests this contrast by describing an installation and leaving the object of the installation for you to identify. Calling every installed component a fixture is the wrong first move. Ask instead whether the larger thing is land or a building, or is another movable item. If it is another good, the fixture analysis from earlier in this chapter does not apply, and the item is an accession when its identity survives the union. If it is real property, the annexation factors decide whether real property law gives anyone an interest in the item. If the connection is too slight in either setting, as with tires or tacked carpet, the item usually remains plain goods.