Concept
Priority Basics
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Priority Among Secured Parties
Priority Basics
Priority ranks competing property claims against one specific asset of the debtor. When two secured parties claim the same collateral, Article 9 starts from a simple ordering: conflicting perfected security interests rank according to priority in time of filing or perfection.1 The next section develops that rule. This one explains what a ranking is worth, what it assumes, and why no single rule can supply every ranking.
A ranking matters because collateral does not always cover every claim against it. Rank decides who is paid first, and each creditor wants the highest position it can get, since a high position raises the odds that the creditor will realize value from the asset.2 Suppose SP-1 holds a first-priority claim of $5,000 in the debtor's equipment and SP-2 holds a second-priority claim of $2,000 in the same item. If the equipment sells for $10,000, SP-1 collects $5,000, SP-2 collects $2,000, and the debtor receives the $3,000 excess.3 If it sells for only $5,500, SP-1 still collects its full $5,000 first, and SP-2 receives the remaining $500 in partial satisfaction. SP-2's unpaid $1,500 is a deficiency, which it must try to collect from the debtor through other means.4 Nothing reaches the lower-ranked creditor until the higher-ranked creditor is paid in full, so the lower rank absorbs the loss whenever the collateral falls short.
Article 9 ranks claims by a version of first-in-time, subject to many exceptions and refinements.5 Legal systems disagree about when a property interest is attached enough to the asset to count in a first-in-time contest, and some count it only after public notice of the interest has been given.6 Article 9's filing system rests on a similar theory: a lender who searches the files under the debtor's name before it lends can learn of the security interests the debtor has already granted.7 Priority dates from the earlier of the first filing covering the collateral or the first perfection of the security interest, provided there is never a later period with neither filing nor perfection.8
Priority is worked one asset at a time. The question to ask is where this creditor stands in this particular asset, because a creditor can hold first priority in one asset and second priority in another. Some rules also depend on the type of asset, so that the rules for goods are not the rules for instruments and chattel paper.9
The right rule also depends on who the competing claimant is. For each priority dispute there is a specific rule, so the first task is to identify carefully the basis of both parties' claims, and a single first-in-time, first-in-right rule will not resolve every contest.10 Article 9 can be read as a series of contests in which one competitor is a secured creditor and the other changes. Section 9-317 covers a secured creditor against a lien creditor, as well as against buyers and lessees, and § 9-322 covers a secured creditor against other secured creditors.11 When three creditors claim one asset, there are three contests, and each may call for a different rule.12
A contest with a lien creditor shows how a change of opponent changes the analysis. On Monday SP-1 funds a loan, and its security interest attaches to Debtor's securities account at Brokerage Inc. On Tuesday a lien creditor levies on the account to execute a judgment against Debtor. On Wednesday SP-1 files a financing statement. SP-1 loses to the lien creditor, because its interest was attached but unperfected when the levy occurred.13 The same result would follow against a trustee in bankruptcy, who is treated as having a judicial lien on all of the bankrupt's assets on the date the petition is filed.14 The § 9-317 rule decides this contest, and the § 9-322 ladder plays no part in it. Had another secured party perfected on Thursday, SP-1's Wednesday filing would have ranked it ahead.15
Every priority rule assumes two earlier steps. Attachment comes first, because a secured party whose interest has not attached has no specific property claim in the debtor's asset and therefore nothing to rank.16 Perfection then usually decides the result. A perfected creditor defeats most claimants whose claims arose after its perfection, while an unperfected creditor loses to a lien creditor and to a secured creditor whose interest attached later but who perfected first.17 The final section of this chapter assembles these inputs into a repeatable method for working a problem.
This chapter's main subject is the contest between two secured parties. Section 9-322 supplies the general rules for that contest.18 Special rules then cover three situations. The first is collateral the debtor acquired already subject to another person's perfected security interest, where the debtor's own grant is subordinate if that interest stays perfected.19 The second is a new debtor whose security interest is perfected only by a filing that would be ineffective but for special continuation rules, where that interest is subordinate to one perfected by other means.20 The third is deposit accounts, investment property, and letter-of-credit rights, where a secured party with control generally outranks one without control.21 The lien creditor contest appears here only to show how the identity of the opponent changes the rule.