Concept
The New-Debtor Rule
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
The New-Debtor Rule
A company borrows against its inventory, and its lender files a financing statement under the company's name. The company later merges into another, and the survivor becomes bound by the old loan agreement. Article 9 calls the survivor a new debtor. The lender's filing, indexed under a name that no longer belongs to the debtor, still perfects against collateral the survivor acquires, though only for a limited time. Section 9-326 asks where that lender ranks when another lender deals with the survivor. The lender ranks behind any competitor whose perfection does not depend on the carried-over filing, and the age of the two filings does not change that result.1
The survivor never signed the security agreement, and it need not. Revised Article 9 settles what the former law left uncertain: conventional rules that bind a successor to its predecessor's liabilities also bind it to the predecessor's security agreement, and under § 9-203(e) a successor so bound need not sign a new one.2 The agreement thus reaches the survivor's property without new paperwork, which leaves perfection and rank as the open questions.
The carry-over has limits. When the old and new debtors are in the same jurisdiction, the filing against the old debtor perfects the secured party's interest in collateral the new debtor acquires within four months after it became bound to the agreement.3 When the new debtor is in a different jurisdiction, the old filing likewise stays effective for collateral the new debtor has and acquires within four months after it becomes the new debtor.4 Those details belong to the perfection reading. This section assumes the old filing works and asks only where the old lender ranks.
Rank is the problem because a financing statement says little. It exists to put third parties on notice that the debtor may have given a security interest in the described property.5 A lender weighing a loan to the survivor searches under the survivor's name, and the old lender's statement sits under a different one. The ordinary ladder would still credit the old lender with the earlier of its first filing or first perfection, so long as no gap intervenes,6 and that early date would defeat a lender who searched carefully, found nothing, and lent.
Section 9-325(a) addresses a different problem. When a debtor acquires collateral already subject to a security interest created by another person, and that interest was perfected at the time of acquisition and has never lapsed, the interest the debtor creates ranks behind it.7 In the new-debtor rule, the lender perfected under the old name is the one subordinated.8 The first subsection below ranks an inherited filer against a lender perfected some other way. The second ranks inherited filers against one another.
Inherited Filings Subordinated
Section 9-326(a) puts a lender perfected only by an inherited filing behind a lender perfected some other way. Subject to subsection (b), a security interest created by a new debtor in collateral in which it has or acquires rights, and perfected solely by a filed financing statement that would be ineffective to perfect it but for § 9-316(i)(1) or § 9-508, is subordinate to a security interest in the same collateral perfected other than by such a filed financing statement.9 Call that kind of statement an inherited filing: it names the predecessor and works against the new debtor's collateral only through the carry-over provisions. Every contest under the rule has two sides. One is the predecessor's lender, whose perfection rests on the inherited filing and who is subordinated. The other is any lender whose perfection comes from a different source. The new debtor is a person who becomes bound as debtor by a security agreement that someone else entered into, most often a company that succeeds a predecessor by merger or consolidation.10
SP-1 filed against Old Debtor, which later merged into New Debtor. New Debtor became bound by Old Debtor's security agreement, and SP-1's filing reaches New Debtor's collateral only through the carry-over provisions. SP-2 then took a security interest from New Debtor and filed against New Debtor by name. SP-2's perfection does not depend on the carry-over provisions, so SP-2 ranks ahead of SP-1 in collateral both claim,11 and it makes no difference which of them filed first.12 The instinctive move is to compare the two filing dates under the first rung of § 9-322(a). That move gives the wrong answer whenever SP-1's date is earlier, because the new-debtor rule asks how each lender became perfected before any date counts.13
The rule puts the risk on the party able to avoid it. The predecessor's lender knows its debtor has been replaced and can file an initial financing statement naming the new debtor. Once it does, its perfection no longer rests solely on the inherited filing, and the rule has nothing to subordinate.14 The text of the rule compares no dates. The preferred lender wins because of how it is perfected.
The new debtor is the company that became bound, not the company whose agreement it inherited. Acquire Corp., already financed by Bank A under a perfected interest in its inventory and after-acquired property, buys Target Corp., whose lender Bank T holds a similar interest under a filing that names Target. Acquire becomes bound by Target's security agreement, so Acquire is the new debtor and Bank T's filing is the inherited one. If Bank T has not filed against Acquire, it ranks behind Bank A in collateral Acquire has or acquires.15
The preferred lender need not have filed anything. SP-X holds an interest in X Corp.'s existing and after-acquired inventory, perfected by filing against X Corp. SP-Z holds an interest in an item of Z Corp.'s inventory, perfected by possession. Z Corp. then becomes bound by X Corp.'s security agreement, for example by buying X Corp.'s assets and assuming the agreement.16 SP-X is perfected in that item solely through the inherited filing, and SP-Z is perfected by possession, so SP-Z ranks first.17
Two edges remain. A competitor that never perfected gains nothing from the rule, and the inherited filing still counts as perfection against it, because a perfected interest outranks an unperfected one.18 And when both lenders rest on inherited filings, neither is the preferred side, so subsection (b) supplies the ranking.
Ranking Inherited Filings
When every competing lender rests on an inherited filing, subsection (a) has no preferred side, and § 9-326(b) supplies the ranking. The other provisions of Part 3 determine priority among conflicting security interests in the same collateral perfected by those filings. But if the security agreements to which the new debtor became bound were not entered into by the same original debtor, the conflicting security interests rank according to priority in time of the new debtor's having become bound.20 Everything turns on one fact: whether the competing agreements trace to one original debtor or to several.
When both agreements came from one original debtor, both financing statements were filed against that same person, so their dates are entries in a single record. The earlier entry shows which lender first put the world on notice of a claim to that person's collateral, and the successor's arrival does not disturb the comparison. The ordinary Part 3 rules, including the first-to-file-or-perfect ladder, therefore decide the contest as they would have decided it against the original debtor. When the agreements came from different original debtors, the dates sit in two records indexed under two names. A 2016 filing against one company and a 2018 filing against another do not show which lender's claim reached the new debtor's property first, and neither was made under the new debtor's name. What the two lenders share is the moment the new debtor became bound by each agreement. Ranking by that moment orders the lenders by when each burden reached the new debtor.
The result runs against the order of the filing dates, which is why a student who reaches for the ladder of § 9-322(a) goes wrong here. Comparing a filing against Alder with a filing against Birch asks the dates to measure something they do not measure.21
The number of original debtors behind the agreements separates the two scenes. Ember was bound by both of Dune's agreements, so each filing is an entry in Dune's record and the two dates compare directly. Cedar was bound by agreements from two different companies, and that is the only reason the time of becoming bound replaces the filing dates. The yardstick is the same whether the old filing carries over under § 9-508 or under § 9-316(i)(1).
Subsection (b) reaches only contests in which every competing lender rests solely on an inherited filing. Once both lenders have a source of perfection beyond an inherited filing, neither falls within § 9-326(a), and the ordinary ladder governs. A lender perfected some other way outranks an inherited filer under subsection (a).22 The first screen on any new-debtor problem is therefore how each lender became perfected. Only then does the number of original debtors choose between the ordinary rules and the time of becoming bound.