Concept
Proceeds and Supporting Obligations
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Proceeds and Supporting Obligations
Collateral seldom stays in the form the secured party took it. Inventory is sold and becomes an account, the account is collected and becomes cash, and the cash buys equipment. A guaranty may stand behind an account the lender financed. Each change raises a ranking question: which date does the lender bring to the contest over the new asset? Section 9-322(b) answers that question for two assets. Proceeds are whatever the debtor receives when the collateral is sold or otherwise disposed of. A supporting obligation is a secondary promise, such as a guaranty or a letter-of-credit right, that backs payment or performance of the collateral.
Subsection (b) opens with the words “for the purposes of subsection (a)(1),” which confine both of its clauses to the date comparison taught under First to File or Perfect.1 Within that comparison, the time of filing or perfection as to collateral is also the time as to a security interest in its proceeds,2 and the time as to collateral supported by a supporting obligation is also the time as to the supporting obligation.3 What travels is a date: the earlier of the first filing and the first perfection, provided no period follows when there is neither.4 Priority is ranked one asset at a time, so proceeds and backing are new assets with contests of their own, and subsection (b) tells the lender which date to bring to each.
The carry-forward exists because a lender that finances inventory expects the goods to be sold; the sales are how it will be repaid. If its rank reset each time the collateral changed form, it would lose its position on the very event the financing contemplated, and a competitor that filed against the resulting accounts at a later date could take first position in value that came from the first lender's own collateral. Carrying the date forward lets rank follow the value. The supporting-obligation clause applies the same reasoning: a lender who relied on an account relied on the guaranty behind it, so its rank in the guaranty tracks its rank in the account.
This unit takes proceeds first, then supporting obligations, and then the separate carry-over in subsection (c) for priorities that a lender has won through control and similar steps.
Priority Date for Proceeds
Section 9-322(b)(1) tells a lender to bring to a contest over proceeds the same date it earned as to the original collateral.5 Proceeds are whatever the debtor acquires on a sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of the collateral.6 When a debtor sells inventory on credit, the resulting account is proceeds of the inventory, as would be the cash, check, chattel paper, or instrument taken in the same sale, and the lender's security interest attaches to any identifiable proceeds.7
The rule does its most frequent work between an inventory lender and an accounts lender. Once the credit sale occurs, both reach the same account: the inventory lender as proceeds of its collateral, the accounts lender as original collateral. The inventory lender brings the date it filed or perfected against the inventory, not the date the account came into being.
Attachment cannot separate the two, because the accounts lender's interest attaches to the new account as original collateral at the same moment the inventory lender's interest attaches to it as proceeds. The contest therefore turns on filing or perfection dates. If the inventory lender's date in the account ran only from the sale, any accounts lender that had filed before the sale would outrank it, however long the inventory lender's own filing had been on the record, and rank would hinge on when the debtor happened to sell. The carry-forward removes that accident. It is also fair to the accounts lender, because a search under the debtor's name finds the inventory filing, and a lender weighing a loan against accounts can infer that the earlier filer probably claims what the inventory becomes.8
The two scenes use the same lenders and the same credit sale. The result changes because S1's filing falls after S2's in the second. The rule rewards the earlier of a lender's filing date and perfection date, not the earlier loan, so S1's February 1 attachment gives it nothing against a lender that filed first.9
The carried date is conditional. Subsection (a)(1) honors a priority date only if no later period exists with neither filing nor perfection.10 Continuous perfection in the proceeds is therefore what keeps the inventory date alive, and a break leaves the lender to date its priority from the later time it files or perfects as to the proceeds.11 A security interest in proceeds is perfected if the security interest in the original collateral was perfected, but that perfection ends on the 21st day after the interest attaches to the proceeds unless one of three conditions is met:12
- The original collateral is covered by a filed financing statement, the proceeds are collateral in which a security interest may be perfected by filing in the same office, and the proceeds were not acquired with cash proceeds.
- The proceeds are identifiable cash proceeds.
- The secured party perfects its security interest in the proceeds by some other method when the interest attaches to the proceeds or within 20 days afterward.
Accounts produced by an inventory sale satisfy the first condition, because accounts and inventory are perfected by filing in the same office and the account was not bought with cash proceeds. A bank that filed against inventory on January 15 therefore stays perfected in an account created by a March 10 credit sale, and its January 15 date governs there. Identifiable cash proceeds satisfy the second condition for as long as they stay identifiable. The good news is that the lender is indefinitely perfected in them; the bad news is that money and checks are seldom long in the hands of a troubled debtor.13 The chain most often breaks for goods bought with cash proceeds, because the same-office rule does not help there. If the debtor spends identifiable cash from an inventory sale on a machine, the machine is proceeds of proceeds, and the lender must file a financing statement describing equipment or the machine, or take possession of it, to keep its interest perfected.14
Two instincts mislead students here. One dates the inventory lender's claim from the sale, which treats the account as an unrelated asset and ignores the carried date. The other awards the account to the accounts lender because the account is its original collateral, although the first scene shows an inventory lender prevailing as a claimant to proceeds. A mechanical method avoids both: write down each lender's filing or perfection date as to its own original collateral, confirm that each interest in the proceeds stayed continuously perfected, and compare the dates.
This date rule supplies only the general answer. A purchase-money lender can win priority in certain proceeds under rules of its own, and where no such rule gives it priority, priority in proceeds returns to first-to-file-or-perfect with the carried dates.15 Those overrides belong to the exceptions later in this chapter, so the contests above assume that no purchase-money rule applies.
Date for Supporting Obligations
Section 9-322(b)(2) gives supporting obligations the same treatment as proceeds: the time of filing or perfection as to collateral supported by a supporting obligation is also the time as to the supporting obligation.17 The lender in question holds an interest in the supported right, such as an account. The clause tells it which date to bring when someone else claims the backing: the date it earned as to the right itself, whether that came from a filing or from perfection by another method.18
The date follows the payment right because a supporting obligation has no function apart from the right it backs. A guaranty exists to make an account more likely to be paid, and a lender that finances the account lends in reliance on the guaranty. The guaranty is nonetheless a separate asset with a contest of its own. If the account lender had to compute its date in the guaranty from scratch, a creditor that took an interest in the guaranty alone could outrank the lender whose collateral the guaranty protects, simply by putting its claim on the record first. The clause prevents that by giving the account lender the same position in the backing that it holds in the account. Like the proceeds clause, it works only inside the date comparison of the first rung, and the carried date holds only if no later period exists with neither filing nor perfection.19 Perfection in the supporting obligation is governed by other rules, so the example below assumes that each interest is perfected and has not lapsed.
The outcome turns on the date Bank A earned as to the account, because that is the only date Bank A brings to the guaranty. Had Bank A filed against accounts on April 1, after Bank B's March 1 filing, its date as to the account would be April 1, that later date would also be its date as to the guaranty, and Bank B would prevail. Bank B's position is the same in both versions: its March 1 date comes from its own filing, and it holds nothing in the account that could lend it another date. A competitor with an interest in the backing alone therefore competes on its own filing or perfection date, while the account lender competes on the date it earned as to the payment right.
Students often compare only the filings made against general intangibles, which leaves the account lender with no date in the guaranty and hands the win to the guaranty-only lender without justification. The opposite mistake is to assume that the account lender always wins in the backing, because the carried date is only as good as the lender's own date in the account, and a late filer against accounts carries a late date. The method is the one used for proceeds: identify the lender's filing or perfection date as to the supported collateral, confirm that the chain was unbroken, and compare that date with the competitor's date in the guaranty or other backing.
Special Priority Reaching Proceeds
Section 9-322(c) takes a priority that a lender has already won under one of the special rules and carries it beyond the original collateral. Except as subsection (f) provides, a security interest in collateral that qualifies for priority over a conflicting security interest under § 9-327, 9-328, 9-329, 9-330, or 9-331 also has priority over a conflicting security interest in any supporting obligation for the collateral and in the collateral's proceeds, if the conditions below are met.21 Those sections govern collateral such as deposit accounts, investment property, letter-of-credit rights, chattel paper, instruments, and negotiable documents of title.22 They reward steps such as control rather than an early filing date: for investment property, a secured party with control outranks one without.23 A win of that kind has no filing date to carry forward, so a separate provision must say whether it survives when the collateral changes form.
The need for that provision shows up in the ordinary course of business. A lender with control of the debtor's securities account outranks a competitor that merely filed, but the debtor is expected to sell the securities eventually. If the lender's priority stopped at the securities, the competitor could claim the sale price at the moment of sale, and the lender would lose its win on the very event the arrangement anticipated. Subsection (c) prevents that. Its conditions answer the opposite danger. If the priority followed every asset the debtor later bought with the money, a rule earned by control of one kind of asset would spread into assets on which other lenders relied on the filing system. The conditions therefore confine the carry-over to proceeds that are perfected and are either cash or like the original collateral.
Supporting obligations are the simpler case. Under subsection (c)(1), a security interest with special priority in the collateral also has priority in any supporting obligation for that collateral, such as a guaranty backing it.24 The text lists no further conditions, and the reasoning matches the date rule: a supporting obligation exists only to make the collateral more likely to be paid, so the lender with priority in the collateral should hold the same position in the backing. The difference from the date rule is that what travels here is a won priority, and a specific rule written for the type of supporting obligation involved can displace it.
Proceeds must satisfy three conditions, and subsection (c)(2) requires all of them. The security interest in the proceeds must be perfected. The proceeds must be cash proceeds or of the same type as the collateral. And when the proceeds are themselves proceeds of proceeds, every intervening proceed must be cash proceeds, proceeds of the same type as the collateral, or an account relating to the collateral.25 Whether perfection in proceeds continues depends on the rules discussed under the date for proceeds, including the 21-day limit. The chain condition prevents a single weak link from being forgiven because the last link looks acceptable.
The same lender can win at one stage of the debtor's dealings and lose at the next.
The chain condition catches a different pattern. Suppose the debtor had spent the cash on inventory and later sold the inventory for cash. The last link is cash and looks acceptable. But the inventory in the middle was neither cash, nor investment property, nor an account relating to the collateral, so the chain broke there and Bank's special priority ended at the inventory.
Subsection (c) begins with the words “except as otherwise provided in subsection (f),” and those words matter because a rule written for a particular type of asset overrides the general carry-over.26 If the proceeds are a deposit account and a secured party has control of it, the deposit-account priority rules of § 9-327 decide the contest in that account.27 A lender whose control extended only to the original securities account therefore cannot rely on subsection (c) against another lender that has control of the deposit account into which the debtor pays the sale price. The override reaches supporting obligations too: a letter-of-credit right that backs the collateral is ranked under § 9-329, not under subsection (c)(1).28