Concept
New Debtor Rule
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
New Debtor Rule
A successor can step into a predecessor's security agreement, and when it does, the predecessor's lender may stay perfected through a financing statement that names someone else. Section 9-326(a) ranks that lender below any competing lender whose perfection comes from another source, however the filing dates compare.1
Article 9 calls the successor a new debtor: a person who becomes bound under § 9-203(d) by a security agreement previously entered into by another person. Most often it is a company that succeeds a debtor by merger or consolidation, and one commentator suspects the cases the rule governs are of microscopic insignificance.2 Sections 9-203(d) and (e) generally make the predecessor's security agreement effective against the successor, so the predecessor's lender can claim the successor's collateral without a new agreement.3
The predecessor's perfection raises a separate problem. A financing statement against the predecessor would, standing alone, be ineffective against the successor's collateral, and two provisions rescue it: § 9-508 and § 9-316(i)(1).4 In the standard illustration, § 9-508 makes Old Bank's statement against Adams effective as to a new item of inventory in which Baker, the successor, has rights.5 Section 9-316 concerns a change in the law governing perfection; the 1999 revision made such changes rarer, chiefly because they follow a debtor's move, but did not eliminate them.6 This chapter calls a filing that works against the new debtor only through one of these provisions a borrowed filing.
Bank stays perfected, yet the second lender's search discloses nothing. Ranking Bank by the date of that filing would let Bank defeat a careful searcher who had no way to learn of its claim. Section 9-326(a) prevents that result by placing the borrowed filing below perfection of any other kind, and the next subsection shows how the placement works.
Subordination of Borrowed Filings
Section 9-326(a) involves two claimants. The subordinated claimant is the predecessor's lender: its interest reaches the successor's collateral because the successor became bound by the old agreement, and its perfection rests solely on a borrowed filing. The preferred claimant is any lender whose interest in the same collateral is perfected by something other than such a filing, such as a financing statement filed against the new debtor by name or possession of the collateral.7 The rule is stated subject to subsection (b), and a later part of this chapter ranks competing inherited filings against one another.
The standard illustration shows the preferred claimant winning without any comparison of dates. Old Bank holds a perfected-by-filing security interest in all of Adams's existing and after-acquired inventory, and New Bank holds one in all of Baker's. Baker acquires Adams's business and assumes Adams's debt to Old Bank, which makes Baker a new debtor, and then acquires a new item of inventory. Old Bank's statement against Adams reaches that item only through § 9-508, so Old Bank is perfected solely by a borrowed filing, while New Bank filed against Baker by name. New Bank has priority, and it does not matter whether New Bank filed before or after Old Bank.8 A student who compares the two filing dates under the first rung of § 9-322(a) asks the wrong question, because the new-debtor rule asks first how each lender came to be perfected.9
The same two banks appeared in the previous section's double-debtor contest, but there New Bank loses and here it wins, because the competing interest reaches the collateral by a different route. In the double-debtor case, Baker buys equipment already burdened by Old Bank's perfected interest and takes it subject to that interest, so the lien travels with the collateral, and Old Bank usually has priority.10 In the new-debtor case, the inventory never belonged to Adams; a rescue provision stretches a filing against Adams over property Baker owns.11 A lender who searches under Baker's name sees nothing of Old Bank, and the rule resolves that gap in the record against Old Bank.
The preferred claimant need not have filed at all. A lender to the successor who holds an item of the successor's inventory is perfected by possession, which is not a borrowed filing, so it outranks a predecessor's lender who relies on one.12 Nor is the rule confined to goods: § 9-326(a) speaks of collateral without qualification, so it reaches purely intangible collateral, meaning intangibles not evidenced by an indispensable writing, such as accounts and general intangibles.13
The hypothetical marks the edge of the rule. Subordination runs only to a competitor perfected other than by a borrowed filing, so an unperfected competitor is ranked under the ordinary ladder, where a perfected interest, even one perfected by a borrowed filing, outranks an unperfected one.14
The predecessor's lender can also remove itself from the rule. If Old Bank files an initial financing statement against Baker by name, it is no longer perfected solely by the borrowed filing, § 9-326(a) does not subordinate it, and the contest returns to the ordinary ladder, which first compares the times of filing or perfection.15 Like any filer, Old Bank needs the debtor's authority to file an authenticated record, and a lender may seek that authority before the loan terms are final in order to be first to file.16
Limits on Subordination
The double-debtor rule of the previous section has its own limit, and the two rules are easy to confuse because the same two banks appear in both. Under § 9-325(a), a security interest the transferee creates is subordinate to the transferor's lender's interest when the transferee acquired the collateral subject to that interest, the interest was perfected at the acquisition, and no later period of unperfection followed.18 The transferor's lender therefore usually wins, and the exceptions, found in subsection (b), arise only in unusual situations.19
Subsection (b) permits subordination of a transferee's lender only if that lender's interest otherwise would have priority solely under § 9-322(a) or § 9-324, or arose solely under § 2-711(3) or § 2A-508(5).20 The first route governs nearly every problem, and it calls for a counterfactual: without § 9-325, what would put the transferee's lender ahead? If the answer is the first-to-file-or-perfect ladder or the purchase-money rule of § 9-324, subsection (a) steps in and reverses the result. If the answer is some other rule, there is no misleading date comparison to correct, and the other rule governs.
Subordination corrects one specific distortion. The ladder and the purchase-money rule rank lenders by when they filed or perfected against the debtor in front of them, and in the double-debtor setting that comparison misleads, because a filing against the transferee says nothing about collateral that reached the transferee already burdened. The rationale is practical: the transferee's lender could have investigated the source of the equipment and found the transferor's lender's filing before advancing money, whereas the transferor's lender had no reason to search filings against anyone but its own debtor.21 In the illustration, SP-A holds a perfected interest in equipment owned by A, who sells it to B outside the ordinary course of business. B takes subject to SP-A's interest and grants SP-B a security interest. SP-B is subordinate even if it filed against B before SP-A filed against A, and even if its interest is purchase-money.22 An earlier filing and purchase-money status are the two advantages SP-B could claim, and subsection (b)(1) names both as sources of priority that leave SP-B inside the rule.
A lender whose priority comes from control never depended on a date comparison. A secured party with control of a deposit account outranks one without control; the same is true for investment property; and a secured party with control of a letter-of-credit right outranks one without control to the extent of its control.23 Because that priority arises from control rather than from the ladder or the purchase-money rule, nothing remains for subsection (a) to correct, and the lender with control keeps its rank.
The word solely does additional work in subsection (b)(1). A transferee's lender with a second source of priority, beyond the ladder or the purchase-money rule, is not a lender whose priority is solely of the subordinated kind. The same reasoning applies to deposit accounts and letter-of-credit rights, where control likewise ranks one secured party ahead of another that lacks it.
The second route in subsection (b) is narrow. It covers a security interest that arises solely under § 2-711(3) or § 2A-508(5), the Article 2 and 2A provisions giving a rejecting buyer or lessee a security interest in the goods. A rejecting buyer or lessee whose interest has some other source falls outside the clause.24
Students often stop once they have spotted the transferee's lender, but that label only says who is in the contest. The limit asks why the lender would win without § 9-325. If the answer is an earlier filing or perfection date, or a purchase-money interest, the lender is subordinated, provided the transferor's lender meets the three conditions of subsection (a). If the answer is control, the lender keeps its priority. Subsection (b) thus screens the source of the transferee's lender's priority, while the conditions of subsection (a) test the transferor's lender's position.