Concept
Defining a Fixture
Fixture status and Article 9 coverage
Fixtures Under Article 9
Defining a Fixture
Article 9 defines a fixture in § 9-102(a)(41) as "goods that have become so related to particular real property that an interest in them arises under real property law."1 Two parts run in sequence. The thing must first be goods, and those goods must then bear a relationship to particular land that gives someone an interest in them under real property law. The first part uses Article 9's own vocabulary; the second hands the decision to another body of law.
The first part ties fixtures to the Code's definition of goods, which reaches all things that are movable when a security interest attaches. That definition names fixtures expressly, along with standing timber to be cut and removed under a conveyance or contract for sale, the unborn young of animals, and crops.2 A fixture therefore remains goods.
The second part has no Article 9 content of its own. The definition prescribes no minimum degree of attachment and no method of fastening; it asks only whether an interest in the goods arises under real property law, and real estate law governs whether goods are fixtures.3 The question matters most when claimants fight over priority. The first step is to ask whether real-property claimants have an interest in the goods as part of the real property. If real property law gives them none, no conflict exists and the goods are ordinary goods. If it gives them an interest, a conflict arises and § 9-334 states the priorities.4
One common formulation describes a fixture as personal property attached to land or a building and regarded as an irremovable part of the real property, such as a fireplace built into a home.5 That formulation points in the right direction, but attachment alone settles nothing.6 Personal property attached to realty yet easily removable, such as carpeting tacked to a floor, is not a fixture.7
For purposes of § 9-334, goods fall into three groups. Some remain pure goods. Others are so substantially integrated into the real estate that they become real estate themselves, which makes them pure realty. The third group sits in between: these items would pass with a deed to the real estate yet remain personal property, and they are the fixtures.8 Only that middle group needs the special fixture rules. Article 9 separately provides that no security interest exists in ordinary building materials incorporated into an improvement on land.9
Calling a fixture "part of the real property" can therefore mislead. The middle group would pass with a deed, but it remains personal property, and when goods are fixtures, property rights in them are governed both by real estate law and by the law of personal property.10 That dual status is why a security interest under Article 9 may be created in goods that are fixtures or may continue in goods that become fixtures.11 If real property law would give a building's buyer a financed furnace along with the deed, the furnace is a fixture, and the lender that financed it can still hold an Article 9 security interest in it.