Concept
Exceptions to the General Rules
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Exceptions to the General Rules
The filing-date ladder of § 9-322(a) is a default, and the section says so twice. Subsection (a) opens with the words "except as otherwise provided in this section,"1 and subsection (f) makes the rules of subsections (a) through (e) subject to a list of other provisions.2 The list reaches subsection (g), on agricultural liens, and the other priority provisions of Part 3 of Article 9. It adds three provisions from outside Part 3: § 4-210, on a collecting bank's security interest; § 5-118, on the security interest of a letter-of-credit issuer or nominated person; and § 9-110, on security interests that arise under Article 2 or 2A.3
The ladder needs these exceptions because it ranks claimants by when they gave notice to the world. Perfected interests rank by the earlier of filing or perfection.4 The date of a later advance does not change that rank. Priority as to each advance relates back to the original filing, and a secured party takes subject to every advance secured by a competing interest that has priority under § 9-322(a)(1).5 An early filer therefore carries its date into everything it later finances. A claimant who should win for another reason cannot win on filing dates alone. It may have paid for the collateral, handled the item for collection, or hold a lien that a statute created. Article 9 gives each of these claimants a rule of its own.
Control of investment property supplies one such rule: a secured party with control outranks one without it, whatever the filing dates.6 Priority by control has its own section later in this chapter. The rest of this unit takes up purchase-money priority, the provisions of other Articles, the agricultural lien statutes, and the ranking of competing purchase-money interests. Before ranking any claimants by date, check whether the collateral or a claimant brings one of these rules into play.
Purchase-Money and Other Overrides
Section 9-322(f)(1) makes the ladder subject to subsection (g) and to the other provisions of Part 3, so the filing-date rules decide a contest between secured parties only when no more specific provision covers it.7 The provision that matters most in practice rewards the lender whose money or credit put the collateral in the debtor's hands. A security interest is the lender's right to take the property described in the security agreement if the loan is not repaid.8 A purchase-money security interest (PMSI) is one held by the seller to secure the price, or by a third-party lender whose loan paid for the goods.9
Without an override, the ladder would favor the lender who contributed nothing. Suppose a bank filed against all of the debtor's present and after-acquired equipment. Its date then outranks every later claimant in each machine the debtor buys afterward, including the seller or lender that financed that very machine. The PMSI rule reverses that result for the financer of the acquisition.
For goods other than inventory, such as equipment, the PMSI wins if it is perfected when the debtor receives possession of the goods or within 20 days afterward.10 The clock runs from the debtor's possession, not from the date of the sale or of the security agreement. The PMSI holder need not have been without notice or knowledge of the earlier interest. It prevails even though it knew of the earlier filing.11
The window is short enough to miss. Had V filed on April 10, twenty-six days after delivery, it would still hold a security interest but would lose the override. The contest would then go to the ladder, where S1's February filing prevails.13
Inventory receives stricter treatment. A PMSI in inventory prevails over a conflicting security interest in the same inventory only if the holder meets conditions beyond timely perfection.14
- The PMSI is perfected by the time the debtor receives possession of the inventory, with no 20-day grace period.
- The PMSI holder sends an authenticated notification to each holder of a conflicting security interest who filed earlier against the same inventory.
- Each recipient receives the notification within the five years before the debtor receives possession.15
- The notification states that the sender has or expects to acquire a PMSI in the debtor's inventory and describes the inventory.
The notice protects the earlier inventory lender. That lender examines the inventory in regular floor checks, and without notice it could treat everything it sees as its own collateral, unaware that another creditor financed some of it.16 The rule for other goods asks only for timely perfection.17
Change the dates and the result changes. If V files on June 5, ten days before a June 15 delivery, and S receives V's notice within the five years before June 15, V outranks S. Without that notice, S prevails.19 A consignor who delivers goods to a debtor for sale must meet the same conditions, because the consignor's interest in the consigned goods is by statute a PMSI in inventory.20
Part 3 holds other rules that sit beside purchase-money priority and that this unit does not develop. Section 9-323 governs later advances when a lien creditor or buyer arrives after a perfected interest, and in rare cases such a claimant can beat the secured party as to some of those advances.21 The certificate-of-title provisions send questions of perfection and priority in titled goods to the law of the jurisdiction whose certificate covers them.22
Because § 9-322(a) is residual, its label of first to file or perfect can mislead.
One explanation is that V perfected first. The better explanation is that V holds a PMSI perfected within 20 days of the debtor's possession, and the fact that perfection came automatically is irrelevant. The second explanation is the more accurate because § 9-322(a) applies only when no other priority rule covers the problem.23 The shortcut names the right winner here, but it would get the equipment hypothetical wrong, where V filed after S1 and still prevailed.
Priority Under Other Articles
Clauses (2) through (4) of § 9-322(f) send three kinds of contest outside the ladder: § 4-210 governs a collecting bank's security interest, § 5-118 governs the security interest of an issuer or nominated person, and § 9-110 governs a security interest arising under Article 2 or 2A.25 These holders acquire their interests through the transaction itself, usually without any filing. A ranking by filing date would put them behind any lender who filed against the debtor earlier, even though they gave the value that put the item or goods where they are.
A bank that handles an item for collection obtains a security interest in the item and its accompanying documents, and that interest has priority over conflicting perfected security interests.26 A secured lender who filed against the customer first therefore cannot reach the item ahead of the bank.
Section 5-118, added by the 1999 Code, gives an issuer of a letter of credit a security interest in a document presented under the letter, to the extent the issuer honors or gives value for the presentation.27 Section 9-322(f)(3) gives that provision effect over the ladder.28
Section 9-110 covers interests that arise under Article 2 or 2A, such as a seller's interest in goods it ships under reservation of title. By hypothesis, the debtor never has possession of the collateral in these cases, or has already sold it in the ordinary course. Such interests are therefore unlikely to prejudice third parties, even though there is no security agreement and no financing statement.29 Section 9-110 builds on that premise. Until the debtor obtains possession, the interest is enforceable and perfected without the usual agreement or filing, and it has priority over a conflicting security interest the debtor created.30
The outcome turns on one fact, the moment the buyer takes possession. While the goods sat with the carrier, the lender's earlier filing counted for nothing against the seller. After delivery the seller holds an ordinary interest that must be perfected like any other. A seller that retained title also holds a purchase-money interest, so it can still prevail by perfecting within 20 days after delivery, but then the purchase-money rule decides the contest and § 9-110 does not.32
Students err in two directions here. One ranks the in-transit seller by filing dates and picks the earlier-filed lender. The other applies the in-transit priority after delivery and picks the seller. Both skip the same question: does the debtor yet have possession? Once the debtor does, the contest returns to § 9-322(a) and the three rungs of the ladder.
Agricultural Lien Statutes
Section 9-322(g) is the one override whose answer lies outside the Code. A perfected agricultural lien has priority over a conflicting security interest in or agricultural lien on the same collateral "if the statute creating the agricultural lien so provides."34 Subsection (g) gives preemptive effect to the separate statute that governs the lien's priority,35 so the statute that creates the lien can displace the usual Code rules.36
An agricultural lien is an interest in farm products, other than a security interest, that secures payment for goods or services furnished in connection with the debtor's farming operation, or rent on land the debtor leased for farming. A statute creates it in favor of a supplier or landlord, and its effectiveness does not depend on the holder's possession of the property.37 Article 9 governs perfection: the lien is perfected when it is effective under the statute and a proper financing statement has been filed centrally.38 The perfection rules for liens and security interests are identical, and except in a few instances Article 9 treats lienholders like secured parties when it ranks them.39
Those instances are the exceptions, so the ladder ordinarily ranks the lien. Perfected liens and perfected security interests rank by the earlier of filing or perfection, a perfected claimant outranks an unperfected one, and among unperfected claimants the first to attach or become effective prevails.40 Only the lien statute can lift a lien out of that scheme. If the statute states no priority rule, the normal Article 9 rules apply.41 Given the importance of these liens in farm operations, state statutes sometimes give them a kind of super-priority.42 Silence in the statute is no decision about rank, and a lender who searches the records may assume the ordinary ladder governs.
An exam stem will often describe the lien and omit the priority sentence, and the omission decides the case. Suppose the statute creates the supplier's lien but says nothing about its rank. The supplier's May filing is later than the bank's March filing, so the ladder's first rung decides the contest and the bank prevails.43 The supplier ranks as a security interest filed on the same date would.
A statute that grants priority in the strongest terms still does nothing for a lienholder that never perfected.
Subsection (g) reaches only a perfected agricultural lien, so the unperfected lien receives no special priority and the perfected bank ranks first. Had the veterinarian filed, the lien would on those terms outrank the bank.44 The statute decides who wins, but Article 9 keeps control of how perfection is achieved.
Competing Purchase-Money Interests
A single acquisition can be financed twice. A bank lends the down payment and the seller finances the balance, and each ends up with a PMSI in the same goods. If both qualify for priority over an earlier blanket lender, the purchase-money rules cannot rank them against each other, because each is a conflicting security interest from the other's side. Section 9-324(g) breaks the deadlock. The seller's PMSI has priority over a PMSI held by a third-party lender, and otherwise the first-to-file-or-perfect rule of § 9-322(a) applies.46
Filing dates would be a poor tiebreaker between the first two claimants, since each has already met the same timing requirement. The statute looks to role instead. The seller supplied the goods themselves and is owed their price, while the other lender supplied money toward that price.
The bank's earlier filing does not help it, because the seller-first rule ranks the two by their roles and never compares the filing dates.
Neither bank is the seller, so the seller-first rule has nothing to apply to, and the ordinary comparison governs. Each lender is credited with the earlier of its first filing and its first perfection,47 and Bank A ranks first. Bank B's larger share of the price does not change the order.
This rule matters only when both claimants qualify for the purchase-money preference. A seller that perfects after the 20-day window has no override to bring. A bank whose interest does qualify then prevails under the ordinary purchase-money rule, and the seller is ranked under § 9-322(a).48 In inventory financing, each claimant must also have met the stricter conditions of perfection at possession and notice to earlier filers before the question of seller status arises.