Concept
Other Exceptions to First-in-Time
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Other Exceptions to First-in-Time
Section 9-322(f) makes the filing-date ladder give way. Subsections (a) through (e) apply only “subject to” a list of other provisions,1 and the list has four clauses. Clause (1) names subsection (g), which gives effect to the separate statutes that govern the priority of agricultural liens, and the other provisions of Part 3. Clause (2) names § 4-210, on a collecting bank’s security interest in items it handles for collection. Clause (3) names § 5-118, on the security interest of a letter-of-credit issuer or nominated person. Clause (4) names § 9-110, on security interests arising under Article 2 or 2A.2 Because of these cross-references, § 9-322(a) is a default rule: it decides a contest only when none of the listed provisions applies.
The ladder asks a single question: who filed or perfected first, or, if no one perfected, who attached first.3 A claimant that wins on another ground is answering a different question, and a date comparison tests that claimant against the wrong measure. A secured party with control of investment property, a deposit account, or a letter-of-credit right outranks a competitor without control, a ground this chapter covered earlier.4 A bank may hold an item for collection and take a special interest in it. A legislature that creates a lien may fix its rank. In each situation Article 9 lets the provision written for that ground decide, so a ranking reached by the ladder alone stays provisional until you have checked whether a listed provision speaks to the contest.
The listed provisions sit in three places: elsewhere in Part 3 of Article 9, in the other Articles of the Code, and in a state statute outside the Code. The aim here is recognition. When a problem supplies a fact that triggers one of them, you should see that the ladder is not the last word and name the provision that displaces it.
Other Part 3 Overrides
Section 9-322(f)(1) subjects the ladder to “subsection (g) and the other provisions of this part,” so any Part 3 rule that speaks to a contest replaces § 9-322(a) for that contest.5 Part 3 is where Article 9 otherwise sets out the priority rules for security interests.6 This chapter has already covered three groups of them: the double-debtor rule (§ 9-325), the new-debtor rule (§ 9-326), and the control rules for deposit accounts, investment property, and letter-of-credit rights (§§ 9-327 through 9-329).7 Two more show what kinds of facts trigger an override: a flaw in a filing, which can cost the filer its place, and a purchaser’s possession of certain paper, which can beat an earlier filing.
A financing statement can contain errors in the information that § 9-516(b)(5) requires, the debtor’s mailing address among it, and still be sufficient to perfect under § 9-502. The filer stays perfected, but its security interest falls behind a conflicting perfected security interest whose holder gave value in reasonable reliance on the incorrect information.8 Section 9-338 states this rule without regard to the type of collateral.9
The ladder rewards the early filer because the record warns later lenders of its claim. A misleading entry fails to warn the lender who relied on it, and the filer, who prepared the statement, was better placed than the lender to catch the error. Two conditions follow from that logic: the later lender must have given value, and its reliance must have been reasonable.
Reliance carries the result. A lender that never read the address, or that learned from other sources that the filing covered this very debtor, was not misled by the error, and the ladder ranks Bank A ahead of it on A’s March date.10
Section 9-330 protects purchasers of chattel paper, such as an installment sale contract, and of instruments, such as a note. A purchaser, including a secured party, that in good faith takes possession of tangible chattel paper or control of electronic chattel paper in the ordinary course of its business and gives new value has priority over a security interest claimed merely as proceeds of inventory, so long as the paper does not show an assignment to an identified assignee other than the purchaser.11 When the competing interest is claimed other than as merely proceeds of inventory, the purchaser still wins if it lacks knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party’s rights.12 For instruments, a purchaser that gives value, takes possession in good faith, and does not know the purchase violates the secured party’s rights outranks a conflicting security interest perfected by a method other than possession.13 Paper of this kind moves by delivery, and the rule treats the purchaser’s possession or control, together with new value and good faith, as doing the work that the filing date does in the ladder.
Part 3 holds other overrides that this chapter names without developing. A holder in due course of a negotiable instrument takes priority over a security interest in the instrument under § 9-331, even if that security interest is perfected.14 For goods covered by a negotiable document of title, § 9-312(c) places an interest perfected directly in the goods behind one perfected through the document.15 The full conditions for these rules belong to a separate reading on chattel paper, instruments, and negotiable documents. Here you need only recognize that a purchaser’s possession or control, or a holder’s status, can decide a ranking in place of a filing date.
Before ranking two lenders by date, scan the facts for a trigger: wrong information in a filing on which a later lender relied, a purchaser holding paper it paid for, a lender with control, or collateral that came to the debtor already encumbered. If none appears, the ladder governs.
Interests Created Under Articles 2, 4, and 5
Three clauses of § 9-322(f) reach beyond Part 3. Clause (2) refers to § 4-210 for a collecting bank’s security interest, clause (3) to § 5-118 for the security interest of an issuer or nominated person under a letter of credit, and clause (4) to § 9-110 for a security interest arising under Article 2 or 2A.17 Article 9 governs these interests along with agricultural liens and consignments,18 but the ladder yields to the rule that gives each interest its priority.19 Each interest arises inside a particular transaction: an item moving through bank collection, documents presented under a letter of credit, or goods sold but not yet in the buyer’s hands. Its holder often has filed nothing, so a ranking by filing date would measure the holder against a notice it never gave.
A collecting bank handles a check or other item for a customer and usually credits the customer’s account before the item is paid. The bank’s security interest in an item and the documents accompanying it has priority over conflicting perfected security interests.20 The preference fits the bank’s position. While the item is out for collection, the bank has extended credit against a payment the payor may still refuse, and if the customer’s secured lender could take the item first, the bank would carry the risk of nonpayment while the lender collected on credit the bank advanced.
The letter-of-credit provision follows the same pattern. An issuer or nominated person that honors a presentation or gives value for it takes a security interest in the document presented, to the extent of the honor or value given.21 The issuer pays the beneficiary against the documents and then looks to the applicant for reimbursement, so the papers are its practical protection. A lender with a blanket lien on the applicant’s assets could otherwise take them first and collect on funds the issuer advanced. Section 9-322(f) therefore makes the ladder subject to § 5-118 whenever the issuer or nominated person is a claimant.
Section 9-110 covers a security interest that arises under Article 2 or 2A, and the standard case is the seller who sells goods and purports to retain a “security interest.”22 The seller’s protected position lasts only until the buyer gets possession. After that, the seller’s position depends on the conventional rules of attachment and perfection, and a seller that never filed a financing statement is an unperfected secured creditor, and perhaps less.23
After delivery the contest is between a perfected lender and an unperfected seller, and the second rung of the ladder resolves it for the lender.24 The only fact that moved the result between the two stages is the moment of the restaurant owner’s possession.
All three interests arise from a transaction in progress, whether an item in collection, a presentation honored, or goods not yet delivered, and the ladder’s dates ignore that fact. A problem that hands you filing dates invites a ranking by date, so ask first whether one of these transactions appears in the facts. How an item is collected and how a letter of credit is honored belong to Articles 4 and 5, and this chapter needs only the point that Article 9 yields to them.
Agricultural Lien Statutes
Subsection (g) sends a contest to a rule that the Code does not contain. A perfected agricultural lien has priority over a conflicting security interest in or agricultural lien on the same collateral “if the statute creating the agricultural lien so provides.”26 The creating statute can thus preempt the usual Code priority rules.27 Given the importance of agricultural liens in farm operations, state statutes sometimes give them a kind of super-priority.28
An agricultural lien is an interest in farm products, other than a security interest, that secures payment or performance of an obligation for goods or services furnished in connection with the debtor’s farming operation, or rent on real property leased in connection with it.29 A statute must create the lien, in favor of a person that furnishes the goods or services in the ordinary course of business or that leased the land.30 The Code’s answer on rank therefore depends on what that statute says, and the first fact to look for in a problem is a priority sentence in it.
Statute and Code divide the work. Suppose a state statute gives a seed supplier a lien on the crops grown from its seed, the supplier sells on credit without taking an Article 9 security interest, and a bank then lends to the farmer and takes a security interest in the crops. The statute decides whether the supplier’s lien exists and what it covers, while Article 9 supplies the rules for perfecting the lien and ranking it against the bank.31 A lien is perfected when it is effective under the creating statute and a proper financing statement has been filed centrally.32 A supplier whose statute creates a valid lien but who never files therefore holds an unperfected lien.
When the creating statute states no priority, Article 9 ranks the lien by the same ladder it uses for security interests, because each rung of § 9-322(a) names agricultural liens alongside security interests. Perfected liens and perfected security interests rank by the earlier filing or perfection date, a perfected claimant outranks an unperfected one, and among unperfected claimants the first to attach or become effective prevails.33 Subsection (g) is the one point at which a lien statute can lift a lien out of that ladder, and it does so when the statute expressly provides that a perfected lien has priority even if the first-to-file rule would otherwise rank it lower. A statute that creates the lien and says nothing about rank leaves the ordinary rules in place.34 An exam stem that gives a lender the earlier filing and a farm supplier a statutory lien therefore turns on one question: does the lien statute contain a priority sentence?
Two features of subsection (g) deserve attention. First, the priority must come from the statute, which is the legislature’s own answer to how the lien should rank against a lender that financed the crop.35 Second, only a perfected lien qualifies, so the filing system keeps its role even when a statute raises the lien’s rank.36
Even in State A, the landlord’s priority depends on having filed. A landlord who never filed a financing statement holds an unperfected agricultural lien, and subsection (g) reaches only a perfected one. The lien then ranks below a perfected security interest under the second rung of the ladder, and it also loses to a lien creditor.37
A lienholder cannot borrow the purchase-money preference. That preference rewards purchase-money security interests, and an agricultural lien is by definition an interest other than a security interest.38 A supplier that furnished seed on credit and relies on the statute alone ranks by the statute’s priority sentence if it has one and by the ladder if it does not. Except in a few instances, Article 9 ranks agricultural liens as it ranks security interests.39