Concept
Working a Priority Problem
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Working a Priority Problem
A priority problem asks you to sort before it asks you to rank. Suppose two lenders claim one machine. The facts do not yet say whether either holds an enforceable interest, what kind of asset the machine is, or whether either lender's filing still counts on the day the contest is decided, and each answer selects a different rule. The default ladder in § 9-322(a) ranks conflicting perfected interests by the earlier of filing or perfection, puts a perfected interest above an unperfected one, and, when no interest is perfected, gives priority to the first to attach.1 This unit arranges the chapter's rules in the order a problem calls for them, then works one problem from start to finish, in which a single fact about one financing statement reverses the outcome.
Setting Up the Problem
Priority is ranked one asset at a time, so the first task is to list each asset the claimants dispute and classify it by type. A creditor can rank first in one asset and last in another, because special priority rules apply to certain types of collateral.2 Equipment and inventory fall under the filing-or-perfection ladder and its purchase-money overrides. A secured party with control of a deposit account under § 9-104, of investment property under § 9-106, or of a letter-of-credit right under § 9-107 outranks a conflicting secured party without control, and in a letter-of-credit right it does so only to the extent of its control.3 Goods covered by a certificate of title fall under § 9-303, which applies even when the jurisdiction whose certificate covers the goods has no other relationship to the goods or the debtor.4
Next, name every claimant to each asset and the kind of claim each one holds. Article 9 supplies a specific rule for each kind of dispute, so a single first-in-time rule cannot resolve them all; you can choose the right rule only after you know the basis of both parties' claims.5 Treat the rules as serial competitions in which one competitor is always a secured creditor and the opponent changes from section to section.6 Section 9-322 decides contests between secured parties; § 9-317(a) decides the contest between a secured party and an execution lien creditor.
A judicial lien creditor gets its lien through legal process, most commonly by winning a judgment and executing on the property. Depending on the jurisdiction, the lien arises when the writ of execution is delivered to the sheriff or when the sheriff levies on the property.7 The moment the lien arises matters because the secured party's status is tested at that moment. In the tools problem below, each bank's interest was attached but unperfected when the execution lien arose, and the lien prevailed. A creditor with neither a security interest nor a lien has no claim on any specific collateral, so even an unperfected secured creditor outranks it unless the Code provides otherwise.8
Test each claimant's security interest for attachment, because a lender whose interest never attached has nothing to rank. In the tools problem, the security agreement carried National Bank's interest to all inventory then owned or later acquired under § 9-203, and the word 'tools' was a sufficient description for State Bank under § 9-108.9 Then ask whether the interest is purchase-money. A lender whose loan paid for the very goods in dispute holds a purchase-money security interest, but the label does not rank the lender by itself. State Bank gave National Bank timely and proper notice, yet its attempt at purchase-money priority under § 9-324(b) came to nothing because it filed in the wrong state and its interest stayed unperfected.10
Perfection supplies the last piece of status: whether each interest is perfected, how, and from what date. Among perfected interests, priority dates from the earlier of the first filing covering the collateral and the first perfection, and the interest keeps that early date only if no later period exists when it was neither filed nor perfected.11 A financing statement can be filed before the interest attaches, so the filing date can precede the perfection date. Status also has a date of its own: an interest perfected on the day of the loan can be unperfected on the day of the contest, so assess each claimant as of the date priority is determined and not only as of the day it lent. A completed status entry reads like this: the bank holds a perfected non-purchase-money security interest in the debtor's equipment, perfected by filing on January 15 and continuously perfected since.12
Ranking the Claimants
With status fixed, select a rule for each pair of claimants and not for the group. Three lenders in one asset produce three pairings, and each pairing is decided on its own terms.14 For each pair, first check whether a rule written for the asset or the claimant displaces the ladder, as purchase-money priority and control do. If none applies, count the perfected interests on the contest date, because the count picks the rung. Two perfected interests rank by critical date. One perfected and one unperfected interest rank for the perfected one, whoever lent first. Two unperfected interests rank by attachment.15
Control, not filing date, ranks the securities account in that scene.16 A result reached under one asset's rule therefore cannot be carried to a second asset, which is why the final ranking is written out asset by asset.
Where a rule turns on timing, and most do, place the events on a time line before ranking anyone. Consider three entries:
- On March 1, Bank 1 begins negotiating with the debtor and files a financing statement. It has lent nothing and is not yet perfected.
- On March 8, Bank 2 signs a security agreement, advances funds, and files. Its interest is perfected that day.
- On March 15, Bank 1 signs a security agreement and advances funds, which perfects its interest.
Bank 2 perfected first, yet Bank 1 has priority. Priority dates from the earlier of filing or perfection, and Bank 1's March 1 filing precedes Bank 2's March 8 date.17 The dates of the advances do not decide the contest. The time an advance is made plays no role in ranking conflicting interests unless no financing statement was filed and the advance supplies the last step toward attachment and perfection, and Bank 1 filed first. Bank 2 therefore takes subject to the advance Bank 1 makes on March 15, even though Bank 2 had already lent.18
Finish by writing the ranking asset by asset and placing every claimant, including those at the bottom. An unperfected secured party whose interest attached outranks an unsecured creditor that holds no lien unless the Code provides otherwise, so it ranks above the general creditors even when it loses to every other claimant.19
The Tools Problem
A problem about a debtor named Ace puts the whole method to work and shows how one fact, whether a financing statement was continued, can reverse the result. Hammer Supply sold tools to Ace, and in Ace's hands the tools are inventory. Two lenders claim them. National Bank holds a security interest in all of Ace's inventory, present and after-acquired, securing its loan and future advances. State Bank lent the money Ace used to pay Hammer Supply for the tools. Priority is determined as of December 1, 2018.21
Status comes first. National Bank's interest attached to the tools when Ace acquired rights in them, and its filed financing statement perfected the interest until the statement lapsed on September 3, 2018.22 State Bank holds a purchase-money security interest because its loan paid for the tools. It sent National Bank timely and proper notice, but it filed its financing statement in Washington when the filing belonged in Idaho, so its interest attached and was never perfected. The correct notice could not cure the misfiling.23 The time line runs as follows:
- When Ace acquires rights in the tools, both interests attach. National Bank is perfected by its filing, and State Bank, having misfiled, is unperfected.
- On September 3, 2018, National Bank's financing statement lapses.
- After the lapse, an execution lien arises on the tools.
- On December 1, 2018, priority is determined.
The contest between the banks comes first. Before the lapse, National Bank was perfected and State Bank was not, so National Bank would have ranked first. The lapse changed that retroactively as to State Bank. A lapsed interest is deemed unperfected as against a purchaser of value, and State Bank, having given value, is one.24 National Bank is thus unperfected as against State Bank, and State Bank was unperfected all along, so the contest falls to the third rung, where the first interest to attach prevails.25 Both interests attached at the same time, when Ace acquired rights in the tools. Article 9 states no priority rule for that situation, and the inference is that the two interests have co-equal priority.26
The execution lien creditor sits outside the secured-party contest, but a complete answer ranks it too. When the lien arose, each bank's interest was attached but unperfected, and no effective financing statement covered the tools, so under § 9-317(a) the execution lien outranks both.27 The full order is the execution lien first, then National Bank and State Bank with co-equal priority.28
Now change one fact. Suppose National Bank had filed a timely continuation statement, so its filing never lapsed, while State Bank still misfiled. National Bank would remain perfected on December 1 and State Bank would remain unperfected, which puts the contest on the second rung. The perfected interest wins whichever attached first, and State Bank's purchase-money status adds nothing, because its interest is unperfected.29
One fact separates the two outcomes. In the lapsed version, State Bank, which never perfected, moves from trailing National Bank to tying it, because the lapse removed the only perfected claimant above it. In the continued version, State Bank ranks behind National Bank. State Bank acts identically in both versions; what changes the answer is whether National Bank's filing survived to the day of the contest. A problem that gives a filing date and says nothing about a continuation is therefore incomplete until you compare the contest date with the date the filing lapses.