Concept
Double Debtor Rule
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Double Debtor Rule
Collateral sometimes changes hands while it is still encumbered, and its new owner may then pledge it to a second lender. Section 9-325 supplies the priority rule for that contest.1
Subsection (a) states the rule in three conditions. Unless subsection (b) provides otherwise, a security interest created by a debtor is subordinate to a security interest in the same collateral created by another person when all three are true:
- the debtor acquired the collateral subject to the security interest the other person created;
- that security interest was perfected when the debtor acquired the collateral; and
- no period afterward left that security interest unperfected.2
Two labels keep the cast straight. The transferor is the debtor who created the first security interest and then passed the collateral along. The transferee is the person who received the collateral and granted the second interest. Suppose Adams owns equipment subject to a security interest in favor of Old Bank. Adams sells the equipment to Baker, who takes it subject to Old Bank's interest, and Baker then grants a security interest in the same equipment to New Bank. Old Bank is the transferor's lender and New Bank is the transferee's lender. Article 9 usually gives priority to Old Bank, so long as Old Bank's interest was perfected when Baker acquired the equipment and stayed perfected afterward.3
Each condition is a separate fact to verify. The first asks whether the collateral arrived encumbered: Baker took the equipment subject to Old Bank's interest and did not take it free of that interest. The second fixes the moment of testing. Old Bank had to be perfected on the day Baker acquired the equipment, so a lender that perfects only after the transfer does not qualify. The third demands continuity. If Old Bank's perfection lapses at any point after the acquisition, subsection (a) no longer subordinates New Bank, and the contest goes to the other priority rules.
The general rule would point the other way. Under § 9-322(a)(1), conflicting perfected security interests rank by the earlier of the time a filing covering the collateral is first made or the interest is first perfected, and New Bank's 2019 filing covers Baker's after-acquired equipment.4 The date comparison misleads here because Baker never owned an unencumbered press for New Bank's early filing to reach. He acquired a press already burdened by a perfected interest, and § 9-325 subordinates the transferee's lender in just that situation.
Subsection (b) carves out exceptions to the rule, but the commentary describes them as applying only in unusual situations.5 On an exam, ask before comparing filing dates whether the debtor got the collateral from someone who had already encumbered it. If so, test the three conditions first, because the first lender's priority may depend on them and not on any filing date.